WCTYSON
Well-known member
- Nov 3, 2014
- 7,364
- 171
Ok, Lets go with what they actually did. Mays wins in hr, rbi, hits,runs, avg. The only one that is close is avg. So how do you have mantle as the better hitter?
For the matter of fairness, most of those numbers are greater because Mays had more PA's and AB's. Mantle had a better OBP but they have the same SLG. I give, the better all around player, Mays the edge because he was faster and better defensively while having other very similar rates with Mantle with the bat in their hands.