Top 100 Prospects - a combination of lists

I took Keith Law, the 3 BA top 50 lists and Kevin Goldstein, weighted each of the lists equally and combined them. 100 is the max you can get (for being ranked #1) and 1 is the worst (for being ranked #100). So you can see that Wieters was #1 on nearly every list! Let me know what you think.

1. Matt Wieters, 99.8
2. David Price, 99.2
3. Madison Bumgarner, 95.8
4. Neftali Feliz, 95
5. Colby Rasmus, 93
6. Travis Snider, 92.4
7. Tommy Hanson, 92
8. Jason Heyward, 91.2
9. Buster Posey, 88.4
10. Cameron Maybin, 86.6
11. Pedro Alvarez, 85.8
12. Brett Anderson, 85.4
12. Trevor Cahill, 85.4
14. Dexter Fowler, 84.8
15. Lars Anderson, 84
16. Mike Stanton, 83.4
17. Rick Porcello, 80.4
17. Tim Beckham, 80.4
19. Eric Hosmer, 79.6
20. Brian Matusz, 78.6
21. Mike Moustakas, 78.2
22. Carlos Santana, 77.6
23. Gordon Beckham, 76.2
24. Logan Morrison, 75.8
25. Matt Laporta, 75
26. Derek Holland, 74
27. Chris Tillman, 73
28. Alcides Escobar, 71.4
29. Jarrod Parker, 71
30. Fernando Martinez, 69.4
31. Wade Davis, 67
32. Josh Vitters, 66.4
33. Justin Smoak, 65.2
34. Angel Villalona, 63.6
35. Jordan Zimmerman, 60.4
36. Andrew McCutchen, 57.4
37. Aaron Hicks, 55
38. Jesus Montero, 53.8
39. Jhoulys Chacin, 53.2
39. Yonder Alonso, 53.2
41. J.P. Arencibia, 51.2
42. Austin Jackson, 50.8
43. Tim Alderson, 47.2
44. Brett Wallace, 44.6
45. Elvis Andrus, 44.6
46. Jordan Schafer, 41.2
47. Mat Gamel, 39.2
48. Dominic Brown, 38.6
49. Michael Inoa, 36
50. Matt Dominguez, 32.2
51. Carlos Carrasco, 31.2
52. Wilmer Flores, 29
53. Jason Castro, 28.4
54. Desmond Jennings, 25.6
55. Greg Halman, 25.4
56. Nick Adenhart, 25.2
57. Michael Bowden, 23.8
58. Chris Carter, 21
59. Ben Revere, 20.6
59. Brett Lawrie, 20.6
61. Jake Arrieta, 20.4
62. Jordan Walden, 19.6
62. Taylor Teagarden, 19.6
64. Jeremy Jeffress, 16.2
65. Carlos Triunfel, 15.8
65. Jose Tabata, 15.8
67. Michael Main, 14.4
68. Aaron Poreda, 14.2
69. James McDonald, 14
70. Brett Cecil, 13.8
71. Martin Perez, 12.8
72. Reid Brignac, 12.4
72. Daniel Bard, 12.4
74. Nick Weglarz, 11.6
75. Freddie Freeman, 11.4
76. Ethan Martin, 11.2
76. Wilin Rosario, 11.2
78. Chris Perez, 11
79. Jeremy Hellickson, 10.8
80. Jason Donald, 10.6
81. Angel Salome, 10.4
82. Daryl Jones, 10.2
83. Tyler Flowers, 10
84. Kyle Blanks, 9.4
84. Michael Taylor, 9.4
86. Andrew Lambo, 9.2
87. Adam Miller, 8.6
88. Christian Friedrich, 8.4
89. Phillippe Aumont, 8
90. Dan Schlereth, 7.6
90. Kyle Skipworth, 7.6
92. Gorkys Hernandez , 7.2
93. Michael Burgess, 7.2
94. David Huff, 7
95. Engel Beltre, 6.6
96. Matt Latos, 6.4
96. Mat Latos, 6.4
98. Scott Elbert, 6.2
99. Chris Nelson, 5.8
100. Michael Saunders, 5.2
101. Max Ramirez, 4.8
102. Nick Hagadone, 4
102. Ross Detwiler, 4
104. Drew Stubbs, 3.4
104. Kellen Kulbacki, 3.4
106. Julio Borbon, 3.2
106. Jeff Samardzija, 3.2
108. Todd Frazier, 3
109. Josh Reddick, 2.8
110. David Cooper, 2.6
111. Junichi Tazawa, 2.2
112. Geraldo Parra, 2
113. Jake Arrietta, 1.8
113. Kyle Drabek, 1.8
115. Adrian Cardenas, 1.6
116. Jefry Marte, 1.4
117. Andrew Brackman, 1.2
117. Ivan DeJesus Jr., 1.2
119. Jeff Locke, 0.8
120. Jay Jackson, 0.6
120. Brandon Erbe, 0.6
122. Brandon Allen, 0.4
123. Adys Portillo, 0.2

Nice job! Very interesting to see.

Gorkys is a hell of a player to be ranked 101 and 110

That's awesome. Looks like J.P. is the 5th best catcher in the minors by these lists. I like!

Penno said:

Gorkys is a hell of a player to be ranked 101 and 110

Click to expand...

Good catch, edited.

Bump for the evening crowd.

2 arrieta?

thought 113 was a little low on him... :lol:

dave

daveyou said:

2 arrieta?

thought 113 was a little low on him... :lol:

dave

Click to expand...

ooops need to get that one too, thanks!

Very interesting that Cahill and Anderson are the same rank :lol:

Thanks Phil!

soccerman034 said:

Very interesting that Cahill and Anderson are the same rank :lol:

Thanks Phil!

Click to expand...

Yeah that happens when you merge all these lists.

I don't see Chris Marrero on anyone's list? He's gotta still at least be a top 150 prospect (considering he will be the next Albert Pujols )

brouthercard said:

I don't see Chris Marrero on anyone's list? He's gotta still at least be a top 150 prospect (considering he will be the next Albert Pujols )

Click to expand...

It was interesting not to see him considering how high he was last year.