[Silvertowne Auction House] "We believe them to be original..."

A_Pharis · Jun 5, 2015

Re: http://www.silvertowneauctions.com/HARMON-KILLEBREW-AUTOGRAPHED-BASEBALL-RAWLINGS-BALL_i22511521

Feel free to check out all of the other "signed" baseballs. Many are clearly written (poorly) by the same hand. I send them an email indicating that they are all terrible forgeries and asking if the have someone on task to prevent such from entering the auction and market. This is the reply I get:

"These sports items are consigned by a long time sports collector who purchased them over a period of time. Most do not have a COA so we are selling "AS IS" with no guarantees. We believe them to be original, but we are not Authenticators of Autographs. Thanks. "

Over a period of time, my ass.

Some in the auction are good... but here are some REALLY bads:
http://www.silvertowneauctions.com/JOE-MORGAN-AUTOGRAPHED-BASEBALL-LITTLE-LEAGUE-BALL_i22511519
http://www.silvertowneauctions.com/STAN-MUSIAL-AUTOGRAPHED-BASEBALL-LITTLE-LEAGUE-BALL_i22511520
http://www.silvertowneauctions.com/PETE-ROSE-AUTOGRAPHED-BASEBALL-POWERADE-COMMEM-BALL_i22511522

Waxov · Jun 5, 2015

are they guys part of
http://www.silvertowne.com/ ??

A_Pharis · Jun 5, 2015

Waxov said:
are they guys part of
http://www.silvertowne.com/ ??

oh, I have no idea, but it's possible.

michaelstepper · Jun 5, 2015

Horrible, and these people know it

Juan Gris · Jun 6, 2015

Wow. I wouldn't do business with that company on principle.

fordman · Jun 6, 2015

I wont claim to be a hand writing expert but you can tell several were done by the same person. The Rose, Seaver, Morgan and Musial are all done by the same hand. Doubt they sell. Someone probably found them and think they have stumbled upon a fortune.

Fordman

jbhofmann · Jun 6, 2015

That silver towne is in a small rural Indiana town not far from me.

Is it a franchise? I always thought it was a mom and pop joint.

Waxov · Jun 6, 2015

jbhofmann said:
That silver towne is in a small rural Indiana town not far from me.

Is it a franchise? I always thought it was a mom and pop joint.

They are one of the biggest coins/metals dealers, and are definitely legit... its sad when a company expands into something they're clueless about.

16christensen16 · Jun 6, 2015

I consider myself to not be a killebrew expert, but a killebrew collector who has a reasonable amount of knowledge. And that killebrew ball auto is terrible.....just awful

A_Pharis · Jun 6, 2015

Yeah, I think even basic knowledge eliminates a group of those balls right off of the bat.
I am hoping no one buys them as I'd hate for them to actually hit any part of the market.

Waxov · Jun 6, 2015

After looking at the BBB it appears Silvertowne Auctions is not in the same state as Silvertowne Coins, so I am thinking they are either different people or overseen by a different manager. Silvertowne Coins has a BBB rating of A+ which doesn't surprise me. These card people though are unrated, if an auto expert wants to write a review here you go-

http://www.bbb.org/lima/business-re...s/silvertowne-auctions-in-leipsic-oh-11001939

WCTYSON · Jun 6, 2015

jbhofmann said:
That silver towne is in a small rural Indiana town not far from me.

Is it a franchise? I always thought it was a mom and pop joint.

Here is the auction house address.

Silver Towne Auctions
128 E. Main St.,
Leipsic, OH,
45856, United States

swish54_99 · Jun 6, 2015

Agree, you can tell they're done by the same person. And all shaky too like they are trying to hard to write it. Joe Morgan is not even close...although, there was another Joe Morgan who played in the 60's I believe.

jbhofmann · Jun 13, 2015

WCTYSON said:
Here is the auction house address.

Silver Towne Auctions
128 E. Main St.,
Leipsic, OH,
45856, United States

They are probably 1hr apart.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

[Silvertowne Auction House] "We believe them to be original..."

A_Pharis

Active member

Waxov

New member

A_Pharis

Active member

michaelstepper

Well-known member

Juan Gris

Well-known member

fordman

Well-known member

jbhofmann

Active member

Waxov

New member

16christensen16

New member

A_Pharis

Active member

Waxov

New member

WCTYSON

Well-known member

swish54_99

Well-known member

jbhofmann

Active member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts