Your Team's All Time Lineup (And Your Favorite Team's Worst)

newhannibal · Mar 10, 2009

Post your favorite teams all-time lineup and discuss:

1) Derek Jeter SS
2) Joe DiMaggio LF
3) Babe Ruth RF
4) Lou Gehrig 1B
5) Mickey Mantle CF
6) Alex Rodriguez 3B
7) Dave Winfield DH
8) Yogi Berra C
9) Tony Lazzeri 2B

Secondary Lineup:

1) Rickey Henderson LF
2) Bernie Williams CF
3) Don Mattingly 1B
4) Reggie Jackson RF
5) Bill Dickey C
6) Graig Nettles 3B
7) Roger Maris DH
8) Joe Gordon 2B
9) Phil Rizzuto SS

Edit Worst Lineup:

C) Frank Fernandez
1B) Kevin Maas
2B) Horace Clarke
3B) Steve Pagulario
SS) Jerry Kenney
LF) Raul Mondesi
CF) Melky Cabrera
RF) Tony Womack

braden · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

C- Ernie Whitt
1B- Carlos Delgado
2B- Roberto Alomar
SS- Tony Fernandez
3B- Kelly Gruber
LF- George Bell
CF- Vernon Wells
RF- Jesse Barfield
DH- Paul Molitor

SP- Dave Stieb
SP- Roy Halladay (can't choose between the two)

RP- Tom Henke

newhannibal · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

braden said:
C- Ernie Whitt
1B- Carlos Delgado
2B- Roberto Alomar
SS- Tony Fernandez
3B- Kelly Gruber
LF- George Bell
CF- Vernon Wells
RF- Jesse Barfield
DH- Paul Molitor

SP- Dave Stieb
SP- Roy Halladay (can't choose between the two)

RP- Tom Henke

No Rickey Henderson?

Craig - 21hawk · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

2B - Rod Carew
RF - Tony Oliva
CF - Kirby Puckett
3B - Harmon Killebrew
1B - Kent Hrbek
LF - Bob Allison
DH - Justin Morneau
C - Joe Mauer
SS - Zoilo Versailles

Starting Staff - Camilo Pascual, Johan Santana, Bert Blyleven, Frank Viola, Mudcat Grant

Relievers - Jeff Reardon, Rick Aguilera, Joe Nathan

Craig

braden · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

newhannibal said:
braden said:

C- Ernie Whitt
1B- Carlos Delgado
2B- Roberto Alomar
SS- Tony Fernandez
3B- Kelly Gruber
LF- George Bell
CF- Vernon Wells
RF- Jesse Barfield
DH- Paul Molitor

SP- Dave Stieb
SP- Roy Halladay (can't choose between the two)

RP- Tom Henke

Click to expand...

No Rickey Henderson?

I'm going by what they did as a Jay.

Mighty Bombjack · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

C- Kurt Manwaring? (about ready to put Ianetta here)
1B- Todd Helton
2B- Eric Young
SS- Troy Tulowitzki
3B- Garrett Atkins (close with Vinny Castilla)
LF- Matt Holiday
CF- Ellis Burks (this is a tough one)
RF- Larry Walker
DH (if playing in an AL park)-Dante Bichette

SP- Aaron Cook
SP- Pedro Astacio

RP- Brian Fuentes

thefasterblade · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

DH Henderson over Winfield.

newhannibal · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

Expos All Time Team:

1) Tim Raines LF
2) Jose Vidro 2B
3) Vladimir Guerrero RF
4) Andre Dawson CF
5) Moises Alou DH
6) Gary Carter C
7) Tim Wallach 3B
8) Andres Galarraga
9) Hubie Brooks SS

newhannibal · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

thefasterblade said:
DH Henderson over Winfield.

The DH one was tough because you have Henderson, Winfield, Jackson, Mattingly etc.

ChasHawk · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

C - Gabby Hartnett
1B - Mark Grace
2B - Ryne Sandberg
SS - Ernie Banks
LF - Billy Williams
3B - Ron Santo
CF - Hack Wilson
RF - Andre Dawson

SP - Mordecai Brown
SP - Greg Maddux
SP - Fergie Jenkins
SP - Grover Cleveland Alexander
SP - Charlie Root

RP - Goose Gossage
RP - Lee Smith
RP - Bruce Sutter

Sadly, I couldn't begin to include anyone from recent teams :lol:

notjomommasclint · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

my red sox lineup

1b- jimmie foxx
2b- bobby doerr
ss- nomar garciaparra
3b- wade boggs
rf- dwight evans
cf- tris speaker
lf- ted williams
c- carlton fisk
dh- carl yastrzemski
sp- roger clemens
rp- sparky lyle

leaving rice, pesky, lynn, and vaughn out is tough... pedro, babe, cy young, and smokey joe could be listed as pitchers tooooooo...

wildcat4 · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

Cardinals...

LF Lou Brock
CF Joe Medwick
RF Stan Musial
1B Albert Pujols
2B Rogers Hornsby
3B Ken Boyer
C Ted Simmons
SS Ozzie Smith

SP Bob Gibson
SP Dizzy Dean
SP Jesse Haines
SP Bob Forsch
SP Joaquin Andujar
RP Bruce Sutter
RP Todd Worrell
RP Al Hrabosky

-Steve

newhannibal · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

notjomommasclint said:
my red sox lineup

1b- jimmie foxx
2b- bobby doerr
ss- nomar garciaparra
3b- wade boggs
rf- dwight evans
cf- tris speaker
lf- ted williams
c- carlton fisk
dh- carl yastrzemski
sp- roger clemens
rp- sparky lyle

leaving rice, pesky, lynn, and vaughn out is tough... pedro, babe, cy young, and smokey joe could be listed as pitchers tooooooo...

No Offerman at 2nd Base?

Craig - 21hawk · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

Offerman = Enforcer

You mess with his team, he takes out his bat!

Craig

newhannibal · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

Craig - 21hawk said:
Offerman = Enforcer

You mess with his team, he takes out his bat!

Craig

[youtube:369j37di]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qN4pIEd5gbs[/youtube:369j37di]

disengager · Mar 10, 2009

ALL MARINERS
1b- Alvin Davis
2b- Harold Reynolds
ss- Alex Rodriguez
3b- Adrian Beltre
rf- Jay Buhner
cf- Ken Griffey Jr
lf- - Ichiro
c- - Dan Wilson
dh-Edgar Martinez
sp- Randy Johnson
rp- Bobby Ayala

crowhop · Mar 10, 2009

C Bruce Benedict 71 OPS+
1B Walter Holke 87 OPS+
2B Mark Lemke 72 OPS+
3B Ken Oberkfell 92 OPS+
SS Andres Thomas 61 OPS+
LF Mike Lum 89 OPS+
CF Rowland Office 77 OPS+
RF Jeff Francoeur 92 OPS+

These are the worst Braves by position and OPS+. The cut-off was 2500 PAs. Only one current guy, but if Gregor Blanco gets many more ABs, he'll be in the running.

wolfmanalfredo · Mar 10, 2009

Re: Your Team's All Time Lineup

Craig - 21hawk said:
2B - Rod Carew
RF - Tony Oliva
CF - Kirby Puckett
3B - Harmon Killebrew
1B - Kent Hrbek
LF - Bob Allison
DH - Justin Morneau
C - Joe Mauer
SS - Zoilo Versailles

Starting Staff - Camilo Pascual, Johan Santana, Bert Blyleven, Frank Viola, Mudcat Grant

Relievers - Jeff Reardon, Rick Aguilera, Joe Nathan

Craig

Wouldn't that be great! I'd almost want to sub out a SP for Jim Kaat though

robboshow · Mar 10, 2009

Pirates

All Time Line Up
1. Honus Wagner SS
2. Max Carey CF
3. Roberto Clemente RF
4. Willie Stargell 1B
5. Barry Bonds LF
6. Pie Traynor 3B
7. Manny Sanguillen C
8. Bill Mazeroski 2B

Worst
1. Pat Meares 2B
2. Dale Berra SS
3. Marvelle Wynne CF
4. Tony Bartirome 1B
5. Pete Castiglione 3B
6. Hal Rice LF
7. Cecil Espy RF
8. Jerry May C

crowhop · Mar 10, 2009

And the Best Braves by OPS+ by Position. 2500 PAs.

C Joe Torre 129
1B Joe Adcock 130
2B Marcus Giles 108
3B Chipper Jones/Eddie Mathews 145*
SS Sam Wise 118
LF Rico Carty 143
CF Wally Berger 141
RF Hank Aaron 158

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Your Team's All Time Lineup (And Your Favorite Team's Worst)

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

Member

New member

Similar threads

Log in