Which is the better card.....?~

George_Calfas · Mar 11, 2014

...for Mickey Mantle
1951 Bowman or 1952 Topps?

We know that value is weighted to the '52, but if prices were the same and you could own only one which would it be? [MENTION=1995]dano7[/MENTION]?

jbmm161 · Mar 11, 2014

1952 Topps is the most iconic baseball card ever.

swish54_99 · Mar 11, 2014

jbmm161 said:
1952 Topps is the most iconic baseball card ever.

+1

mlbsalltimegreats · Mar 11, 2014

I would Own the 51 Bowman, To me that's his true Rc.

ThoseBackPages · Mar 11, 2014

jbmm161 said:
1952 Topps is the most iconic baseball card ever.

T206 Wagner > 52 Mantle

ThoseBackPages · Mar 11, 2014

prices being equal? i would take the 1952 Topps Mantle.

i would gladly trade my '51 Bowman Mantle PSA 5 for a '52 Topps Mantle PSA 5

JoshHamilton · Mar 11, 2014

1951 Bowman. True RC, and I think the '52 is overrated. Then again, I prefer action shots to posed headshots

dano7 · Mar 11, 2014

I'd give the 52 a slight edge, just because so many were destroyed by Topps. But I really love my 1951 Bowman, because it is technically Mantle's rookie card (even though NOT chrome!). Plus, 51 is my birth year.
DANNY

George_Calfas · Mar 11, 2014

Nice danny......you old fart

michaelstepper · Mar 11, 2014

I'd take the bowman

Austin · Mar 11, 2014

dano7 said:
I'd give the 52 a slight edge, just because so many were destroyed by Topps.

I've read that there are many more 1952 Topps Mantles than '51 Bowmans, even though the '52s are rare high numbers and Topps dumped cases in the bay.
The '51 Bowmans didn't sell well compared to Topps, and the 52 is also a double print.
Al Rosen, who has bought and sold thousands of these cards, confirms the '51 Bowman Mantle is more rare, and the price difference is ridiculous.

I'd still rather have the '52 Topps because it's so iconic and I love how it looks. Being a Yankees fan and my dad collecting in the '50s, it's my ultimate dream card.

Gonzaleznut · Mar 11, 2014

Great question. I would take either, but if I had to choose it would be the '52 Topps

gt2590 · Mar 11, 2014

The Topps please...

Do you need my Shipping Address?

jay1065 · Mar 11, 2014

Tough call. Part of me says the '51 because of the true RC status. However, I think I would go with the '52. When I started collecting as a kid in the 80's, the '52 Mantle was THE card to own.

jbhofmann · Mar 11, 2014

'51 and it's not even close for me.

They're like works of art. The Mantle pose and the green canvas flapping in the Mays background are so underrated.

I've always thought The Mick looked a little like Sloth from The Goonies on the '52T.

moxacaine · Mar 11, 2014

It would be tough, 51 is his RC however, it is a horizontal card and i just dont care for horizontal cards in slabs. petty i know so for that reason i would go with the 52 Topps

scotty216brs · Mar 11, 2014

JoshHamilton said:
1951 Bowman. True RC, and I think the '52 is overrated. Then again, I prefer action shots to posed headshots

This is how I feel as well.

joey12508 · Mar 11, 2014

Bowman 51 looks so cool to me and its his first card. I am not even sure but whats the price of the 51 compared to the topps 52?

Sent from my iPhone using Freedom Card Board mobile app

George_Calfas · Mar 12, 2014

For me the early Bowman sets have better appeal

darrend505 · Mar 12, 2014

I'd have to go with the Topps, but I'm biased.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

~~~~Which is the better card.....?~~~~~

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

New member

New member

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

Super Moderator

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

Similar threads

Log in

Which is the better card.....?~