Let's See Some MiLB Updated Top Ten Prospect Lists!

Let's play this as anyone who has had at least some MLB service time as NOT eligible. So no Price, Wieters, Rasmus, McCutchen, Fowler,L etc....

No Porcello, Hanson, Poreda, Snider, etc. as well. But I did not include 2009 Draftees as none of them have debuted yet.


And I am by no means going to get this right either as it's way early, but I just wanted some discussion. This list is also based on ceiling and not current output. More like stats blended with ceiling.


1. Madison Bumgarner
2. Jason Heyward
3. Jarrod Parker
4. Chris Tillman
5. Logan Morrison
6. Neftali Feliz
7. Mike Moustakas
8. Justin Smoak
9. Pedro Alvarez
10. Jesus Montero

Again, I know I am bound to forget someone. But let's see yours!

Thanks.

1) Madison Bumgarner
2) Justin Smoak
3) Jason Heyward
4) Brett Wallace
5) Chris Tillman
6) Jesus Montero
7) Buster Posey
8) Mike Stanton
9) Neftali Perez
10) Logan Morrison
11) Tim Alderson
12) Pedro Alvarez
13) Josh Vitters
14) Mike Moustakas
15) Jake Arrieta
16) Eric Hosmer
17) Jarrod Parker
18) Brain Matusz
19) Tim Beckham
20) Jake Odorizzi (actually maybe Lars Anderson?)

I might be forgetting a top 15 guy or two

Michael Stanton
Madison Bumgarner
Jason Heyward
Jarrod Parker
Neftali Feliz
Justin Smoak
Chris Tillman
Dominic Brown
Brian Matusz
Jesus Montero
Carlos Santana/Logan Morrison

1. Madison Bumgarner
2. Jason Heyward
3. Chris Tillman
4. Jarrod Parker
5. Logan Morrison
6. Justin Smoak
7. Michael Stanton
8. Mike Moustakas
9. Jesus Montero
10. Neftali Feliz

I may have missed someone, but I just did it quick.

trademhigh said:

1. Madison Bumgarner
2. Jason Heyward
3. Chris Tillman
4. Jarrod Parker
5. Logan Morrison
6. Justin Smoak
7. Michael Stanton
8. Mike Moustakas
9. Jesus Montero
10. Neftali Feliz

I may have missed someone, but I just did it quick.

Click to expand...

LOL CMON NOW GUYS

I no order:

Jason Heyward
Madison Bumgarner
Jesus Montero
Chris Tillman
Mike Stanton
Neftali Feliz
Tim Alderson
Justin Smoak
Buster Posey
Jake Arrieta (This kid is nasty!)

jbone17 said:

I no order:

Jason Heyward
Madison Bumgarner
Jesus Montero
Chris Tillman
Mike Stanton
Neftali Feliz
Tim Alderson
Justin Smoak
Buster Posey
Jake Arrieta (This kid is nasty!)

Click to expand...

Now this seams like the actual list but it just needs to be numbered

In no particular order:

Justin Smoak
Jason Heyward
Jake Arrieta
Madison Bumgarner
Buster Posey
Logan Morrison
Pedro Alvarez
Michael Stanton
Lars Anderson
Jarrod Parker

Michael Stanton
Madison Bumgarner
Justin Smoak
Jason Heyward
Jesus Montero
Josh Vitters
Neftali Feliz

ROLLTIDE4LIFE said:

trademhigh said:

1. Madison Bumgarner
2. Jason Heyward
3. Chris Tillman
4. Jarrod Parker
5. Logan Morrison
6. Justin Smoak
7. Michael Stanton
8. Mike Moustakas
9. Jesus Montero
10. Neftali Feliz

I may have missed someone, but I just did it quick.

Click to expand...

LOL CMON NOW GUYS

Click to expand...

The list is based off stats and ceiling .

trademhigh said:

ROLLTIDE4LIFE said:

trademhigh said:

1. Madison Bumgarner
2. Jason Heyward
3. Chris Tillman
4. Jarrod Parker
5. Logan Morrison
6. Justin Smoak
7. Michael Stanton
8. Mike Moustakas
9. Jesus Montero
10. Neftali Feliz

I may have missed someone, but I just did it quick.

Click to expand...

LOL CMON NOW GUYS

Click to expand...

The list is based off stats and ceiling .

Click to expand...

if you are rating on ceiling, then there is no way you can put moustakas ahead of hosmer

GiantsSuperCollector said:

jbone17 said:

I no order:

Jason Heyward
Madison Bumgarner
Jesus Montero
Chris Tillman
Mike Stanton
Neftali Feliz
Tim Alderson
Justin Smoak
Buster Posey
Jake Arrieta (This kid is nasty!)

Click to expand...

Now this seams like the actual list but it just needs to be numbered

Click to expand...

Okay, Lol.

1. Heyward
2. Bumgarner
3. Montero
4. Tillman
5. Stanton
6. Feliz
7. Alderson
8. Smoak
9. Posey
10. Arrieta

Based on who I would draft if I was a GM right now, drafting for an entire career.

Hitters:
1. Moustakas
2. Stanton
3. Heyward
4. Smoak
5. Alvarez

Pitchers:
1. Tillman
2. Bumgarner
3. Arrieta
4. Parker
5. Feliz