Grenkie wins Cy Young w/ 17 wins does that help Lincecum?

kdailey4315 said:

Since Grenkie won the Cy Young with 17 wins do you think that helps Lincecum only havinf 15 wins? If Lincecum had a few more wins it wouldn't even be that close to begin with.

Click to expand...

EricInCT said:

kdailey4315 said:

Since Grenkie won the Cy Young with 17 wins do you think that helps Lincecum only havinf 15 wins? If Lincecum had a few more wins it wouldn't even be that close to begin with.

Click to expand...

Please don't be absurd and compare Grenkie to Lincecum.

Click to expand...

kdailey4315 said:

EricInCT said:

kdailey4315 said:

Since Grenkie won the Cy Young with 17 wins do you think that helps Lincecum only havinf 15 wins? If Lincecum had a few more wins it wouldn't even be that close to begin with.

Click to expand...

Please don't be absurd and compare Grenkie to Lincecum.

Click to expand...

Yeah, you're right it's a big insult to Lincecum but I was just talking from a wins stand point. I can see how you would be so offended.

Click to expand...

darocker80 said:

kdailey4315 said:

EricInCT said:

kdailey4315 said:

Since Grenkie won the Cy Young with 17 wins do you think that helps Lincecum only havinf 15 wins? If Lincecum had a few more wins it wouldn't even be that close to begin with.

Click to expand...

Please don't be absurd and compare Grenkie to Lincecum.

Click to expand...

Yeah, you're right it's a big insult to Lincecum but I was just talking from a wins stand point. I can see how you would be so offended.

Click to expand...

Ya i dunno. But I have to say, if greinke beats out felix with 16 wins, i think lincecum can beat out wano with 15 wins. Lincecum has more Ks and lower ERA than wano (lower WHIP, opp BAA, shut outs). But he has that 19 wins. If he won 20 i'd say its game over, but who knows?

Click to expand...

mredsox89 said:

darocker80 said:

kdailey4315 said:

EricInCT said:

kdailey4315 said:

Since Grenkie won the Cy Young with 17 wins do you think that helps Lincecum only havinf 15 wins? If Lincecum had a few more wins it wouldn't even be that close to begin with.

Click to expand...

Please don't be absurd and compare Grenkie to Lincecum.

Click to expand...

Yeah, you're right it's a big insult to Lincecum but I was just talking from a wins stand point. I can see how you would be so offended.

Click to expand...

Ya i dunno. But I have to say, if greinke beats out felix with 16 wins, i think lincecum can beat out wano with 15 wins. Lincecum has more Ks and lower ERA than wano (lower WHIP, opp BAA, shut outs). But he has that 19 wins. If he won 20 i'd say its game over, but who knows?

Click to expand...

But Greinke had an ERA of 1/3 run better than Felix. Linceum's is only .15 better than Wainwright, and .24 WORSE than Carpenters. Only way Lincecum win's is if Carpenter and Wainwright split votes

Click to expand...

mredsox89 said:

No, both STL pitchers have more wins and Carpenter has a better ERA. Greinke was able to win with fewer wins because of a much better era than Felix and CC.

Click to expand...

darocker80 said:

kdailey4315 said:

EricInCT said:

kdailey4315 said:

Since Grenkie won the Cy Young with 17 wins do you think that helps Lincecum only havinf 15 wins? If Lincecum had a few more wins it wouldn't even be that close to begin with.

Click to expand...

Please don't be absurd and compare Grenkie to Lincecum.

Click to expand...

Yeah, you're right it's a big insult to Lincecum but I was just talking from a wins stand point. I can see how you would be so offended.

Click to expand...

Ya i dunno. But I have to say, if greinke beats out felix with 16 wins, i think lincecum can beat out wano with 15 wins. Lincecum has more Ks and lower ERA than wano (lower WHIP, opp BAA, shut outs). But he has that 19 wins. If he won 20 i'd say its game over, but who knows?

Click to expand...

Brett Keith said:

I don't think so. Greinke won because he was clearly the best pitcher in the AL, Lincecum is one of three very good candidates in the NL.

Click to expand...