B.J. Upton could be demoted

P_Manning 18 · May 31, 2013

Think the Braves are regretting the 5yr $75M contract they signed him to this off season???

Atlanta Braves consider sending B.J. Upton to minors - ESPN

joeya2001 · May 31, 2013

Ehhh we got Justin out of it. Fair tradeoff lol

Sent from my HTCEVODesign4G using Freedom Card Board mobile app

scotty216brs · May 31, 2013

That was an awful contract to give him, what were they thinking? Sending him down might do him some good, but the 'good' is that he won't have to stink up the Braves.

19braves77 · Jun 1, 2013

In the back of their minds, Braves brass are hoping he tweeks something and is forced to take a Minor League assignment everyday he takes the field.

BunchOBull · Jun 1, 2013

Having Bros in the outfield was good press, but now that J.Up is shining, the brass don't need the "Bros" schtick anymore. Sending him down will relieve the masses.

BBCgalaxee · Jun 1, 2013

Think of it like this.

If u picked" upton" as the best off season pickup in your office pool, you're looking great!

And if you had "upton" as the worst off season pickup in your office pool, well, a winner is you.

19braves77 · Jun 1, 2013

The everyday lineup should be this:

1. Schafer- CF
2. Simmons- SS
3. Upton- Rf
4. Gattis- LF
5. Freeman- 1st
6. McCann- C
7. Pena- 2nd
8. Johnson- 3rd

WaxPax · Jun 1, 2013

So you would bench Heyward in favor of Schafer?

19braves77 said:
The everyday lineup should be this:

1. Schafer- CF
2. Simmons- SS
3. Upton- Rf
4. Gattis- LF
5. Freeman- 1st
6. McCann- C
7. Pena- 2nd
8. Johnson- 3rd

HPC · Jun 1, 2013

Who really thought paying $75 million for a bj was a good idea?

brianga26 · Jun 1, 2013

I thought it was the dumbest move any team has made in years.. BJ hasn't hit above .250 since his rookie year (correct me if I am wrong)

Huffamaniac · Jun 1, 2013

Wrong. Rookie year was 2004 where he hit . 258. He hit .300 in 07 and .273 in 08. Since 08 his best season batting average wise was last year where he batted .246 but had 28 Hrs

brianga26 said:
I thought it was the dumbest move any team has made in years.. BJ hasn't hit above .250 since his rookie year (correct me if I am wrong)

jbmm161 · Jun 1, 2013

Overpaid for sure but I don't think the Braves get the same production out of Justin without having his brother there. Justin is happy and producing because of it. I bet a part BJ has to be a little jealous of his brothers success and a demotion would probably makes things worse for both of them.

CAROLINA BOSOX · Jun 1, 2013

Don't forget that BJ always hustles on every play! He was very arrogant when he played in Charleston and I always figured that Basball Karma would catch up to him. Didn't surprise me when he got outed in Tampa Bay for jogging after missing a ball. I was disappointed when the Braves picked him up and gave him such a big contract.

RiceLynnEvans75 · Jun 1, 2013

WaxPax said:
So you would bench Heyward in favor of Schafer?

Absolutely.

ronniedp23 · Jun 1, 2013

WaxPax said:
So you would bench Heyward in favor of Schafer?

While he's hitting like this... yeah. Personally I think its time to hire Chipper as a "hitting consultant" to work with the under performing players.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Freedom Card Board mobile app

vwnut13 · Jun 1, 2013

jbmm161 said:
Overpaid for sure but I don't think the Braves get the same production out of Justin without having his brother there. Justin is happy and producing because of it. I bet a part BJ has to be a little jealous of his brothers success and a demotion would probably makes things worse for both of them.

Sure Justin Upton has 14 HR, but he only has 29 RBI (11 Solo HR) and is hitting 0.186 with runners on base.

Austin · Jun 1, 2013

Justin Upton has been almost as horrible as B.J. for the past month.

In April, Justin hit .298 with 12 homers and 19 rbi.
In May, Justin hit .211 with 2 homers and 10 rbi.

So both brothers suck, but Justin gets praised because he was on fire to start the season.

Tywill555 · Jun 1, 2013

I get that he's struggling but it's not like this has never happened to another player In baseball before. He just needs to get his head straight and he should be able to make a comeback.

predatorkj · Jun 1, 2013

What gets me time and again is the pure praise for Justin. Yes he is a good ball player. But for years now he has been talked about like he's this beast of a player and to tell you the truth, he doesn't stand out in my mind as being as good as everyone makes him out to be. And of course I get some people telling me to just wait and see. Like I said, I won't argue that he's a good player. I'm just surprised the hype hasn't died down by now. Is everyone still expecting him to turn it up a few more notches?

cards01fan · Jun 1, 2013

HPC said:
Who really thought paying $75 million for a bj was a good idea?

That's just like being married, paying for it lol

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

B.J. Upton could be demoted

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

Active member

Active member

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Active member

New member

Active member

Well-known member

New member

Active member

New member

Similar threads

Log in