Is Bryce Harper overrated and just a semi-star and NOT a mega-star as we thought?

JEBJJA · Aug 16, 2013

First of all I like the kid, he's been a role model so this isn't being negative. Is Bryce Harper overrated and just a semi-star and NOT a mega-star as we thought? His stats are way below expectations. His desire is there. His hustle is there. But did fatigue set in from all these different derby's, contests, year round baseball he did from the time he was a little kid? What about the pressure of being that #1 prospect label since he was 16? I haven't been impressed so far over the course of his career like I have been with Trout. What do you guys think? Overhyped? Fatigued? Overmatched?

rsmath · Aug 16, 2013

I would think the two things against him now are "young and stupid" and injured. If he can stay healthy and mature a few years, I think he can be a top-tier ballplayer in the game.

cgilmo · Aug 16, 2013

He's a mega star

These things take time and he's way ahead of the game.

sheetskout · Aug 16, 2013

He's 20....c'mon.

muskiesfan · Aug 16, 2013

sheetskout said:
He's 20....c'mon.

My thoughts exactly.

Regardless, I do believe he was over-hyped at the very least. Overrated? Probably some there as well too. If he stays healthy, I believe he will have a very bright future and be a superstar for years to come.

I like the kid and I hope he has a very successful MLB career. The hype was way too much though. On this board, a lot of that was to try and help people sell their stuff at even more of a premium. In general, media outlets are always on the search for the next big thing they can force down our throats.

Had Bryce been given the luxury that most people get of being drafted, working his way up, and being "just" a player on a big league team, I don't think anyone would have any complaints. When he was in high school and being touted as the next Mantle, next Griffey, and even the next better than Mantle and Griffey, that was just too much hype for anyone to realistically attain.

Lars · Aug 16, 2013

Looks like he kills himself to prove that he can be a dominant jack hole on a baseball field - the key is staying healthy - it seems like Trout does things effortlessly and clean while Harper is a brute force.

Everything little thing Harper does is overrated, but he is 20 and people are enamored by youth and potential.

However, the Mormon he is, Harper would probably say some unsavory things if you said that playing too much baseball is going to turn him into some mediocre disappointment rather the superstar he can be.

thefatguy · Aug 16, 2013

The list is like this

Mike Trout

Bryce Harper

alwayson22 · Aug 16, 2013

Bryce Harper will be a mega-star.

sebpoo · Aug 16, 2013

Kind of sophomore jinx for him and a down year for the entire Nats batting lineup, things should get fixed next year.

bmc398 · Aug 16, 2013

The kid has the personality and following to be a mega star even without the Mega Star stats. I think he has all the potential in the world, but at 20 he's still got plenty to learn about the pro game.

I think the biggest adjustment from high school - college - MiLB - MLB is the length of the season. You go from playing 30-40 games a season to 50-60 to 90-120 games very quickly. And then you make the final jump and now are expected to be on all day, every day for basically 32 straight weeks playing almost every day....thats a huge adjustment for anybody to make.

WaxPax · Aug 16, 2013

Considering most kids his age (20) are just sniffing High A if they are "Can't Miss" prospects....too early to tell

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Freedom Card Board mobile app

WoundedDuck · Aug 16, 2013

Lars said:
However, the Mormon he is, Harper would probably say some unsavory things if you said that playing too much baseball is going to turn him into some mediocre disappointment rather the superstar he can be.

I'm confused as to what being Mormon has to do with this.

All The Hype · Aug 16, 2013

He probably has the best chance of any player 25 or younger to hit 500 homers in his career. He will be a mega star.

Topnotchsy · Aug 16, 2013

WoundedDuck said:
I'm confused as to what being Mormon has to do with this.

It sounds like he saying that Mormons don't believe the road to success comes from sitting on the couch doing nothing

.

elmalo · Aug 16, 2013

Way too early to tell. Not sure that he can ever live up to the hype.

gracecollector · Aug 16, 2013

I typically reserve "mega star" for players who have actually accomplished some impressive long-term stats. Guys like Trout and Harper flame out all the time, never having reached superstar status. Book is out on superstar status until after 4 seasons in baseball, in my opinion.

George_Calfas · Aug 16, 2013

I have to laugh at the age comments
-Signed Mike Trout

TBTwinsFan · Aug 16, 2013

Pretty much every "can't miss kid" is over-hyped.

That being said, dude is still young.

stricklcp · Aug 16, 2013

Like a few earlier posts, I agree, that it's waaaaaayyyyyy too early to tell. I think he's still getting adjusted and fatigue has nothing to do with at as athletes at this level "should" be conditioned to weather a long season. Only time will tell if he's as legit as the media reports him to be! And since I hold a few of his SP cards......I wish him well!!!

chompsmcgee · Aug 16, 2013

elmalo said:
Way too early to tell. Not sure that he can ever live up to the hype.

They used to say that about Lebron

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Is Bryce Harper overrated and just a semi-star and NOT a mega-star as we thought?

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

Member

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Featured Contributor, The best players in history?

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

Member

New member

Similar threads

Log in