Who is your 2009 NFL MVP (so far)?

ffgameman · Nov 19, 2009

Up to this point who is your 2009 NFL MVP?

I'm leaning toward Peyton Manning or Brett Favre. Manning is having his usual year....hard to debate his performance. But, I don't think anyone expected Brett Favre to be doing this well; 17 TD, 3 interceptions. Plus, he has helped in the emergence of Sidney Rice as a competent receiver.

lisu · Nov 19, 2009

Drew Brees

Card Magnet · Nov 19, 2009

Favre.

Even though he's on a losing team, CJ is having a spectacular year. I htink if the Titans were winning more, he'd be in the talks.

lumm0x · Nov 19, 2009

lisu said:
Drew Brees

I'm a ridiculous homer but even as a Saints fan I can't say it's Drew. He had god like stats for us last year and look how we finished out. If anyone on the Saints organization could be the MVP it would be Gregg Williams. If I had to pick a player it would be Darren Sharper. Both of those have made more impact on our current record than Drew has, but with that said, without Brees we would be closer to 1-8.

ffgameman · Nov 19, 2009

Brees would be higher on my list if his interception total hadn't picked up over the last few games.

Right for me:

1. Favre
2. Manning (very close behind Favre)
3. Brees
4. Johnson

lumm0x said:
lisu said:

Drew Brees

Click to expand...

I'm a ridiculous homer but even as a Saints fan I can't say it's Drew. He had god like stats for us last year and look how we finished out. If anyone on the Saints organization could be the MVP it would be Gregg Williams. If I had to pick a player it would be Darren Sharper. Both of those have made more impact on our current record than Drew has, but with that said, without Brees we would be closer to 1-8.

sffanmike25 · Nov 19, 2009

Peyton Manning

colts1888 · Nov 19, 2009

It better be manning he has the same numbers but man he has done with with no run game,rookie wide recievers and an injured

trademhigh · Nov 19, 2009

1. Brett Favre
2. Chris Johnson
3. Peyton Manning

Big Mac McGwire · Nov 19, 2009

ummm There is NO DEBATE.

PEYTON. Favre has pro bowlers all around him. Harvin, The O line and The D line.

Peyton is a 1 man show. the colts have no running game. take him off the colts there prolly winless

Ryo1549 · Nov 19, 2009

Peyton Manning hands down.

ffgameman · Nov 19, 2009

Peyton has Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, and a decent defense.

My vote for Favre is largely due to the sheer surprise of his performance. I wouldn't be surprised if my year-end "vote" goes to Manning though.

Big Mac McGwire said:
ummm There is NO DEBATE.

PEYTON. Favre has pro bowlers all around him. Harvin, The O line and The D line.

Peyton is a 1 man show. the colts have no running game. take him off the colts there prolly winless

trademhigh · Nov 19, 2009

Agreed with you completely. Peyton also has Addai. Besides AP, I don't really see who Favre has. Harvin is a Rookie WR, and what does the D Line have to do with this? They don't make Favre play better.

ffgameman said:
Peyton has Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, and a decent defense.

My vote for Favre is largely due to the sheer surprise of his performance. I wouldn't be surprised if my year-end "vote" goes to Manning though.

Big Mac McGwire said:

ummm There is NO DEBATE.

PEYTON. Favre has pro bowlers all around him. Harvin, The O line and The D line.

Peyton is a 1 man show. the colts have no running game. take him off the colts there prolly winless

Click to expand...

Viking4Alpha · Nov 19, 2009

Chris Johnson.

wheeler281 · Nov 19, 2009

Tom Brady.

Card Magnet · Nov 19, 2009

Big Mac McGwire said:
ummm There is NO DEBATE.

PEYTON. Favre has pro bowlers all around him. Harvin, The O line and The D line.

Peyton is a 1 man show. the colts have no running game. take him off the colts there prolly winless

Holy swollen font Batman! :lol:

Peyton is not just a one man show. He has Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark - two of the best at their respective positions.

I think Favre has been laregly responsible for the emergence of Harvin. Harvin would have been good, but I think Favre brought that out sooner. He also took Sidney Rice from a mediocre backup to a solid, reliable WR.

Bigger is better

FAVRE

Gellman · Nov 19, 2009

Peyton Manning, but thats too easy. Favre has too many pieces in place in MN, including the fact that they won two extra games on sheer ******* luck. I say Manning is leading an undefeated team and lighting it up. Thats all it takes.

Johnson should be in consideration though.

ffgameman · Nov 19, 2009

Especially if he continues on pace for 2000 yards.

Being on a losing team tremendously hurts his chances though..

Gellman said:
Peyton Manning, but thats too easy. Favre has too many pieces in place in MN, including the fact that they won two extra games on sheer fracking luck. I say Manning is leading an undefeated team and lighting it up. Thats all it takes.

Johnson should be in consideration though.

tide12champrings · Nov 19, 2009

1. Trent Edwards
2. Dick Juaron
3. Ralph "Elephant Head" Wilson

ffgameman · Nov 19, 2009

No Terrell Owens?

tide12champrings said:
1. Trent Edwards
2. Dick Juaron
3. Ralph "Elephant Head" Wilson

tide12champrings · Nov 19, 2009

ffgameman said:
No Terrell Owens?

tide12champrings said:

1. Trent Edwards
2. Dick Juaron
3. Ralph "Elephant Head" Wilson

Click to expand...

The Bills are ridiculous. Gotta be the worse Franchise in football.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Who is your 2009 NFL MVP (so far)?

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Similar threads

Log in