Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

The 2014 Alphanumeric Mystery Baseball Challenge: Starting Pitchers

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

cjedmonton

Well-known member
Sep 20, 2009
1,891
316
Great White North
Let's get started with learning how to decode and score your starting pitchers.

As a reminder, each contestant must score their own franchise. Once you get the hang of deciphering your codes, this is a very easy (and hopefully fun) game to play. However, no one will do it for you. Participation is required if you want a chance to win!

Deciphering Your Codes

1st Code

The 1st code you entered refers to a corresponding cell in a 10x10 grid.

In that grid are 100 numbers, each referring to one of the top 100 winningest pitchers in major league history.

Simply cross reference the first code you provided to find your player.


Example:

You chose F8 as your 1st code for starting pitcher #1 . If you look at the starting pitcher grid, F8 refers to 71.

71 means you are looking for the pitcher with the 71st highest career win total.

This pitcher is Joe Niekro.

NOTE: If your number is not shown, that means your player is tied with others. Simply count down to the spot where your player's rank should be.

Example: If you drew 69, you won't find that number in the all-time win list on MLB.com. That's because there's a 3 way tie for 67th place. Simply go back to 67 (Hooks Dauss) and go down two players to get to 69 (Mel Harder). Make sense? This method will be used anytime you have a player tied with others.


2nd Code

The 2nd code refers to a corresponding cell in a 26x15 grid.

In that grid are 390 codes, each referring to 1 of 15 different pitching categories and 1 of 26 seasons during that player's career you will use to score that player.

Simply cross reference the 2nd code you provided to get your stat/season code.

Your stat/season code is broken down as follows:

- The letter refers to the statistical category you will use to score that player's line. See the scoring chart.
- The number refers to the player's season you will use to score that player's line.


Example:

You have Joe Niekro.

You chose R12 as your 2nd code for him. If you look at the stat/season grid, R12 refers to M4.

M4 means you are looking for statistical category "M" during Niekro's 4th season.

NOTE: If your season number is greater than the length of that player's career, simply continue counting from Year 1 until you get to your number. In Niekro's case, suppose you had a season number of 24. In this case, you would count through his 22 year career once and then continue back at the top to his 2nd year to get to 24.


Scoring

Once you decode your player, stat category, and season, you're ready to score their line.

Simply look at the scoring chart and multiply their actual total for that stat category for the season in question by the value assigned, depending on whether or not they are a Hall of Famer.

If you need to confirm if a player is a Hall of Famer, go here:

Hall of Famers | Baseball Hall of Fame

Let's take the Niekro example from the top.

You selected F8, R12

F8 = 71 = Joe Niekro

R12 = M4 = Earned Runs Allowed in Year 4

He had 96 earned runs allowed in Year 4 (1970).

Niekro is not a Hall of Famer.

The scoring chart shows -5 for each earned run allowed by a non-Hall of Famer.

96 x -5 = -480

If Niekro was a Hall of Famer, his score would've been 96 x -2.5 = -240.

Add up all 5 starting pitcher scores and post it in this thread.


Trade Deadline

After your outfielders have been decoded and scored, you will be involved in a trade with one of your fellow franchise owners. Up to 3 positions will be swapped straight up with that owner. Details to follow shortly.


Bonus Scoring

This will apply to your entire franchise and will be introduced at the very end of the contest.


I will keep this thread open until Wednesday before moving on to the next part of your franchise.

A similar thread will be introduced for the remaining sections.

Contestants are encouraged to spot check each other's posted total.

If you have any questions, be sure to ask! Once you score a couple of lines, you'll see how easy this is to play.

Good luck!


The Field

Grids + Scoring Chart

Top 100
 
Last edited:

Y4NK335

New member
Aug 7, 2008
3,130
0
TBD
Wow first one up already! Time to check it out.

By the way, I filled in my C earlier this evening via edit but forgot to notify you, if that is acceptable I would appreciate it.

Thanks,
 

oiccup41

Member
Aug 27, 2010
707
3
Maine
I'm an idiot. Can I get a random for Starting Pitcher 5? I selected L2 which doesn't fit in the chart. Thanks!
 

MrMet

Well-known member
Apr 6, 2010
13,556
612
The Poconos
Oh god I'm already confused, haha, I'm sure it'll make more sense looking on a computer rather than mobile
 

cjedmonton

Well-known member
Sep 20, 2009
1,891
316
Great White North
Don't worry! Plenty of time to check this out on a computer. It really is an easy game to play, I promise. Just gotta get the hang of deciphering your codes.
 

Y4NK335

New member
Aug 7, 2008
3,130
0
TBD
Starting Pitcher
Code One
SP1: A1 - 5 - Warren Spahn
SP2: B2 - 86 - Chief Bender
SP3: C3 - 69 - Mel Harder
SP4: D4 - 15 - Don Sutton
SP5: E5 - 43 - Jack Morris




Code Two
SP1: A1 - J4 - HR allowed - 19 (HOF)
SP2: B2 - J8 - HR allowed - 1 (HOF)
SP3: C3 - N18 - Complete Games - 2
SP4: D4 - L10 - ERA >< 4 - 2.87 (1.13 lower than 4)
SP5: E5 - K18 - Hits Allowed - 163


Scoring:
SP1: 19 x -5 = -95
SP2: 1 x -5 = -5
SP3: 2 x 10 = 20
SP4: 2.87 < 4; 113 x 4 = 452
SP5: 163 x -3 = -480


Total: -108


Not the best start but definitely could have been worse!
 

cjedmonton

Well-known member
Sep 20, 2009
1,891
316
Great White North
Starting Pitcher
Code One
SP1: A1 - 5 - Warren Spahn
SP2: B2 - 86 - Chief Bender
SP3: C3 - 69 - Mel Harder
SP4: D4 - 15 - Don Sutton
SP5: E5 - 43 - Jack Morris




Code Two
SP1: A1 - J4 - HR allowed - 19 (HOF)
SP2: B2 - J8 - HR allowed - 1 (HOF)
SP3: C3 - N18 - Complete Games - 2
SP4: D4 - L10 - ERA >< 4 - 2.87 (1.13 lower than 4)
SP5: E5 - K18 - Hits Allowed - 163


Scoring:
SP1: 19 x -5 = -95
SP2: 1 x -5 = -5
SP3: 2 x 10 = 20
SP4: 2.87 < 4; 113 x 4 = 452
SP5: 163 x -3 = -480


Total: -108


Not the best start but definitely could have been worse!

That was fast! You know exactly what you're doing.

Unfortunately, Morris' score is -489 (163 * -3). Your overall score is -117 so far.

Anything can happen, so you are by no means out of it.
 

oiccup41

Member
Aug 27, 2010
707
3
Maine
If I did it correctly very good start.

Starting Pitcher 1: D7,R4 88 Bobo Newsome IP2/7 275IP=550
Starting Pitcher 2:B1,X9 6 Jim Galvin HOF SHO100/10 3 SHO=300
Starting Pitcher 3:J4,J9 21 Tom Glavine HOF W30/19 13 wins=390
Starting Pitcher 4:A9,T6 1 Cy Young HOF W30/26 34 wins=1020
Starting Pitcher 5 D2,T3 81 Jim Perry CG10/21 7CG=70

Total = 2330
 

Y4NK335

New member
Aug 7, 2008
3,130
0
TBD
That was fast! You know exactly what you're doing.

Unfortunately, Morris' score is -489 (163 * -3). Your overall score is -117 so far.

Anything can happen, so you are by no means out of it.

:lol: opps, thanks for the catch. This is what i get for doing the entire thing on my iPad.
 

cjedmonton

Well-known member
Sep 20, 2009
1,891
316
Great White North
If I did it correctly very good start.

Starting Pitcher 1: D7,R4 88 Bobo Newsome IP2/7 275IP=550
Starting Pitcher 2:B1,X9 6 Jim Galvin HOF SHO100/10 6 SHO=600
Starting Pitcher 3:J4,J9 21 Tom Glavine HOF W30/19 13 wins=390
Starting Pitcher 4:A9,T6 1 Cy Young HOF W30/26 34 wins=1020
Starting Pitcher 5 D2,T3 81 Jim Perry CG10/21 7CG=70

Total = 2630

Even better than you thought! Galvin actually had 6 shutouts during his 10th year.

I'm only spot checking these early ones because I have time. I'm counting on the 12 of you to periodically check each other's work. Otherwise, we're on the honor system.

Thanks again.
 

Gwynn545

Well-known member
Aug 29, 2008
5,526
44
North Seattle
Starting Pitcher #1 : A7, T5: 77th, Losses, 6th: F. Fitzsimmons-7 losses= -105
Starting Pitcher #2 : C2, L7: 61st, Win %, 1st: S. Jones- 0%= -1000
Starting Pitcher #3 : B9, G2: 37th, Hits All., 16th: E. Rixey- 317 hits= -475.5 (HOF)
Starting Pitcher #4 : I4,J4: 83rd, Walks, 15th: J. Perry-55 Walks=-275
Starting Pitcher #5 : H10,X1: 75th, Shutouts 12th:B. Caruthers-2 SHO=100

Total: -1755.5
 

clarkzac

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2010
9,836
1,099
I hope I did this right-
SP 1: I7, E2 --> (8, I3) --> Greg Maddux, Innings Pitched, 3rd season, 249*4(HOF)= 996
SP 2: A8,J4--> (12, D15)--> John Clarkson, Walks Allowed, 15th season (3rd season), 97*-2.5 (HOF) = -242.5
SP 3: H5, J2--> (23, H14)--> Lefty Grove, Losses, 14th Season, 4*-7.5(HOF) = -30
SP 4: D9, Z11--> (95, O19)--> Milt Pappas, Batting Average Against, 19th Season (2nd season), .262 BAA, 12*-5 = -60
SP 5: E10, X1--> (92, F12)--> Vida Blue, Shutouts, 12th season, 3*50= 150

Total = 813.5

Thank you Greg Maddux for being elected to the HOF and for being a workhorse :lol: I would also like to thank Lefty Grove for only losing 4 games in his 14th season
 

metallicalex777

Super Moderator
Aug 7, 2008
13,904
117
Seattle, Wa
Code One
SP1: F3 = 89 – Billy Pierce
SP2: C7 = 3 – Grover Alexander (HOF)
SP3: E10 = 92 –Vida Blue
SP4: B5 = 36 – Bob Feller (HOF)
SP5: H2 = 40 – Ted Lyons (HOF)

Code Two
SP1: H4 = L4 – 3.98 ERA (< 4.00)
SP2: Q6 = C17 – 1.12 WHIP ( < 1.25)
SP3: Y14 = F8 – 6 Shutouts
SP4: T13 = E25 – 59 Strikeouts
SP5: V9 = F16 -1 Shutout

Scoring:
SP1: 4 - 3.98 = .02 x 100 = 2 x 2 = 4
SP2: 1.25 - 1.12 = .13 x 100 = 13 x 20 = 260
SP3: 6 x 50 = 300
SP4: 59 x 6 = 354
SP5: 1 x 100 = 100

Total: 1018

EDIT: [MENTION=3744]cjedmonton[/MENTION] - I forget how tricky the greater/less than scoring was but I think it is correct now.
 
Last edited:

wildcat4

New member
Aug 7, 2008
652
0
Southern Illinois
Question on the Starting Pitching scoring chart... Is the Win Pct. >.500 scoring correct? I would have thought that having a winning percentage over .500 would give you positive points, not negative points.
I ask because I have a pitcher that went 19-9 for a .679 Win Pct., which is really good. But according to the scoring chart he would receive negative numbers for having a great year.
 

Gwynn545

Well-known member
Aug 29, 2008
5,526
44
North Seattle
Question on the Starting Pitching scoring chart... Is the Win Pct. >.500 scoring correct? I would have thought that having a winning percentage over .500 would give you positive points, not negative points.
I ask because I have a pitcher that went 19-9 for a .679 Win Pct., which is really good. But according to the scoring chart he would receive negative numbers for having a great year.

Looks like 2 points for every 1/1000th above .500 for regular player, 4 points for HOFers.
 

marhjan

New member
Aug 2, 2010
248
0
A4, C13 Randy Johnson G23 - 0 Saves = 0pts
B9, D2 Eppa Rixey F6 - 4 Shutouts (HOF) = 400pts
B6, E4 Andy Pettitte G11 - 0 Saves = 0pts
C8, S7 Charlie Hough M24 - 97 Earned Runs = -485pts
A2, T12 Jim McCormick H19 - 11 Losses = -165pts

Total pts (400-650) = -250pts

Getting Saves for Randy Johnson and Andy Pettitte was kind of boring - thank god for Eppa Rixey's 4 Shutouts in 1917 lol.
 

Members online

Latest posts

Top