Another Poll! Would you do this?

shephech · Oct 22, 2008

Please again I am going to make a decision on this myself, but wondering what you would do Thanks!

I send:
*Alex Rodriguez Allen & Ginter Auto.

I Recieve:
*Albert Pujols Ultimate Collection Dual GU JSY Auto.

*Kevin Durant/Al Horford 07-08 Premier Dual Auto /15

*M.Campbell 08 A&G Auto SP.

*Jess Todd Donruss Elite Red Cut Auto /25

LMK Thanks,

Shep. :ugeek:

FortyFour · Oct 22, 2008

You by a lot.

shuedini · Oct 22, 2008

Seems like a no-brainer to me! Side B...fo' sho'!

95vr4 · Oct 22, 2008

Side B almost doubled side A?

blanning71 · Oct 22, 2008

Nope. I would still keep the Arod. The Pujols is nice but its just an auto'd jersey card. There are a ton of them on the market now a days. The Durant and Horford is a nice card but its a dual subset auto and not a true RC. The other two autos are so so at best. The Arod is a very tough card to come by. I would hold out for something very nice.

FCB NEWS Bottom Line................KEEP AROD AUTO......................AROD AUTO IS SP'ed..............BIG MONEY!!!!!!.......RARE!!!

shephech · Oct 22, 2008

blanning71 said:
Nope. I would still keep the Arod. The Pujols is nice but its just an auto'd jersey card. There are a ton of them on the market now a days. The Durant and Horford is a nice card but its a dual subset auto and not a true RC. The other two autos are so so at best. The Arod is a very tough card to come by. I would hold out for something very nice.

FCB NEWS Bottom Line................KEEP AROD AUTO......................AROD AUTO IS SP'ed..............BIG MONEY!!!!!!.......RARE!!!

Would you top it?

If so let's chat!

Thanks Brian.

Shep. :ugeek:

jeremy · Oct 22, 2008

arod over a scientist and some basketball dudes

if it was a pujols allen and ginter then maybe

blanning71 · Oct 22, 2008

Well I would probably put a 200 bv on the Pujols jersey auto. Seems consistent with other cards that I have seen like that. Card would probably sell somewhere in the 125-150ish range.

Pujols jsy/auto--bv200
durant/horford dual auto ---bv160
Murray Campbell auto--bv50
Jess Todd EEE auto---maybe 25-30bv?

I would love to get that auto from ya as I have discussed with you before. I don't think I have enough to offer you right now. I just don't want you to give up the farm for it as the last three cards in the deal are rather soft. A quick check of completed Durant autos would show you that his stock has fallen for now atleast. A comparative card for the Dual would be an Ultimate dual auto of Durant/Horford #'d to 25 that went for about 76 bucks. If it were still selling over 100 it would be a closer deal. Jump on AIM and we can chat about it.

mlbsalltimegreats · Oct 22, 2008

Side B all the way. A-Rod autos can be had anytime.

wideright · Oct 22, 2008

I would side with those who feel the Arod A&G is worth more than the 4 cards you are getting.

smapdi · Oct 22, 2008

The A-Rod is a 2007, which makes it a tougher choice (keeping a 2006 would be a no-brainer) but I'd still keep it. A&G is an iconic auto set that will be popular for a long time.

The Pujols is nice, but it's a fairly generic card. There's a copy on ebay now, maybe you could gauge your decision from it. I've never been a fan of dual autos, and I don't think either Durant or Horford is going to set the league on fire. There's a copy for sale right now, although the seller is in the Philippines, which will surely affect the price. The Campbell is apparently a $25 card, though it seems to be kind of HTF. The Todd could be good but he is solidly in the sleeper category presently. He jumped 2 levels this year, finishing at AAA at 22, and kept decent numbers at each stop. If he does get heat even briefly, that would be a great item to flip. Side B is surely worth more altogether, presently, and could go up substantially, so if your idea is immediate or short-term resale, that'd probably be a fine deal. If you're keeping any one of those cards, it's a toss-up, and I'd keep the A-Rod.

Guest · Oct 22, 2008

Side B all the way bro, and ARod is my favorite player.

Nice Jess Todd.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Another Poll! Would you do this?

What Would You Do???

Side A (AROD):

Side B (Pujols+):

shephech

New member

FortyFour

New member

shuedini

Well-known member

95vr4

New member

blanning71

Super Moderator

shephech

New member

jeremy

New member

blanning71

Super Moderator

mlbsalltimegreats

New member

wideright

New member

smapdi

Well-known member

Guest

Guest

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts