How much should a card like this sell for??

numba1yankeefan · Mar 30, 2009

http://cgi.ebay.com/MARK-MELANCON-2008- ... dZViewItem

his base auto's sell for around $5, his refs around $12-15, his golds $30 and his blacks $35

how much should his printing plate auto's go for? I already made 3 offers which were all auto-declined and I thought they were very fair and I am over the limit of offers. I have contacted him but he was taking 2 days to get back to me each time I replied and finally he stopped contacting me.

Also, I will give anyone who helps me get this into my collection a nice prize

JoshB. · Mar 30, 2009

Not much more than $50 IMO...

XdanX · Mar 30, 2009

I would say 60.

Bruin7 · Mar 30, 2009

Probably around $60-$80.

Allen

trademhigh · Mar 30, 2009

Beavan Sterlings sold around the same last I checked, and I think his plate brought in 60 + shipping. Granted that's 07 sterling, but I still believe it will be about the same. Maybe more if there are any big time yankee 1/1 collectors.

numba1yankeefan · Mar 30, 2009

thanks guys.....my first offer was $50, then $70, then $80 and all were automatically declined

I want this card so bad but how far would you really go? :?

daveyou · Mar 30, 2009

no more than $50 on the plate. plates, with the except of lars for some reason, doesn't sell for as much as people think from sterling

dave

200lbhockeyplayer · Mar 30, 2009

If he auto-declined $80 for that...let him keep it.

In auction, that card would (and should) sell in the $50 range.

bouwob · Mar 30, 2009

agree, let him eat up ebay fees until he decides to list it auction style.

numba1yankeefan · Mar 30, 2009

bouwob said:
agree, let him eat up ebay fees until he decides to list it auction style.

hope he does list it that way

moxacaine · Mar 30, 2009

200lbhockeyplayer said:
If he auto-declined $80 for that...let him keep it.

In auction, that card would (and should) sell in the $50 range.

agree

MTBright · Mar 30, 2009

I would question it getting 50.

numba1yankeefan · Mar 30, 2009

i think i will try contacting him again

thanks guys

predatorkj · Mar 30, 2009

Well he's gotten 8 different offer so yours may have fell short.May want to up the ante.Try contacting him with a higher offer since your out of offers on ebay.

numba1yankeefan · Mar 30, 2009

predatorkj said:
Well he's gotten 8 different offer so yours may have fell short.May want to up the ante.Try contacting him with a higher offer since your out of offers on ebay.

the other offers could have been $30-40 though...will try contacting him again to see what we can do

numba1yankeefan · Mar 30, 2009

just offered him $50 paypal and a 08 donruss threads diamond kings lars anderson auto for it

lets see what happens

numba1yankeefan · Mar 31, 2009

numba1yankeefan said:
just offered him $50 paypal and a 08 donruss threads diamond kings lars anderson auto for it

lets see what happens

he told me he was not interested him and I responded and he hasnt gotten back to me since last night

i hate people like this!

numba1yankeefan · Mar 31, 2009

holy crap! sorry to keep posting but just saw this one now, and it's price!

http://cgi.ebay.com/2008-MARK-MELANCON- ... dZViewItem

my luck

numba1yankeefan · Mar 31, 2009

numba1yankeefan said:
holy crap! sorry to keep posting but just saw this one now, and it's price!

http://cgi.ebay.com/2008-MARK-MELANCON- ... dZViewItem

my luck

apparently $60 is a terrible offer and he wants atleast $150 for it :?

numba1yankeefan · Apr 1, 2009

numba1yankeefan said:
numba1yankeefan said:

holy crap! sorry to keep posting but just saw this one now, and it's price!

http://cgi.ebay.com/2008-MARK-MELANCON- ... dZViewItem

my luck

Click to expand...

apparently $60 is a terrible offer and he wants atleast $150 for it :?

not sure if anyone is reading this but got the guy to go from $400 to $75

very happy!!

just need the other guy to come down

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

How much should a card like this sell for??

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

New member

Active member

Active member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Similar threads

Log in