Would you still collect your PC player if they were traded to another team?

ASTROBURN · Nov 15, 2012

I prefer "Franchise Players". I have always collected Bagwell, and if he had gone to another team, well thankfully that never happened and I never had to choose. But I also side collected Biggio, Berkman, Oswalt, and others... But once they left, so did my interest in their cards (except Biggio). But it made it simple then. Just Bagwell now.

Zambrano38 · Nov 15, 2012

Yes depending on how long I have been collecting them. After around 3 years, I like the player too much to stop collecting them.

21ccl · Nov 15, 2012

Yes i would because there the same players just on different teams. I also bet that [MENTION=3743]55_marlins_sp[/MENTION] would never ever ever give up his Josh Johnson collection .

If he did, the world going to end!

RAZOR-Z · Nov 15, 2012

10 different 11 total - LOVE the variety

shayscards79 · Nov 15, 2012

I give up when a player leaves a team. I only pc Colts players... so as an example, Peyton Manning left... I'm done buying Manning, even if the card is in a Colts uniform.

BiggioBrooks755 · Nov 15, 2012

Great stories guys and gals

I love the player but also love the team

csmtampa · Nov 15, 2012

I'm a Rays fan and collect BJ Upton. Now that Upton is leaving I'm not sure If I will pick up his future releases. It might depend on where he ends up. I will however keep collecting the cards I need of him in the current Rays uniform.

Big Mac McGwire · Nov 15, 2012

I did in 97. i'll be doing it again this year.

ONLY EXCEPTION IS IF THE NEW TEAM IS THE YANKEES

joey12508 · Nov 15, 2012

metallicalex777 said:
There are quite a few collectors that collect a player on only a certain team. Look at Ken Griffey Jr. for example. His Mariners uniform cards tend to sell higher than his Reds and (obviously) White Sox cards.

As for me with Felix Hernandez, if/when he ever moves on I would continue to collect him but only in Mariners uniform (hometown)...I would most likely go after a few multi player stuff though depending on who is on it.

jbmm161 · Nov 15, 2012

I will more than likely stop collecting Josh Hamilton as a Ranger fan I predominantly collected his Ranger autos, but also have a good amount of Rays and Reds cards. I will sell those first and keep a few of my nicer Ranger cards. I also collect other Rangers but not as heavily. May start collecting Profar (have a BC Blue and 3 BGS 9.5 Refractor Autos sold some while the selling was good) and Gallo BC Autos to take his place. The hard part of being a Ranger fan the last few years is you knew Hamilton was going to command more money than Texas wants to pay and you never know which prospect was going to be dealt during the season.
I have sold off former Rangers and Cowboys in the past.

This is also the reason I diversified what and how I collect prospects and BC PSA autos that way I'm not attached if they get hot or tank. Also got rid of most of my football SP authentic autos because most of them I overpaid for do to player injuries this year.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Would you still collect your PC player if they were traded to another team?

ASTROBURN

Active member

Zambrano38

New member

21ccl

New member

RAZOR-Z

Member

shayscards79

New member

BiggioBrooks755

New member

csmtampa

New member

Big Mac McGwire

New member

joey12508

Well-known member

jbmm161

Active member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts