What ONE CARD would you trade your entire current collection for?

mudflap02 · Mar 26, 2013

I was thinking about this today. It would be kind of neat to consolidate everything into one card.

The rules are simple. It has to be a card. And it can only be one. And you can't keep anything - everything you currently own goes out the door.

I would probably trade my Heritage sets for a nice high grade '52 Mantle. The value would probably be similar and it would be a whole lot easier to keep around.

WNP22 · Mar 26, 2013

Do they have to be of similar value?

VandyDan · Mar 26, 2013

I could like, buy more in the future, right?

Probably the Price Super Auto. It was on the bay for a very high BIN, don't know if it sold or not. I think my whole collection is worth about that anyway, but still. Even then I don't know. I kinda like my PC, even if it is deficient in super high end.

Lancemountain · Mar 26, 2013

206 Wagner.

uniquebaseballcards · Mar 26, 2013

No way!

Good question BTW LOL.

MisterT · Mar 26, 2013

None. Its not about value to me. I like the variety, the history, the memory of where I got the card, etc. There are lots of "one" cards I would want...the high grade 52 Mantle, the Wagner, etc. etc. But no one card is worth my collection to ME. Dollar wise on eBay, sure. But not to me.

SydBarrett · Mar 26, 2013

33 Goudey Gehrig PSA 4+

gracecollector · Mar 26, 2013

1887 Old Judge Cap Anson in uniform. Would be nice to clear up the space!

TBTwinsFan · Mar 26, 2013

I'd trade every card I have (minus my perkins and vintage collections) for a Perkins superfractor.

apbtpat · Mar 26, 2013

206 Wagner!

VizquelCollector.com · Mar 26, 2013

Oooooh, good question!

It'd have to be something I could sell immediately. I wouldn't care to begin a new card collection, so essentially it'd be the amount enticing enough to abandon my collection and collecting cards altogether. Would want to recoup the approx $ I've spent plus "sell" my time investment... and I'm also creating a lifestyle change. It'd take me a while to come up with a number but it's definitely north of $25K.

James52411 · Mar 26, 2013

TBTwinsFan said:
I'd trade every card I have (minus my perkins and vintage collections) for a Perkins superfractor.

You haven't traded your entire collection.

Slette · Mar 26, 2013

2006 Elite Chad Greenway Black Status auto 1/1

The values don't come close to matching up, but I'd do it without thinking twice

Tyler McEver · Mar 26, 2013

I don't have a completed set but I would trade my cards in my collection for a Cam Newton 1/1 superfractor auto or a 6 way of HOFer's.

TBTwinsFan · Mar 26, 2013

James52411 said:
You haven't traded your entire collection.

Yeah, true.

Calripkenjrcollector · Mar 26, 2013

uniquebaseballcards said:
No way!

Good question BTW LOL.

+1
You guys can have all the Wagner's, Ruth's and Mantle's. All the time, effort and memories I have in my collection is worth more than anything.

roundtree34 · Mar 26, 2013

a high grade t206 cobb or a psa 10 nolan ryan

notjomommasclint · Mar 26, 2013

Bgs 9.5 x4 Michael Jordan 86-87 fleer. I'd even deliver.

I'm old Greg

hofvintagecollector · Mar 26, 2013

I'd trade my entire prospect collection for a the 2010 Chrome Matt Harvey superfractor autograph

magicpapa · Mar 26, 2013

Calripkenjrcollector said:
+1
You guys can have all the Wagner's, Ruth's and Mantle's. All the time, effort and memories I have in my collection is worth more than anything.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

What ONE CARD would you trade your entire current collection for?

Active member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

Active member

Member

Active member

New member

Well-known member

Similar threads

Log in