Will Roy Halladay be traded at this year's deadline?

JEA2880 · May 6, 2009

He's locked up through next season, but I've already started hearing whispers that he might be available at this year's deadline. As a Mets fan, do you think an offer of Jose Reyes for Roy Halladay straight up would do anything for Toronto? Each player switches leagues so they don't have to worry about facing one another. The Jays get a young SS who is signed to an incredibly affordable contract through next year with an option for 2011 that they would definitely exercise, and save a lot of money by dumping Halladay. Obviously the Mets end up with what could be the most dynamic 1-2 combo in baseball history. Am I crazy thinking that this could actually make a lot of sense for both teams?

Edit: Granted, the Jays are in first place right now, but let's be honest - it's only a matter of time before the big boys catch up and grab hold of the division. If they're still competitive by the deadline, this is pretty much moot.

braden · May 6, 2009

No, Halladay will not be traded at the deadline. I firmly believe he will sign an extension.

Ricciardi has said that if he were to ever think about dealing Doc, he'd approach other teams with a mask and a gun because there's no other way he'd be dealt.

And personally, I wouldn't even think for a second about Reyes straight up for Doc. Now, I personally think Reyes is quite overrated so that plays into my reasoning but in my opinion, it doesn't even come close.

scotty21690 · May 6, 2009

Halladay is the staple of their franchise, no way in hell they trade him.

Bigfan5 · May 6, 2009

I actually do think he's traded at the deadline. The usual suspects will all get in line for his services and I think the Dodgers end up with him. They have the minor league talent to trade and given their thin pitching I think they'll be very motivated to deal this time. As much as I hate it I bet that Andrew Lambo is the centerpiece of the trade along with other top prospects and someone like MacDonald who's had some major league experience.

200lbhockeyplayer · May 6, 2009

First off, calling a Halladay/Santana combo "what could be the most dynamic 1-2 combo in baseball history" is extremely far-reaching.

That said, from the outside, I feel that the Mets are indeed looking for a way to get top value for Reyes while getting him out of town and clearly they have major pitching issues...and I think this would help the Mets more than Toronto.

Losing your staff ace is a major hole, and the Blue Jays would need a lot of time to try to get another #1, especially within their system.

Regardless, I think Halladay decides what he wants done. If he wants to retire a Blue Jay, he'll seek the contract extension.

JEA2880 · May 6, 2009

braden said:
And personally, I wouldn't even think for a second about Reyes straight up for Doc. Now, I personally think Reyes is quite overrated so that plays into my reasoning but in my opinion, it doesn't even come close.

I think he's the most overrated player in all of baseball and have said that for a while - as a Mets fan, I want to capitalize on his perceived value before everyone else figures it out too.

200lbhockeyplayer said:
First off, calling a Halladay/Santana combo "what could be the most dynamic 1-2 combo in baseball history" is extremely far-reaching.

How do you figure? Johan is the best pitcher in baseball right now, and I think he has been for the past 5+ years (89-40, 2.77 ERA, 1.02 WHIP and 1233 K's since 2004), while Halladay hasn't done much worse (118-50, 3.20 ERA, 1.13 WHIP and 1090 K's since 2002 which includes his 2 shortened seasons with injuries). Add in the fact that this has all been done in an offensive-oriented era and I don't see how you can argue this would be one of the best 1-2 combos in history?

As far as your point about getting Reyes out of town, I think the first step is sending his boy Minaya packing first. Either way, I hope you're right and they dump him.

dooly · May 6, 2009

There is almost no chance Halladay will be traded at the trade deadline, even if Toronto is out of it. This was supposed to be a rebuilding year for 2010 when all the injured pitchers return, so even without the Jays great start, Halladay would have stuck around. Add in the fact that Halladay likes playing for the Jays and Ricciardi has stated that if he were to ever be traded, he'd need a "boatload", there is almost no chance of this happening. All the rumours you hear are just that, rumours from the papers of big market clubs fantasizing about getting a beast like Doc. I really do believe that Halladay will sign a contract extension, especially if the club continues playing well this year (not necessarily even get to the playoffs, but just show some promise for the future).

theplasticman · May 7, 2009

Hope he stays.

Hallsgator · May 7, 2009

No.

Riccardi would be crucified if he did that and the fans already aren't very found of him.

chisox3706 · May 7, 2009

hopefully to the white sox

...but i doubt it and the jays will probably resign

aarne13 · May 7, 2009

Not a chance. They Jays would want an Allstar or two plus several top prospects. I'm not sure if that would be enough. Halladay is a robot.

MacK · May 7, 2009

It seems like it's always rumored, but I really doubt it actually happens.

JEA2880 · Jul 13, 2009

Bumping this for the "I told you so" factor since it's become very topical

Certainly I don't foresee the Mets being players in any deal at this point, but it sure makes me seem like a legit prognosticator!

abncollectsautos · Jul 13, 2009

Though I would love to see Holliday an Atlanta Brave, I do not think he will be traded. But i do think he will be moved this off season.

Bornagaincollector · Jul 13, 2009

I think the Blue Jays would have to trade Roy Halladay if they want to contend for a w.s. in the future....Yes,he is a Stud and a true #1 starter no doubt.With the Yankees,Boston and the Rays in the Division who have better talent and are more attractive to free agents then the Blue Jays are a .500 or slightly better for the next 4-5 years if they sign him to a extention.If they can trade him can get 1-2 really good mlb roster players now & another 2-3 top prospects.

I believe that would put them closer to contending in the a.l. east then if they keep Halladay.

Thumpersports · Jul 13, 2009

Bornagaincollector said:
I think the Blue Jays would have to trade Roy Halladay if they want to contend for a w.s. in the future....Yes,he is a Stud and a true #1 starter no doubt.With the Yankees,Boston and the Rays in the Division who have better talent and are more attractive to free agents then the Blue Jays are a .500 or slightly better for the next 4-5 years if they sign him to a extention.If they can trade him can get 1-2 really good mlb roster players now & another 2-3 top prospects.

I believe that would put them closer to contending in the a.l. east then if they keep Halladay.

Good pitching beats good hitting. If Marcum and Macgowan and maybe Litsch were healthy, things might be differant right now. The Jays stack up to the big boys in line-up more than some think.

One thing is for certain, if he does get traded, JP will officially become the worst Jays GM in history and public enemy of all Jays fans. That said, why he even still has a chance to pull off a trade is insane anyway. The guy has done nothing and most Jays fans already hate him.

justinmandawg · Jul 13, 2009

There is a big trade looming. I'll drop the info when I get it in for sure.

ryanhoward06 · Jul 13, 2009

justinmandawg said:
There is a big trade looming. I'll drop the info when I get it in for sure.

Phils involved?

justinmandawg · Jul 13, 2009

ryanhoward06 said:
justinmandawg said:

There is a big trade looming. I'll drop the info when I get it in for sure.

Click to expand...

Phils involved?

No sir. If it happens, it's huge.

abncollectsautos · Jul 13, 2009

ryanhoward06 said:
justinmandawg said:

There is a big trade looming. I'll drop the info when I get it in for sure.

Click to expand...

Phils involved?

Acoording to Buster Olney on Baseball Tonight they have the best chance. Since i am an Atlanta fan i sure hope the Phils cant get a deal done.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Will Roy Halladay be traded at this year's deadline?

New member

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

New member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Member

Active member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Similar threads

Log in