Best deal on ebay ever?? Puckett First Pitch Preview for $7

clarkfan · Sep 13, 2011

I didn't see it until it hit completed listings, so I wasn't the winner, but a HUGE score for the collector that did

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=330607315239

ThoseBackPages · Sep 13, 2011

:shock: :shock: :shock:

MojoDan · Sep 13, 2011

Approx how much did the seller leave on the table with that one?

WoundedDuck · Sep 13, 2011

MojoDan said:
Approx how much did the seller leave on the table with that one?

We'll probably find out when it gets relisted

jszczech · Sep 13, 2011

All I can say is wow.

JEA2880 · Sep 13, 2011

Someone needs to provide some context, I don't know what these cards are

clarkfan · Sep 13, 2011

JEA2880 said:
Someone needs to provide some context, I don't know what these cards are

Just a very rare parallel of the 1996 Aficionado Series (1st 100 cards), only available as a Web Issued Redemption (at the time time Internet wasn't that big). Some player collector's have never seen their particular player (Vizquel, Juan Gonzalez) and others have paid $200 to $400 for their player, even the lesser name players usually bring $10 to $25. Puckett is probably one of the top players in the set, so seller left a good chunk of money on the table. Even on a bad day, the Puckett is probably worth $150. A Griffey sold for $350 a year or two ago. Deals are out there though. McGwire sold recently for less than $40. I'm just jealous of the buyer that won. I would have loved to score a deal like that.

jacksoncoupage · Sep 13, 2011

The guy who won it is a huge Puckett/Error/Promo/Oddball collector. Nice guy and total sharpshooter with rare stuff, I have no idea how he does it!

He's also one of the guys who found the uncut sheets of 1990 Upper Deck Mike Witt cards!

n1astrosfn · Sep 13, 2011

last two went for 255 and 247.50 :shock:

Hendersonfan · Sep 14, 2011

I think I've seen 2 Henderson's ever and they were upwards of $150 if I remember correctly.

autocut · Sep 14, 2011

That's still trumped by the guy who sold a 2001 Donruss Signature Nolan Ryan Significant Signatures Auto SP for $5. BV: $250. Flipped it for about $140.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/180689640672

Russ S. · Sep 14, 2011

jacksoncoupage said:
The guy who won it is a huge Puckett/Error/Promo/Oddball collector. Nice guy and total sharpshooter with rare stuff, I have no idea how he does it!

He's also one of the guys who found the uncut sheets of 1990 Upper Deck Mike Witt cards!

GOOD for him!!

I'd rather see an actual PLAYER collector snag that beauty then someone (buying oddball/rare 90's *****) just wanting to scoop it up to gang-rape the real player collectors in need!

George_Calfas · Sep 14, 2011

Russ S. said:
jacksoncoupage said:

The guy who won it is a huge Puckett/Error/Promo/Oddball collector. Nice guy and total sharpshooter with rare stuff, I have no idea how he does it!

He's also one of the guys who found the uncut sheets of 1990 Upper Deck Mike Witt cards!

Click to expand...

GOOD for him!!

I'd rather see an actual PLAYER collector snag that beauty then someone (buying oddball/rare 90's *****) just wanting to scoop it up to gang-rape the real player collectors in need!

Russ, what fun is that. You should scoop up cards and offer them on ebay for a bagillion times over value, then at some point the ebay market will catch up top your price.

BTW, a member here inquired about this card about 6-months ago and offered $150 for one.

boomo · Sep 14, 2011

there really are people who must hit refresh as a business 14-18 hrs a day.
ive tried it for 30 minutes and got sick of it. But it works for some people.

jszczech · Sep 14, 2011

I would have no problem paying $150 for one.

wolters03 · Sep 14, 2011

autocut said:
That's still trumped by the guy who sold a 2001 Donruss Signature Nolan Ryan Significant Signatures Auto SP for $5. BV: $250. Flipped it for about $140.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/180689640672

How exactly does that trump this??? This guy won the Puckett for $7 and if he does flip it will bring in around $250. Not sure how a profit of $135 is better than a profit of $240?!

autocut · Sep 14, 2011

wolters03 said:
autocut said:

That's still trumped by the guy who sold a 2001 Donruss Signature Nolan Ryan Significant Signatures Auto SP for $5. BV: $250. Flipped it for about $140.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/180689640672

Click to expand...

How exactly does that trump this??? This guy won the Puckett for $7 and if he does flip it will bring in around $250. Not sure how a profit of $135 is better than a profit of $240?!

we'll see "if" he flips it.

RustyGreerFan · Sep 14, 2011

Russ S. said:
jacksoncoupage said:

The guy who won it is a huge Puckett/Error/Promo/Oddball collector. Nice guy and total sharpshooter with rare stuff, I have no idea how he does it!

He's also one of the guys who found the uncut sheets of 1990 Upper Deck Mike Witt cards!

Click to expand...

GOOD for him!!

I'd rather see an actual PLAYER collector snag that beauty then someone (buying oddball/rare 90's *****) just wanting to scoop it up to gang-rape the real player collectors in need!

As a rare 90's ***** myself, I would have scooped it up to flip in a heartbeat. I gotta sell cards to buy more! If it sells, I'm not sure how that's a gang rape, or any other kind of rape - especially if it's an auction.

clarkfan · Sep 14, 2011

RustyGreerFan said:
Russ S. said:

jacksoncoupage said:

The guy who won it is a huge Puckett/Error/Promo/Oddball collector. Nice guy and total sharpshooter with rare stuff, I have no idea how he does it!

He's also one of the guys who found the uncut sheets of 1990 Upper Deck Mike Witt cards!

Click to expand...

GOOD for him!!

I'd rather see an actual PLAYER collector snag that beauty then someone (buying oddball/rare 90's *****) just wanting to scoop it up to gang-rape the real player collectors in need!

Click to expand...

As a rare 90's ***** myself, I would have scooped it up to flip in a heartbeat. I gotta sell cards to buy more! If it sells, I'm not sure how that's a gang rape, or any other kind of rape - especially if it's an auction.

Agreed 100%. Anyone who would have seen that listing and didn't buy it, is foolish. Collecting Will Clark is very expensive and anything I can do to offset the price of Clark cards is bonus. I choose to invest in superstars rather than prospecting and it usually pays off. Passing on a $7 Puckett First Pitch Preview is just nuts, but I'm sure it was only on ebay a few minutes before it got picked up, so I would have had no chance at it.

homerun28aa · Sep 14, 2011

I know two or three guys who would probably fight each other for this card....even at 200 bucks. One of the great eBay steals for sure.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Best deal on ebay ever?? Puckett First Pitch Preview for $7

Active member

New member

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

New member

Active member

Member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Similar threads

Log in