BA Phillies Top 10 is up

mwashuc06 · Nov 9, 2009

1. Domonic Brown, of
2. Kyle Drabek, rhp
3. Michael Taylor, of
4. Travis D'Arnaud, c
5. Trevor May, rhp
6. Anthony Gose, of
7. Sebastian Valle, c
8. Jarred Cosart, rhp
9. Antonio Bastardo, lhp
10. Domingo Santana, of

http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/pr ... 69125.html

Bob Loblaw · Nov 9, 2009

I have no problem with this. Amazing how the system is depleted after trading away Marson, Knapp, Donald, and Carrasco.

Bob Loblaw · Nov 9, 2009

LOVE the fact that they still have love for Scott Mathieson.

http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/pr ... 69125.html

BEST TOOLS
Best Hitter for Average Domonic Brown
Best Power Hitter Michael Taylor
Best Strike-Zone Discipline Domonic Brown
Fastest Baserunner Jiwan James
Best Athlete Jiwan James
Best Fastball Scott Mathieson
Best Curveball Kyle Drabek
Best Slider Mike Stutes
Best Changeup Yohan Flande
Best Control Justin DeFratus
Best Defensive Catcher Travis d'Arnaud
Best Defensive Infielder Freddy Galvis
Best Infield Arm Freddy Galvis
Best Defensive Outfielder Anthony Gose
Best Outfield Arm Domonic Brown

PROJECTED 2013
LINEUP
Catcher Travis d'Arnaud
First Base Ryan Howard
Second Base Chase Utley
Third Base Sebastian Valle
Shortstop Jimmy Rollins
Left Field Jayson Werth
Center Field Shane Victorino
Right Field Domonic Brown
No. 1 Starter Cole Hamels
No. 2 Starter Cliff Lee
No. 3 Starter Kyle Drabek
No. 4 Starter J.A. Happ
No. 5 Starter Trevor May
Closer Ryan Madson

Messier2 · Nov 9, 2009

No Michael Taylor in the "projected 2013" lineup...hmm...he could be trade bait in their mind....

Jaypers · Nov 9, 2009

In his scouting report, they mention the Phillies likely bringing up Drabek as a power reliever, at least at first.

Personally, I think he is good enough to knock someone out of the rotation right from the get-go.

allstars · Nov 9, 2009

Jaypers said:
In his scouting report, they mention the Phillies likely bringing up Drabek as a power reliever, at least at first.

Personally, I think he is good enough to knock someone out of the rotation right from the get-go.

Word around here is that he should be "up" by midseason 2010.

Interesting that they have Cole ahead of Lee in the rotation, makes me think they did this stuff before the playoffs...hopefully Cole just had a bad year. I doubt Madsen will retain a closer role either.

phillyfan0417 · Nov 9, 2009

Jaypers said:
In his scouting report, they mention the Phillies likely bringing up Drabek as a power reliever, at least at first.

Personally, I think he is good enough to knock someone out of the rotation right from the get-go.

Kyle Drabek needs innings. I would definitely let him pitch in the minors another full season.

Really like that list and there are a few players who should be on that list next season. Like I thought last year, D'arnaud is the better catching prospect and i'm glad they held on to him.

Bob Loblaw · Nov 9, 2009

Madson will not and can not close. Surprised they didn't pencil Mathieson in for a closer. . . I suspect he'll be doing it in 2011.

cgilmo · Nov 9, 2009

With a great rookie campaign by JA Happ

he's now bumped up to a possible 4th starter

Jaypers · Nov 9, 2009

::facepalm::

JAYPERS (IL): Just how close was Zach Collier to making your list? Has his 2009 lowered your stock in him any? Why or why not?

John Manuel: Not too close. Haven't gotten a lot of positive reports on Collier, which is disappointing. I was a big believer in him out of HS last year out of the draft and once the Phils got him. He's got tools and there is hitting ability in there, but he just never found a groove or adjusted to the speed of the game this year. Still a Top 30 guy but they have so many toolsy OFs, he wasn't really a serious Top 10 contender; he's been passed by the competition.

cgilmo · Nov 9, 2009

my collier buy is looking pretty sad right about now

Messier2 · Nov 9, 2009

cgilmo said:
my collier buy is looking pretty sad right about now

What did you buy?

mwashuc06 · Nov 9, 2009

cgilmo said:
my collier buy is looking pretty sad right about now

I feel stupid getting a Collier ball signed instead of Sebastian Valle.

trademhigh · Nov 9, 2009

Jeff N. said:
Madson will not and can not close. Surprised they didn't pencil Mathieson in for a closer. . . I suspect he'll be doing it in 2011.

I agree. I think he's definitely closer material.

BowmanChromeAddict · Nov 9, 2009

cgilmo said:
With a great rookie campaign by JA Happ

he's now bumped up to a possible 4th starter

On that list of starters how could he be any higher than a 4th? Does he have potential to be higher than a 4th? Heck yeah, but not among Hamels and Lee, and Drabek clearly has a ceiling up there as well.

muchuckwagon · Nov 9, 2009

cgilmo said:
my collier buy is looking pretty sad right about now

I feel really good now about the gold refractor that I was able to sell at a multiple of the going market rate a few months after the product release because it was 50-50 centering all around.

cgilmo · Nov 9, 2009

Messier2 said:
cgilmo said:

my collier buy is looking pretty sad right about now

Click to expand...

What did you buy?

a lot of 20 base autos

subbed them all to bgs, half gemmed

muchuckwagon · Nov 9, 2009

cgilmo said:
Messier2 said:

cgilmo said:

my collier buy is looking pretty sad right about now

Click to expand...

What did you buy?

Click to expand...

a lot of 20 base autos

subbed them all to bgs, half gemmed

Ouch.....

cgilmo · Nov 9, 2009

muchuckwagon said:
cgilmo said:

Messier2 said:

cgilmo said:

my collier buy is looking pretty sad right about now

Click to expand...

What did you buy?

Click to expand...

a lot of 20 base autos

subbed them all to bgs, half gemmed

Click to expand...

Ouch.....

eh, ive done worse

muchuckwagon · Nov 9, 2009

cgilmo said:
eh, ive done worse

Despite what people tend to post...we all have, if we like to admit it or not.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

BA Phillies Top 10 is up

New member

Active member

Active member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Similar threads

Log in