Name the SUPERSTARS of the 80s & 90s who didn't make it

I want to build a list of all the Superstars and Fan Favorites of the 80s and 90s who didn't or won't quite make the cut for the HOF list.
Provide player's name and rookie year for players you think would be classified as a superstar or fan favorite.

Here's a few to start the list...

84 Mattingly
88 Grace
91 Mo Vaughn
93 Jim Edmonds

Edit to add:
I absolutely love the 1999 international refractors, but there are a crazy 440 in the set. I want to just collect the superstars and "FAN FAVORITES" (many of which I already have), help me identify the fan favorites from teams you have watched or stars I may have overlooked. I have bolded all of your inputs that are in the set, thanks for the help. Any final inputs or any that are bolded taht you don't think should fit either category (fan favorites or superstars)?

I can't believe how many of these players I have NEVER EVER HEARD OF. Makes you wonder how many of the 2007,2008,2009, that we think are decent now will soon be forgotten??

WOW, WHAT A LIST!!

#1 Ben Grieve $8.00
#2 Kerry Wood $8.00
#3 Ruben Rivera $8.00
#4 Sandy Alomar Jr. $8.00
#5 Cal Ripken $60.00 S
#6 Mark McGwire $50.00 S
#7 Vladimir Guerrero $20.00 S
#8 Moises Alou $8.00
#9 Jim Edmonds $8.00 S
#10 Greg Maddux $30.00 S
#11 Gary Sheffield $8.00 S
#12 John Valentin $8.00
#13 Chuck Knoblauch $8.00
#14 Tony Clark $8.00 S
#15 Rusty Greer $8.00
#16 Al Leiter $8.00
#17 Travis Lee $8.00
#18 Jose Cruz Jr. $8.00
#19 Pedro Martinez $12.00 S
#20 Paul O'Neill $12.00 S
#21 Todd Walker $8.00 S
#22 Vinny Castilla $8.00 S
#23 Barry Larkin $12.00 S
#24 Curt Schilling $8.00 S
#25 Jason Kendall $8.00 S
#26 Scott Erickson $8.00
#27 Andres Galarraga $8.00 S
#28 Jeff Shaw $8.00
#29 John Olerud $8.00 S
#30 Orlando Hernandez $8.00
#31 Larry Walker $8.00
#32 Andruw Jones $12.00 S
#33 Jeff Cirillo $8.00
#34 Barry Bonds $50.00 S
#35 Manny Ramirez $12.00 S
#36 Mark Kotsay $8.00
#37 Ivan Rodriguez $12.00 S
#38 Jeff King $8.00
#39 Brian Hunter
#40 Ray Durham $8.00
#41 Bernie Williams $12.00 S
#42 Darin Erstad $8.00
#43 Chipper Jones $20.00 S
#44 Pat Hentgen $8.00
#45 Eric Young $8.00
#46 Jaret Wright $8.00
#47 Juan Guzman $8.00
#48 Jorge Posada $12.00 S
#49 Bobby Higginson $8.00
#50 Jose Guillen $8.00
#51 Trevor Hoffman $8.00 S
#52 Ken Griffey Jr. $30.00 S
#53 David Justice $8.00 S
#54 Matt Williams $8.00 S
#55 Eric Karros $8.00
#56 Derek Bell $8.00 S
#57 Ray Lankford $8.00
#58 Mariano Rivera $20.00 S
#59 Brett Tomko $8.00
#60 Mike Mussina $12.00 S
#61 Kenny Lofton $8.00 S
#62 Chuck Finley $8.00
#63 Alex Gonzalez $8.00
#64 Mark Grace $12.00 S
#65 Raul Mondesi $8.00
#66 David Cone $8.00 S
#67 Brad Fullmer $8.00
#68 Andy Benes $8.00
#69 John Smoltz $12.00 S
#70 Shane Reynolds $8.00
#71 Bruce Chen $8.00
#72 Adam Kennedy $8.00
#73 Jack Cust $8.00
#74 Matt Clement $8.00
#75 Derrick Gibson $8.00
#76 Darnell McDonald $8.00
#77 Adam Everett $20.00
#78 Ricardo Aramboles $8.00
#79 Mark Quinn $8.00
#80 Jason Rakers $8.00
#81 Seth Etherton $8.00
#82 Jeff Urban $8.00
#83 Manny Aybar $8.00
#84 Mike Nannini $8.00
#85 Onan Masaoka $8.00
#86 Rod Barajas $8.00
#87 Mike Frank $8.00
#88 Scott Randall $8.00
#89 Justin Bowles $8.00
#90 Chris Haas $8.00
#91 Arturo McDowell $8.00
#92 Matt Belisle $8.00
#93 Scott Elarton $8.00
#94 Vernon Wells $8.00
#95 Pat Cline $8.00
#96 Ryan Anderson $8.00
#97 Kevin Barker $8.00
#98 Ruben Mateo $8.00
#99 Robert Fick $8.00
#100 Corey Koskie $8.00
#101 Ricky Ledee $8.00
#102 Rick Elder $8.00
#103 Jack Cressend $8.00
#104 Joe Lawrence $8.00
#105 Mike Lincoln $8.00
#106 Kit Pellow $8.00
#107 Matt Burch $8.00
#108 Cole Liniak $8.00
#109 Jason Dewey $8.00
#110 Cesar King $8.00
#111 Julio Ramirez $8.00
#112 Jake Westbrook $8.00
#113 Eric Valent $12.00
#114 Roosevelt Brown $8.00
#115 Choo Freeman $12.00
#116 Juan Melo $8.00
#117 Jason Grilli $8.00
#118 Jared Sandberg $8.00
#119 Glenn Davis $8.00
#120 David Riske $8.00
#121 Jacque Jones $8.00
#122 Corey Lee $8.00
#123 Michael Barrett $8.00
#124 Lariel Gonzalez $8.00
#125 Mitch Meluskey $8.00
#126 Freddy Adrian Garcia $8.00
#127 Tony Torcato $8.00
#129 Ntema Ndungidi $8.00
#130 Andy Brown $8.00
#131 Ryan Mills $8.00
#132 Andy Abad $8.00
#133 Carlos Febles $8.00
#134 Jason Tyner $8.00
#135 Mark Osborne $8.00
#136 Phil Norton $8.00
#137 Nathan Haynes $8.00
#138 Roy Halladay $8.00 S
#139 Juan Encarnacion $8.00
#140 Brad Penny $8.00
#141 Grant Roberts $8.00
#142 Aramis Ramirez $8.00 S
#143 Cristian Guzman $8.00
#144 Mamon Tucker $8.00
#145 Ryan Bradley $8.00
#146 Brian Simmons $8.00
#147 Dan Reichert $8.00
#148 Russell Branyan $8.00
#149 Victor Valencia $8.00
#150 Scott Schoeneweis $8.00
#151 Sean Spencer $8.00
#152 Odalis Perez $8.00
#153 Joe Fontenot $8.00
#154 Milton Bradley $8.00
#155 Josh McKinley $8.00
#156 Terrence Long $8.00
#157 Danny Klassen $8.00
#158 Paul Hoover $8.00
#159 Ron Belliard $8.00
#160 Armando Rios $8.00
#161 Ramon Hernandez $8.00
#162 Jason Conti $8.00
#163 Chad Hermansen $8.00
#164 Jason Standridge $8.00
#165 Jason Dellaero $8.00
#166 John Curtice $8.00
#167 Clayton Andrews $8.00
#168 Jeremy Giambi $8.00
#169 Alex Ramirez $8.00
#170 Gabe Molina $8.00
#171 Mario Encarnacion $8.00
#172 Mike Zywica $8.00
#173 Chip Ambres $8.00
#174 Trot Nixon $8.00
#175 Pat Burrell $60.00 S
#176 Jeff Yoder $8.00
#177 Chris Jones $8.00
#178 Kevin Witt $8.00
#179 Keith Luuloa $8.00
#180 Billy Koch $8.00
#181 Damaso Marte $8.00
#182 Ryan Glynn $8.00
#183 Calvin Pickering $8.00
#184 Michael Cuddyer $8.00
#185 Nick Johnson $40.00
#186 Doug Mientkiewicz $20.00
#187 Nate Cornejo $8.00
#188 Octavio Dotel $8.00
#189 Wes Helms $8.00
#190 Nelson Lara $8.00
#191 Chuck Abbott $8.00
#192 Tony Armas Jr. $8.00
#193 Gil Meche $8.00
#194 Ben Petrick $8.00
#195 Chris George $8.00
#196 Scott Hunter $8.00
#197 Ryan Brannan $8.00
#198 Amaury Garcia $8.00
#199 Chris Gissell $8.00
#200 Austin Kearns $60.00 S
#201 Alex Gonzalez $8.00
#202 Wade Miller $8.00
#203 Scott Williamson $8.00
#204 Chris Enochs $8.00
#205 Fernando Seguignol $8.00
#206 Marlon Anderson $8.00
#207 Todd Sears $8.00
#208 Nate Bump $8.00
#209 J.M. Gold $8.00
#210 Matt LeCroy $8.00
#211 Alex Hernandez $8.00
#212 Luis Rivera $8.00
#213 Troy Cameron $8.00
#214 Alex Escobar $12.00
#215 Jason LaRue $8.00
#216 Kyle Peterson $8.00
#217 Brent Butler $8.00
#218 Dernell Stenson $8.00
#219 Adrian Beltre $8.00 S
#220 Daryle Ward $8.00
#221 Jim Thome $12.00 S
#222 Cliff Floyd $8.00
#223 Rickey Henderson $20.00 S
#224 Garret Anderson $8.00 S
#225 Ken Caminiti $8.00 S
#226 Bret Boone $8.00
#227 Jeromy Burnitz $8.00
#228 Steve Finley $8.00 S
#229 Miguel Tejada $8.00 S
#230 Greg Vaughn $8.00 S
#231 Jose Offerman $8.00
#232 Andy Ashby $8.00
#233 Albert Belle $8.00 S
#234 Fernando Tatis $8.00
#235 Todd Helton $12.00 S
#236 Sean Casey $8.00
#237 Brian Giles $8.00
#238 Andy Pettitte $12.00 S
#239 Fred McGriff $12.00 S
#240 Roberto Alomar $12.00 S
#241 Edgar Martinez $12.00 S
#242 Lee Stevens $8.00
#243 Shawn Green $8.00
#244 Ryan Klesko $8.00
#245 Sammy Sosa $20.00 S
#246 Todd Hundley $8.00
#247 Shannon Stewart $8.00
#248 Randy Johnson $20.00 S
#249 Rondell White $8.00
#250 Mike Piazza $30.00 S
#251 Craig Biggio $12.00 S
#252 David Wells $8.00
#253 Brian Jordan $8.00
#254 Edgar Renteria $8.00
#255 Bartolo Colon $8.00
#256 Frank Thomas $20.00 S
#257 Will Clark $12.00 S
#258 Dean Palmer $8.00
#259 Dmitri Young $8.00
#260 Scott Rolen $12.00 S
#261 Jeff Kent $8.00 S
#262 Dante Bichette $8.00
#263 Nomar Garciaparra $30.00 S
#264 Tony Gwynn $25.00 S
#265 Alex Rodriguez $30.00 S
#266 Jose Canseco $12.00 S
#267 Jason Giambi $8.00 S
#268 Jeff Bagwell $12.00 S
#269 Carlos Delgado $8.00 S
#270 Tom Glavine $12.00 S
#271 Eric Davis $8.00
#272 Edgardo Alfonzo $8.00
#273 Tim Salmon $12.00
#274 Johnny Damon $12.00 S
#275 Rafael Palmeiro $12.00 S
#276 Denny Neagle $8.00
#277 Neifi Perez $8.00
#278 Roger Clemens $40.00 S
#279 Brant Brown $8.00
#280 Kevin Brown $12.00
#281 Jay Bell $8.00
#282 Jay Buhner $8.00
#283 Matt Lawton $8.00
#284 Robin Ventura $8.00
#285 Juan Gonzalez $8.00
#286 Mo Vaughn $8.00
#287 Kevin Millwood $8.00 S
#288 Tino Martinez $12.00
#289 Justin Thompson $8.00
#290 Derek Jeter $50.00 S
#291 Ben Davis $8.00
#292 Mike Lowell $8.00 S
#293 Calvin Murray $8.00
#294 Micah Bowie $8.00
#295 Lance Berkman $8.00 S
#296 Jason Marquis $8.00
#297 Chad Green $8.00
#298 Dee Brown $8.00
#299 Jerry Hairston Jr. $8.00
#300 Gabe Kapler $8.00
#301 Brent Stentz $8.00
#302 Scott Mullen $8.00
#303 Brandon Reed $8.00
#304 Shea Hillenbrand $30.00
#305 J.D. Closser $12.00
#306 Gary Matthews Jr. $8.00
#307 Toby Hall $12.00
#308 Jason Phillips $8.00
#309 Jose Macias $8.00
#310 Jung Bong $8.00
#311 Ramon Soler $8.00
#312 Kelly Dransfeldt $8.00
#313 Carlos Eduardo Hernandez $12.00
#314 Kevin Haverbusch $8.00
#315 Aaron Myette $8.00
#316 Chad Harville $8.00
#317 Kyle Farnsworth $12.00
#318 Gookie Dawkins $12.00
#319 Willie Martinez $8.00
#320 Carlos Lee $8.00 S
#321 Carlos Pena $80.00 S
#322 Peter Bergeron $8.00
#323 A.J. Burnett $30.00 S
#324 Bucky Jacobsen $12.00
#325 Mo Bruce $8.00
#326 Reggie Taylor $8.00
#327 Jackie Rexrode $8.00
#328 Alvin Morrow $8.00
#329 Carlos Beltran $12.00 S
#330 Eric Chavez $8.00
#331 John Patterson $8.00
#332 Jayson Werth $8.00
#333 Richie Sexson $8.00
#334 Randy Wolf $8.00
#335 Eli Marrero $8.00
#336 Paul LoDuca $8.00
#337 J.D Smart $8.00
#338 Ryan Minor $8.00
#339 Kris Benson $8.00
#340 George Lombard $8.00
#341 Troy Glaus $12.00 S
#342 Eddie Yarnall $8.00
#343 Kip Wells $12.00
#344 C.C. Sabathia $120.00 S
#345 Sean Burroughs $20.00
#346 Felipe Lopez $50.00
#347 Ryan Rupe $8.00
#348 Orber Moreno $8.00
#349 Rafael Roque $8.00
#350 Alfonso Soriano $150.00 S
#351 Pablo Ozuna $8.00
#352 Corey Patterson $40.00
#353 Braden Looper $8.00
#354 Robbie Bell $8.00
#355 Mark Mulder $50.00 S
#356 Angel Pena $8.00
#357 Kevin McGlinchy $8.00
#358 Michael Restovich $12.00
#359 Eric DuBose $8.00
#360 Geoff Jenkins $8.00
#361 Mark Harriger $8.00
#362 Junior Herndon $8.00
#363 Tim Raines Jr. $8.00
#364 Rafael Furcal $60.00 S
#365 Marcus Giles $30.00
#366 Ted Lilly $8.00
#367 Jorge Toca $12.00
#368 David Kelton $8.00
#369 Adam Dunn $100.00 S
#370 Guillermo Mota $8.00
#371 Brett Laxton $8.00
#372 Travis Harper $8.00
#373 Tom Davey $8.00
#374 Darren Blakely $8.00
#375 Tim Hudson $60.00 S
#376 Jason Romano $8.00
#377 Dan Reichert $8.00
#378 Julio Lugo $20.00
#379 Jose Garcia $8.00
#380 Erubiel Durazo $12.00
#381 Jose Jimenez $8.00
#382 Chris Fussell $8.00
#383 Steve Lomasney $8.00
#384 Juan Pena $8.00
#385 Allen Levrault $8.00
#386 Juan Rivera $30.00
#387 Steve Colyer $8.00
#388 Joe Nathan $40.00 S
#389 Ron Walker $8.00
#390 Nick Bierbrodt $8.00
#391 Luke Prokopec $8.00
#392 Dave Roberts $20.00 S
#393 Mike Darr $8.00
#394 Abraham Nunez $12.00
#395 Giuseppe Chiaramonte $8.00
#396 Jermaine Van Buren $8.00
#397 Mike Kusiewicz $8.00
#398 Matt Wise $8.00
#399 Joe McEwing $12.00
#400 Matt Holliday $120.00 S
#401 Willi Mo Pena $100.00
#402 Ruben Quevedo $8.00
#403 Rob Ryan $8.00
#404 Freddy Garcia $30.00
#405 Kevin Eberwein $8.00
#406 Jesus Colome $8.00
#407 Chris Singleton $8.00
#408 Bubba Crosby $20.00
#409 Jesus Cordero $8.00
#410 Donny Leon $8.00
#411 Goefrey Tomlinson $8.00
#412 Jeff Winchester $8.00
#413 Adam Piatt $8.00
#414 Robert Stratton $8.00
#415 T. J Tucker $8.00
#416 Ryan Langerhans $20.00
#417 Anthony Shumaker $8.00
#418 Matt Miller $8.00
#419 Doug Clark $8.00
#420 Kory DeHaan $8.00
#421 David Eckstein $60.00 S
#422 Brian Cooper $8.00
#423 Brady Clark $30.00
#424 Chris MaGruder $8.00
#425 Bobby Seay $8.00
#426 Aubrey Huff $40.00 S
#427 Mike Jerzembeck $8.00
#428 Matt Blank $8.00
#429 Benny Agbayani $12.00
#430 Kevin Beirne $8.00
#431 Josh Hamilton $200.00
#432 Josh Girdley $8.00
#433 Kyle Snyder $8.00
#434 Mike Paradis $8.00
#435 Jason Jennings $20.00
#436 David Walling $8.00
#437 Omar Ortiz $8.00
#438 Jay Gehrke $12.00
#439 Casey Burns $8.00
#440 Carl Crawford $100.00 S

Would Van Slyke and Murphy qualify in your opinion?

81 Tim Raines
82 Lee Smith
83 Frank Viola
84 Mattingly, Gooden, Strawberry, Saberhagan
85 Hershiser
86 Fielder
87 Larkin

Juan Gonzalez 1990
Jose Canseco 1986
Bo Jackson 1986-1987

Albert Belle

xcantgobackx said:

Albert Belle

Click to expand...

+1 One of the most under-rated players of all-time.

McGwire
Bell (Not Albert)
Barfield
Tartabull

1986 The Crime Dog, Fred McGriff (493 HR, 2490 Hits, .284 BA, 5 time AS)

dale murphy, no reason he shouldnt be a hof'er

orel hershiser and mcgriff belong also

Will Clark - 1986
Harold Baines - 1980
Fernando Valenzuela - 1980
Bobby Bonilla - 1986

^^

Jack Morris

I'd say on that list, these guys are S[strike:35d2ssg0]ponge[/strike:35d2ssg0]-Worthy

Darin Erstad $8.00
Nick Johnson $40.00
Bret Boone $8.00
Sean Casey $8.00
Eric Davis $8.00
Shawn Green $8.00
Eric Chavez $8.00

gvsu96 said:

Jack Morris

Click to expand...

It's a crime he's not in the hall. There's no so-so pitcher who goes 10 innings in a Game 7 of the World Series. Only a Hall of Famer can do that! That should have cemented the Hall for him. Then to go to Toronto and win another one..ooohh...aarrgh...just don't get me started! :evil:

George Bell
Vince Coleman

gracecollector said:

I'd say on that list, these guys are S[strike:l6bp2wkx]ponge[/strike:l6bp2wkx]-Worthy

Darin Erstad $8.00
Nick Johnson $40.00
Bret Boone $8.00
Sean Casey $8.00
Eric Davis $8.00
Shawn Green $8.00
Eric Chavez $8.00

Click to expand...

:lol: Seinfeld references never get old

By no means a superstar, but Jeff Conine was certainly a fan favorite

Andre Dawson
Jack Clark

Can't believe no one said Larry Walker. He was as feared a hitter as there ever was, for a few years anyways. Anyone remember that five year stretch of .366, .363, .379, .309, .350 . Not to mention his statline from '97

.366 BA 49 HR 130 RBI 33 SB .720 SLG% :shock:






-Mike

Will Clark, one of the best clutch hitters in the late '80's early '90's, a career .300 hitter and comparable to Mattingly.