Would you leave a neg or neutral?

Ryo1549 · May 22, 2009

So i purchased a card on May 6th, bought it now and paid. I just got it today. He told me he had sent it around the 15th. I show on the label he sent it on the 19th. One of the cards did not have a top load was just taped (in a sleeve) ontop of the other card. Cards are fine but a little pissed at the situation. What would you do?

G $MONEY$ · May 22, 2009

Is it a person that sells many sportscards?

Ryo1549 · May 22, 2009

seems like he sells plenty of cards

HoustonTeams4Me · May 22, 2009

I'd leave a positive & dock him heavily on his shipping,communication (heck all of the DSR's or whatever they're called)! You got your item's, they're not damaged, it really wasn't that long of a wait (just saying). It seems many people (I have been included in this group before & had to give myself a dose of reality) have unreal expectation's & sometime's need to give other's a little slack- people make mistakes & I feel that as long as I got what I paid for (as long as it wasn't something that I lost money on because the window for a potential "flip" had passed- although that is different as I would've notified the seller that I need it pronto), then the seller fulfilled thier obligation to me! Do what you feel but IMO this seller doesn't deserve a neut or neg.

matchpenalty · May 22, 2009

I'd neg him. Only thing worse than slow shipping is lying about the date you sent out.

the1mcjensen · May 22, 2009

neutral all the way

Groat · May 22, 2009

It's really up to the buyer. Personally though, I'd leave a positive and just gig him on the stars.

seahawks4ever · May 23, 2009

was the shipping charge ridiculous too? I would go with a neutral if the shipping charge wasn't too bad. I left a neutral to ebay seller mia_ronniebrown just today. 2 weeks to ship, $3.50 for shipping and shipped in half a bubble mailer with scotch tape over the top loader and the card stuck on it.

Pine Tar · May 23, 2009

Positive, you got what you payed for even though it was like over 10 days
I would just hit him on the stars though.

Card Magnet · May 23, 2009

I wouldn't neg him, but I'd use a neutral and keep the stars low on the appropriate categories.

imac220 · May 23, 2009

Ryo1549 said:
So i purchased a card on May 6th, bought it now and paid. I just got it today. He told me he had sent it around the 15th. I show on the label he sent it on the 19th. One of the cards did not have a top load was just taped (in a sleeve) ontop of the other card. Cards are fine but a little at the situation. What would you do?

I have never left someone a neutral, but in this case I would. That knuckle head took almost 20 days to ship the card for goodness sakes! And lying about the shipping date? Thats a no-no.

Ryo1549 · May 23, 2009

I went ahead and left a positive and dinged him on the stars.

vaughn · May 23, 2009

neutral. period.

seahawks4ever · May 23, 2009

Ryo1549 said:
I went ahead and left a positive and dinged him on the stars.

you are such a sweetheart. :mrgreen:

With ebay the way it is now (sellers unable to leave negs) now I am really paying attention to how sellers go about their business. Before the change I had received 2 negs, both from sellers going after me because I was honest about what they did.

TonyButlerStopSuckin · May 24, 2009

Ryo1549 said:
I went ahead and left a positive and dinged him on the stars.

I really think this was the only way to go. Yeah it took a while for him to send out but you got the card in fine condition so I really dont think there is much to complain about. Certainly not enough to warrant a neg or neutral.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Would you leave a neg or neutral?

Ryo1549

New member

G $MONEY$

New member

Ryo1549

New member

HoustonTeams4Me

New member

matchpenalty

New member

the1mcjensen

New member

Groat

New member

seahawks4ever

New member

Pine Tar

Active member

Card Magnet

New member

imac220

New member

Ryo1549

New member

vaughn

New member

seahawks4ever

New member

TonyButlerStopSuckin

New member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts