Back by popular demand>>>>Judge Your Sig Thread>>>>

Lancemountain · May 7, 2012

The old judge your signature thread is so passé......and this great new format requires a new judging thread.

Post here and I will judge your signature. This time around I will have guidelines

5 points for content
5 points for design
5 points for presentation
5 points for x factor

total possible 20 points

Gwynn545 · May 7, 2012

Just know that I give my students extra credit for going first on their presentation...just keep...that...in...mind...

Lancemountain · May 7, 2012

Gwynn545 said:
Just know that I give my students extra credit for going first on their presentation...just keep...that...in...mind...

content gets a 5 as the point is made. Poster is a Gwynn collector. Both design and presentation score well as it's clean, well sized and; like the McDonald's arch, well recognizable. 8 more points. You are losing a few points for x factor as it has not been updated in years.

17/20

Card Magnet · May 7, 2012

Rate away, Lance.

homerun28aa · May 7, 2012

Wonder how mine compares. Although I think I need more than just cards in mine to score high lol

Lancemountain · May 7, 2012

homerun28aa said:
Wonder how mine compares. Guess you need more than just cards in your sig to score high lol

I see no sig here and that is a shame as I think you are the 1/1 yaz sterling guy? Judges love that stuff. But as I said, no sig is showing up

edit: Gilmo kicked the tires and now I can see that you are, in fact, the guy I was thinking of. Williams, yaz, oops

Loose that part about describing what your bucket is, we all know that.

c-4
d-4
p-4
x-3

15/20 Judges like overall

gt2590 · May 7, 2012

CM, I'd be careful, Lance is a NY football Giants fan. I don't think I'll post my Dez Bryant Rainbow for that reason lol...

And LM, does having Mets content still cost you Points?

Lancemountain · May 7, 2012

Card Magnet said:
Rate away, Lance.

Cleanest one from you I have seen in a bit but you have always scored well. You are like the Leo DiCaprio of sigs...never win it all but always critically acclaimed.

17/20 points lost for being a tad bunched up. The little magnet guy is all up in that tho <3

Lancemountain · May 7, 2012

gt2590 said:
CM, I'd be careful, Lance is a NY football Giants fan. I don't think I'll post my Dez Bryant Rainbow for that reason lol...

And LM, does having Mets content still cost you Points?

Mets content in signatures used to reduce scores significantly but as the current state and future of the franchise is that bad, I chose to alleviate that requirement as I am a man of the downtrodden. It's 2012 and they are still paying Bonilla. LOL

Anyway, you got a good ol' 10/20 going on. Nothing bad, nothing good.

Wanna hit a game this week?

Big Mac McGwire · May 7, 2012

how bout just going with whats trending on twitter?

Lancemountain · May 7, 2012

Big Mac McGwire said:
how bout just going with whats trending on twitter?

twitter is boring.

8/20

Content is cool, but out of focus pictures and different sizes are very distracting.

gradedeflator · May 7, 2012

here's mine--one word: "Classic"

p.s. I don't expect to win, but if I do, the credit should really go to the boardmember who makes all the A&G cards! and I cant believe I am blanking on his name...

Lancemountain · May 7, 2012

gradedeflator said:
here's mine--one word: "Classic"

p.s. I don't expect to win, but if I do, the credit should really go to the boardmember who makes all the A&G cards! and I cant believe I am blanking on his name...

you are blanking on his name because it's like j8obel74eia or something like that. Great guy, made many a sig including some banners for me.

Yours is nice. Clean and historical.

c-4
d-3
p-4
x-2

13/20 overall nice sig

gt2590 · May 7, 2012

Lancemountain said:
Cleanest one from you I have seen in a bit but you have always scored well. You are like the Leo DiCaprio of sigs...never win it all but always critically acclaimed.

17/20 points lost for being a tad bunched up. The little magnet guy is all up in that tho <3

But CM's got a more active "P***y Patrol" than Leo!

Ty Hope · May 7, 2012

Judge away! But I must warn you, the force is strong with this one

ThoseBackPages · May 7, 2012

20 here. thanks for the contest.

jbhofmann · May 7, 2012

mine changes almost daily

James52411 · May 7, 2012

When you rate me, you negate me. But do it anyway.

alexs64 · May 7, 2012

I will join in on the fun. Thanks for judging me. A job normally reserved a the higher power.

csmtampa · May 7, 2012

Is there an option on this theme to turn off board signatures? Some of them on the site are absolutely ridiculous.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Back by popular demand>>>>Judge Your Sig Thread>>>>

Active member

Well-known member

Active member

New member

Active member

Active member

Super Moderator

Active member

Active member

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Super Moderator

New member

New member

Active member

New member

Active member

New member

Similar threads

Log in