Question about trade Posey/montero for Betances Red

jdacunha · May 25, 2009

I was offered a Betances Ref Ref Auto BGS 9.5

for

Posey Blue Ref BGS 9.5
Montero BGS 9.5
$200

I am still working on the deal with the guy, but I am not sure how much SV I can get for the Posey Blue, raw they sell for $110-$120, would $160 be fair? The montero goes for $70 so I would have $430 into the Betances, which is a little too much.

How much SV for the Betances, would be fair?
How much SV for the Posey, would be fair?

Nikobaseball · May 25, 2009

I would much rather your side of the deal, just my opinion though.
Posey blue 9.5 probably 160-200 depending on the day.

Messier2 · May 25, 2009

Betances is too risky. I would keep the safe bets (Montero and Posey). JMO.

jdacunha · May 25, 2009

Nikobaseball said:
I would much rather your side of the deal, just my opinion though.
Posey blue 9.5 probably 160-200 depending on the day.

I agree with you. I am still bring his price down on the cash side.

I have found pretty much all 5 Betances Red Refs and everyone is looking for $400 on them. They are all BGS 9.5s

yanksfan4eva · May 25, 2009

i would keep the hitters over the pitcher.
posey and montero both seem to be in the giants/yanks future plans. i could see betances being dangled as trade bait for a late season vet.

jdacunha · May 25, 2009

yanksfan4eva said:
i would keep the hitters over the pitcher.
posey and montero both seem to be in the giants/yanks future plans. i could see betances being dangled as trade bait for a late season vet.

I don't mind trading the Montero's because I have so many. I will have 15 base 9.5s, at least and probably some more BGS 10s.

I don't want to trade the Posey Blue...but I really like the Red Ref...it is a sweet card

yanksfan4eva · May 25, 2009

jdacunha said:
yanksfan4eva said:

i would keep the hitters over the pitcher.
posey and montero both seem to be in the giants/yanks future plans. i could see betances being dangled as trade bait for a late season vet.

Click to expand...

I don't mind trading the Montero's because I have so many. I will have 15 base 9.5s, at least and probably some more BGS 10s.

I don't want to trade the Posey Blue...but I really like the Red Ref...it is a sweet card

true i totally forgot how incredibly deep your montero stash is.

iphoner111 · May 25, 2009

Betances sucks
http://web.minorleaguebaseball.com/milb ... pid=476454

Johan Santana 57 · May 25, 2009

Id say to lessen the blow of $$ include another Montero. You have to be into a lot of them cheaply since the 9.5 get good premiums so if you include one more Montero and lessen the money value even more then it isn't as bad.

HoustonTeams4Me · May 25, 2009

If I were you I would only trade/buy the Betances at the $285 SV mark & that to me is high, especially being that the main thing Betances has going for him in the "Hype" department is the "possibility" of him being a Yankees pitcher (all it would take is a trade & Betances current standing in the "meaningful" prospect rank's would immediately be diminished...or lowered to the point that you would really be kicking yourself in the arse)! IMO, if a trade or purchase is questionable (if I am personally having an internal debate or having noticeable doubt) then I pass on that particular offer & begin building another option/route! Just my opinion though! Good Luck in your decision, Dave.

EricInCT · May 25, 2009

HoustonTeams4Me said:
If I were you I would only trade/buy the Betances at the $285 SV mark & that to me is high, especially being that the main thing Betances has going for him in the "Hype" department is the "possibility" of him being a Yankees pitcher (all it would take is a trade & Betances current standing in the "meaningful" prospect rank's would immediately be diminished...or lowered to the point that you would really be kicking yourself in the arse)! IMO, if a trade or purchase is questionable (if I am personally having an internal debate or having noticeable doubt) then I pass on that particular offer & begin building another option/route! Just my opinion though! Good Luck in your decision, Dave.

For a red ref auto 9.5? Joking?

HoustonTeams4Me · May 25, 2009

EricInCT said:
HoustonTeams4Me said:

If I were you I would only trade/buy the Betances at the $285 SV mark & that to me is high, especially being that the main thing Betances has going for him in the "Hype" department is the "possibility" of him being a Yankees pitcher (all it would take is a trade & Betances current standing in the "meaningful" prospect rank's would immediately be diminished...or lowered to the point that you would really be kicking yourself in the arse)! IMO, if a trade or purchase is questionable (if I am personally having an internal debate or having noticeable doubt) then I pass on that particular offer & begin building another option/route! Just my opinion though! Good Luck in your decision, Dave.

Click to expand...

For a red ref auto 9.5? Joking?

Nope, dead serious!

jdacunha · May 25, 2009

I dont think $285 is a fair price. Atleast $350 for a 9.5...It's a Red Ref

jdacunha · May 25, 2009

Changed the deal up. I am giving up my Blue Montero (o/c) and a montero base auto. and $200...I think its a good deal.

pujolsjunkie · May 25, 2009

jdacunha said:
Changed the deal up. I am giving up my Blue Montero (o/c) and a montero base auto. and $200...I think its a good deal.

That is a strong deal IMO.

jdacunha · May 25, 2009

He just told me he has the Super too. Anyone have any idea what that would go for?

goblue6919 · May 25, 2009

Betances was just placed on the DL. I would stick to lower end cards with him, it's too risky giving up that much for a Betances red ref 9.5.

Invest4thefuture · May 25, 2009

Why is he on the DL?

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Question about trade Posey/montero for Betances Red

New member

New member

New member

New member

Member

New member

Member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Similar threads

Log in