BGS Grades Are In How'd I Do? (2nd Submission ever)

Hi,

New member/longtime lurker.

This is only my second submission ever (some cards in this order belong to my buddy).

Some of these were crack and resubmits (didn't do too well there).

The McCovey RC's killed me as I compared them (under a loupe) to my BGS 5 and all 3 were significantly better in all 4 categories. Not sure why thry graded out so low. Any way to find out?

Comments are welcome.....


ItemID Set Name Player Final Grade
6041404 2008 Topps Chrome Rookie Autographs John David Booty D 9.0
6041387 2008 Topps Chrome Refractors Darren McFadden 9.5
6041393 2008 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Rafael Rodriguez AU/999 9.0
6041394 2008 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Rafael Rodriguez AU/999 9.0
6041395 2008 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Rafael Rodriguez AU/999 9.0
6041396 2008 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Rafael Rodriguez AU/999 9.0
6041391 2008 Bowman Draft AFLAC Autographs Blake Beavan 9.5
6041405 2008 Bowman Draft AFLAC Autographs Nick Noonan 9.5
6041406 2008 Bowman Draft AFLAC Autographs Nick Noonan 9.0
6041397 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Jason Heyward AU 9.0
6041401 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Madison Bumgarner AU 9.5
6041402 2008 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Refractors Cody Adams AU 9.5
6041380 2008 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Red Refractors Ryne White 9.5
6041376 2008 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Blue Refractors Angel Villalona FG 9.5
6041377 2008 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Blue Refractors Andrew Liebel 9.0
6041398 2008 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Michael Stanton AU 9.5
6041399 2008 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects M.Inoa AU EXCH 9.5
6041382 2007 Upper Deck All-Star FanFest Tim Lincecum 9.5
6041385 2007 Upper Deck All-Star FanFest Daisuke Matsuzaka 9.0
6041386 2007 Upper Deck All-Star FanFest LE Josh Hamilton 9.5
ItemID Set Name Player Final Grade
6041381 2007 Topps All-Star FanFest Tim Lincecum 9.5
6041383 2007 Giants Topps Tim Lincecum 8.0
6041408 2007 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Signature Aspirations * Nick Noonan/100 8.5
6041392 2007 Bowman Sterling Prospects Madison Bumgarner AU 9.5
6041407 2007 Bowman Sterling Prospects Nick Noonan AU 9.5
6041400 2007 Bowman Chrome Draft Draft Picks Gold Refractors Devin Mesoraco AU 9.5
6041384 2006 Topps AFLAC Tim Alderson 9.0
6041403 2005 Diamond Kings HOF Heroes Signature Materials Bronze Phil Niekro Bat-Jsy/25 9.0
6041375 2002 Bowman Chrome Draft Refractors Matt Cain 9.0
6041360 1997-98 SP Authentic BuyBack Jason Kidd 94/5 Authentic
6041378 1992 Stadium Club Dome Manny Ramirez 9.5
6041379 1992 Stadium Club Dome Jason Giambi 9.0
6041388 1991 Giants Pacific Gas and Electric Will Clark 7.5
6041373 1990 Topps Tiffany Will Clark 9.5
6041374 1990 Topps Tiffany Will Clark AS 9.5
6041369 1990 Mother's Will Clark Will Clark-(Batting pose looking-over right shou 8.5
6041370 1990 Mother's Will Clark Will Clark-(Holding bat on-left shoulder) 9.5
6041371 1990 Mother's Will Clark Will Clark-(Holding bat ready-to swing) 9.0
6041372 1990 Mother's Will Clark Will Clark-(Standing with bat-behind shoulders) 8.5
6041390 1989 Mother's Will Clark Will Clark-(Swing follow-through) 8.0
6041389 1987 Giants Mother's Will Clark 8.0
6041366 1978 Topps Willie McCovey 8.5
6041362 1969 Topps Bob Griese 6.5
6041361 1967 Topps J.Marichal CL6 No Ear 4.0
6041363 1960 Topps W.McCovey ASR 5.0
6041364 1960 Topps W.McCovey ASR 3.5
6041365 1960 Topps W.McCovey ASR 3.5
6041368 1952 Bowman Bobby Thomson 3.5
6041367 1949 Bowman Bobby Thomson 2.0

Here's my first sub from a few months back

NOTE: Most of the vintage is all PC I wanted slabbed for protection. They were mostly cards handed down to me.

ItemID Set Name Player Final Grade
5864382 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Blue Refractors Wendell Fairley AU 9.5
5864388 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Blue Refractors Austin Jackson 9.5
5864384 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Michael Moustakas AU 9.5
5864386 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Jason Heyward AU 9.0
5864387 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Matt Dominguez AU 9.5
5864448 2007 Upper Deck All-Star FanFest Tim Lincecum 9.5
5864450 2007 UD Masterpieces Tim Lincecum 10.0
5864375 2007 Topps All-Star FanFest Tim Lincecum 9.5
5864376 2007 Topps All-Star FanFest Tim Lincecum 9.5
5864377 2007 Topps All-Star FanFest Tim Lincecum 9.0
5864378 2007 Topps All-Star FanFest Tim Lincecum 9.5
5864444 2007 Topps All-Star FanFest Tim Lincecum 9.5
5864397 2007 Giants Topps Tim Lincecum 9.5
5864398 2007 Giants Topps Tim Lincecum 9.5
5864399 2007 Giants Topps Tim Lincecum 9.0
5864400 2007 Giants Topps Tim Lincecum 9.0
5864401 2007 Giants Topps Tim Lincecum 9.5
5864396 2007 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Signature Turn of the Century * Nick Noonan/300 EXCH 9.5
ItemID Set Name Player Final Grade
5864393 2007 Bowman Chrome Draft Draft Picks Refractors Nick Noonan AU 9.5
5864392 2007 Bowman Chrome Draft Draft Picks Kellen Kulbacki AU 9.5
5864394 2007 Bowman Chrome Draft Draft Picks Nick Noonan AU 9.0
5864354 2006 Topps AFLAC Promo Nick Noonan 9.5
5864355 2006 Topps AFLAC Promo Tim Alderson 9.5
5864389 2002 Bowman Chrome Draft Refractors Fred Lewis 9.5
5864352 1998 Ultra Gold Medallion Peyton Manning 9.0
5864353 1996-97 Finest Steve Nash B 9.5
5864381 1994 SP Holoviews Michael Jordan 9.0
5864380 1994 SP Alex Rodriguez Authentic
5864391 1993 SP Derek Jeter 7.5
5864367 1993 Giants Mother's Will Clark 9.5
ItemID Set Name Player Final Grade
5864361 1992 Giants Mother's Will Clark 8.5
5864362 1992 Giants Mother's Will Clark 9.5
5864364 1991 Giants Mother's Will Clark 8.5
5864365 1991 Giants Mother's Will Clark 8.5
5864366 1991 Giants Mother's Will Clark 8.5
5864363 1990 Giants Mother's Will Clark 9.0
5864390 1989 Upper Deck Ken Griffey Jr. 7.5
5864368 1989 Giants Mother's Will Clark 5.5
5864369 1989 Giants Mother's Will Clark 9.5
5864370 1989 Giants Mother's Will Clark 9.5
5864371 1989 Giants Mother's Will Clark 9.5
5864360 1987 Giants Mother's Matt Williams 9.5
5864358 1986 Giants Mother's Will Clark 9.5
5864359 1986 Giants Mother's Robby Thompson 9.5
5864441 1973 Topps S.Carlton/N.Ryan LL 3.0
5864442 1973 Topps Pete Rose 6.5
5864437 1972 Topps Jim Palmer 4.0
5864438 1972 Topps Hank Aaron IA 3.5
5864439 1972 Topps Johnny Bench IA 4.5
ItemID Set Name Player Final Grade
5864440 1972 Topps Thurman Munson IA 3.0
5864435 1971 Topps Tom Seaver 3.0
5864436 1971 Topps Johnny Bench 3.5
5864434 1970 Topps Willie McCovey 4.0
5864342 1969 Topps Dick Butkus 8.0
5864343 1969 Topps Bob Griese 7.0
5864344 1969 Topps Fred Biletnikoff 8.0
5864345 1969 Topps Fred Biletnikoff 8.5
5864346 1969 Topps Fred Biletnikoff 7.0
5864347 1969 Topps Bart Starr 7.0
5864348 1969 Topps Bart Starr 4.0
5864349 1969 Topps Bart Starr 8.5
5864350 1969 Topps George Blanda 7.5
5864351 1969 Topps Daryle Lamonica 5.5
5864330 1968 Topps Joe Namath 4.0
5864331 1968 Topps Gale Sayers 6.5
5864332 1968 Topps Johnny Unitas 6.0
5864333 1968 Topps Johnny Unitas 4.5
5864334 1968 Topps Johnny Unitas 7.0
5864338 1968 Topps Dick Butkus 7.5
ItemID Set Name Player Final Grade
5864339 1968 Topps Alex Karras 7.5
5864431 1968 Topps Al Kaline 6.0
5864432 1968 Topps Johnny Bench 7.5
5864433 1968 Topps Phil Niekro 7.5
5864327 1967 Topps Jack Kemp 3.0
5864328 1967 Topps Joe Namath 4.0
5864425 1967 Topps Don Sutton 4.0
5864426 1967 Topps Phil Niekro 5.5
5864427 1967 Topps Phil Niekro 6.5
5864428 1967 Topps Roberto Clemente CL5 4.0
5864429 1967 Topps Roberto Clemente 5.0
5864321 1967 Philadelphia Johnny Unitas 4.5
5864322 1967 Philadelphia Dick Butkus 6.0
5864323 1967 Philadelphia Mike Ditka 2.0
5864324 1967 Philadelphia Bart Starr 5.0
5864411 1966 Topps Jim Hunter 6.5
5864421 1966 Topps Bob Uecker TR 2.5
5864406 1965 Topps Veale/Drysdale/Gibson LL 6.5
5864325 1963 Topps Bart Starr 1.0
5864404 1963 Topps Bob Uecker 7.0
ItemID Set Name Player Final Grade
5864402 1960 Topps W.McCovey ASR 5.0

Nice stuff.. would any of the Rafael Rodriguez autos be available FT?

kruzie3 said:

Nice stuff.. would any of the Rafael Rodriguez autos be available FT?

Click to expand...

Possibly....PM me. (Your bucket is blocked on this server)

looks like you did pretty well for your 2nd sub ever, congrats