Who wins on this fantasy trade?

Rudzud · Aug 5, 2009

Player A gets Albert Pujols

Player B gets Josh Johnson, John Lester, Clayton Kershaw, and Matt Garza

Edit:

Player B is in last place for K's and W's

Player A needs offense

rookieaddict · Aug 5, 2009

Doesn't make any sense...did you mean that A needs offense?

Is it a keeper league?

dooly · Aug 5, 2009

hard to say without seeing their whole team but from what you wrote, it seems like it would help them both

it also depends if player B will have enough innings to go around for all the new pitchers he gets. also taking on more players, who would he need to drop

Rudzud · Aug 5, 2009

rookieaddict said:
Doesn't make any sense...did you mean that A needs offense?

Is it a keeper league?

Whoops, mixed that up.

No, not a keeper league just a run of the mill rotto.

Rudzud · Aug 5, 2009

dooly said:
hard to say without seeing their whole team but from what you wrote, it seems like it would help them both

it also depends if player B will have enough innings to go around for all the new pitchers he gets. also taking on more players, who would he need to drop

B would have enough innins and games started available fo rthe rest of the season. His pitching staff is in dire condition and could drop easily drop 4 players.

rookieaddict · Aug 5, 2009

I think B somehow gets the upper hand, at least in terms of what it can do for his season. That's 4 solid contributors. Who would they be replacing pujols with?

kentuckyderby · Aug 6, 2009

If the guy getting the pitchers can replace Pujols with a middle of road 1B then very good deal for him

thefasterblade · Aug 6, 2009

Really depends on the format of the league. If there are playoffs, I likely would give it to team B. If it is strict Roto, I am probably giving it to A, because he has already reaped 3/4 of a season out of those players and has all their stats credited to his pitching staff. He can likely just pick up RP to maintain ERA and WHIP and take the hit in Ks and Ws. Pujols is probably good for about 14 additional HRs this year.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Who wins on this fantasy trade?

Rudzud

New member

rookieaddict

Active member

dooly

New member

Rudzud

New member

Rudzud

New member

rookieaddict

Active member

kentuckyderby

New member

thefasterblade

New member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts