Redeem Mystery Card or Buy two Boxes of Razor Sport Icons?

tuftsrunner · Jun 26, 2009

I've been thinking about it for a while now but I pose a question to all...Should I sell my 2009 SP Legendary Cuts mystery Redemption card and buy two boxes of 2009 Razor Sport Icons or Redeem the card and roll the dice? If I buy the two boxes of Sport Icons I get some decent cut signatures, and have a shot at a couple of superstar cuts. On the other hand I could get a monster cut from Upper Deck? Any thoughts?

cgilmo · Jun 26, 2009

tough call

tough call

George_Calfas · Jun 26, 2009

If you paid for a education from Tufts you should know the answer is sell the redemption and buy singles that you want.

cgilmo · Jun 26, 2009

George_Calfas said:
If you paid for a education from Tufts you should know the answer is sell the redemption and buy singles that you want.

how will that satisfy his urge to roll the dice?

tuftsrunner · Jun 26, 2009

Yea, I would rather role the dice with one of the two choices. I think that's the whole appeal of cut signature products like Legendary Cuts and Sport Icons. The chance at the monster cut.

cgilmo · Jun 26, 2009

tuftsrunner said:
Yea, I would rather role the dice with one of the two choices. I think that's the whole appeal of cut signature products like Legendary Cuts and Sport Icons. The chance at the monster cut.

look over the razor checklist

The chance for MOSTER cuts is kinda slim

the chance for a good cut that you will enjoy is high, and the chance for a dog is low

George_Calfas · Jun 26, 2009

tuftsrunner said:
Yea, I would rather role the dice with one of the two choices. I think that's the whole appeal of cut signature products like Legendary Cuts and Sport Icons. The chance at the monster cut.

Bust wax then would be my route.

As Cgilmo mentioned the checklist is nice and you know you are getting at least two encased cards instead of one.

200lbhockeyplayer · Jun 26, 2009

Personally, given the two options I would clearly choose the SP Legendary Mystery Cut signature.

While we can certain that there are some "dogs" in the product, we can be just as certain that there will be some fairly huge potential pulls. The Razor product has less risk, but just a lot less potential gain.

So if it's excitement you want...SP Legendary Cuts.

justwar · Jun 26, 2009

Take it from someone who, waited a year to get a hank stramm cut auto (dreamed about the John Lennon) and just recently saw IN PERSON how sweet the razor icons are. You're still kind of rolling the dice but with the Razor checklist you have a much better shot (percentage-wise) of getting a great hit.

Justin

Kutzy · Jun 26, 2009

I remember my only mystery cut auto from a UD product. I waited 13 months to get a John Travolta. I could have gotten $350 for the redemption, instead got over a year wait and a $100 card.

HoustonTeams4Me · Jun 26, 2009

Personally I'd redeem it (the anticipation & waiting could be torture, but then again it also could be a thrill-ride...all those days speculating & dreaming of the possibilities & "what-if's")! I'd definitely roll the dice on the UD SP Legendary Cuts if I had to choose out of these 2 choice's that you offerred (the Razor stuff just doesn't do it for me)! Just my opinion, good luck either way bud!

Edit: Either way you're in an admirable position to be in!

200lbhockeyplayer · Jun 26, 2009

I'll come clean...I sold my 2009 SP Legendary Cuts Mystery redemption and I'm putting the money into autographs/index cards that I'll make into cards.

But given those two choices...I'd take the chance with the SP Legendary Mystery Cut.

arod305 · Jun 26, 2009

I dont even think its a question. With the mysery cut your actually going to get a cut signature of someone dead, the way cut autos should be.

kentuckyderby · Jun 26, 2009

redeem and buy singles

Rudzud · Jun 26, 2009

kentuckyderby said:
redeem and buy singles

Yes!

Do both!!

i43770 · Jun 26, 2009

Between those two options, I would choose the Razor Sport Icons. If you are looking to sell, they both have about the same percentage that have sold for more than the price of box/redemption. If you are looking to keep them, with the Razor, you will have 2 autos (or more if you pull a dual) compared to 1. They are encased by BGS, so you know they will be protected for almost anything. It is pretty weird looking at completed auctions, there have been more players that are still alive selling for more than the price of a box than the ones that are deceased.

But to another option out there (well it has been mentioned in this thread already), I would sell the redemption and buy some Sports Icons. You can pick up quite a few deceased HOFers for $50 or less.

But on the price of Mystery Cuts, some people got some pretty good deals from this auction site/house: Huggins And Scott

ronfromfresno · Jun 26, 2009

If I had to do over I would have sold my 2008 Mystery Cuts redemption for $300 when I had a chance. I redeemed it and got this card, still haven't been able to sell it at a BIN of $45.

tuftsrunner · Jun 26, 2009

I'm keeping track of what cards have been pulled out of Razor Sport Icons, to see if it's worth it. It's just hard to decide what to do right now since UD hasn't released a checklist yet. As of now I'm leaning towards selling and then buying the Sport Icons boxes while they are still available, not 100% sure yet though.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Redeem Mystery Card or Buy two Boxes of Razor Sport Icons?

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

Active member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

Similar threads

Log in