Law/Prospectus/BA Composite Top Prospect Rankings

I took all three lists, Keith Laws, Baseball Prospectus, and Baseball America and combined them into one document and took the average ranking of the three lists. If a player did not appear on a list I did not count it against them as there were a couple players like Yu Darvish and Cespedes who only appeared on one list (BA) because they have different criteria. If a player is tied with another I organized them by the number of lists they were on (from 3-1) and their lowest position on any one given list. In some cases there were ties.

Rank Player Position Team
1 Bryce Harper OF Nationals
2 Matt Moore LHP Rays
3 Mike Trout OF Angels
4 Yu Darvish RHP Rangers
5 Jurickson Profar SS Rangers
6 Jesus Montero C Mariners
7 Manny Machado SS Orioles
8 Shelby Miller RHP Cardinals
9 Dylan Bundy RHP Orioles
10 Julio Teheran RHP Braves
11 Gerrit Cole RHP Pirates
12 Travis D'Arnaud C Blue Jays
13 Trevor Bauer RHP Diamondbacks
14 Yoenis Cespedes OF A's
15 Jameson Taillon RHP Pirates
16 Devin Mesoraco C Reds
17 Miguel Sano 3B Twins
18 Taijuan Walker RHP Mariners
19 Tyler Skaggs LHP Diamondbacks
20 Wil Myers OF Royals
21 Anthony Rendon 3B Nationals
T-22 Bubba Starling OF Royals
T-22 Jacob Turner RHP Tigers
24 Carlos Martinez RHP Cardinals
25 Archie Bradley RHP Diamondbacks
26 Manny Banuelos LHP Yankees
27 Danny Hultzen LHP Mariners
28 Martin Perez LHP Rangers
29 Nolan Arenado 3B Rockies
30 Francisco Lindor SS Indians
31 Zack Wheeler RHP Mets
32 Jarrod Parker RHP Athletics
33 Drew Pomeranz LHP Rockies
34 Mike Montgomery LHP Royals
35 Arodys Vizcaino RHP Braves
36 Matt Harvey RHP Mets
37 Hak-Ju Lee SS Rays
38 Christian Yelich OF Marlins
39 Gary Brown OF Giants
40 Drew Hutchison RHP Blue Jays
41 Luis Heredia RHP Pirates
42 Billy Hamilton SS Reds
43 Brandon Jacobs OF Red Sox
44 Rymer Liriano OF Padres
45 Jake Marisnick OF Blue Jays
46 Oscar Taveras OF Cardinals
47 A.J. Cole RHP Athletics
48 Brad Peacock RHP Athletics
49 Xander Bogaerts SS Red Sox
50 Jonathan Singleton 1B Astros
51 Nick Castellanos 3B Tigers
52 Yasmani Grandal C Padres
53 Anthony Rizzo 1B Cubs
54 Will Middlebrooks 3B Red Sox
55 Robbie Erlin LHP Padres
56 James Paxton LHP Mariners
57 Daniel Corcino RHP Reds
58 Mike Olt 3B Rangers
59 Brett Jackson OF Cubs
60 Anthony Gose OF Blue Jays
61 Jean Segura SS Angels
62 George Springer OF Astros
63 Josh Bell OF Pirates
64 Zach Lee RHP Dodgers
65 Gary Sanchez C Yankees
66 Jarred Cosart RHP Astros
67 Randall Delgado RHP Braves
68 Casey Kelly RHP Padres
69 Jake Odorizzi RHP Royals
70 Wily Peralta RHP Brewers
71 Yonder Alonso 1B Padres
72 Taylor Jungmann RHP Brewers
73 Matt Szczur OF Cubs
74 Michael Choice OF Athletics
75 Trevor May RHP Phillies
76 Starling Marte OF Pirates
77 Nick Franklin SS Mariners
78 Cory Spangenberg 2B Padres
79 Eddie Rosario OF Twins
80 Matt Adams 1B Cardinals
81 Dellin Betances RHP Yankees
82 Cheslor Cuthbert 3B Royals
83 Sonny Gray RHP Athletics
84 Jed Bradley LHP Brewers
85 Joe Ross RHP Padres
86 Daniel Norris LHP Blue Jays
87 Mason Williams OF Yankees
T-88 Wilin Rosario C Rockies
T-88 Javier Baez SS Cubs
90 Joe Wieland RHP Padres
91 Jonathan Schoop INF Orioles
92 Zack Cozart SS Reds
93 Chris Archer RHP Rays
94 Garrett Richards RHP Angels
95 Zack Cox 3B Cardinals
96 Allen Webster RHP Dodgers
97 Leonys Martin OF Rangers
T-98 Aaron Hicks OF Twins
T-98 Jose Fernandez RHP Marlins
100 Robbie Grossman OF Pirates
101 John Hellweg RHP Angels
102 Addison Reed RHP White Sox
103 Jedd Gyorko 3B Padres
104 John Lamb LHP Royals
105 Tyrell Jenkins RHP Blue Jays
T-106 Enny Romero LHP Rays
T-106 Jessie Biddle LHP Phillies
108 Oswaldo Arcia OF Twins
109 Chad Bettis RHP Rockies
110 Blake Swihart C Red Sox
111 Mikie Mahtook OF Rays
112 Nate Eovaldi RHP Dodgers
113 Neil Ramirez RHP Rangers
114 Taylor Guerrieri RHP Rays
115 Jeurys Familia RHP Mets
116 Matt Davidson 3B Diamondbacks
117 Kolten Wong 2B Cardinals
118 Matt Purke LHP Nationals
T-119 Jordan Swagerty RHP Cardinals
T-119 Andrelton Simmons SS Braves
121 Noah Syndergaard RHP Blue Jays
T-122 Christian Bethancourt C Braves
T-122 Austin Hedges C Padres
124 Joe Benson OF Twins
125 Derek Norris C Athletics
126 Aaron Sanchez RHP Blue Jays
127 Tim Wheeler OF Rockies
128 Ryan Lavarnway C Red Sox
T-129 Christian Villanueva 3B Rangers
T-129 Grant Green OF Athletics
131 Jorge Alfaro C Rangers

At lest three named Zach or Zack

Composite lists can be helpful. It allows you to see the outliers in each list in an instant.

Scouting Book has a pretty good list usually.

http://www.scoutingbook.com/prospects/matrix