Topps Redemption. Is this a fair trade?

braves1047 · Feb 12, 2010

I had a redemption for a 2008 cosingers Garrett Olsen Brian Burres Autograph. Topps finally sent me a replacement. It is an uncirulated Adam Lind autograph. I have no idea what set it is out of. It just has a 2009 copyright date. I think Adam Lind is a good player but I liked the co-signers autographs just for the fact you get 2 autos on 1 card. Does this seem like a fair exchange or did they short me?
Here is an example of the card. I am not selling mine.

http://cgi.ebay.com/2009-Topps-Adam-Lin ... 1e5a72cc45

ballcardzdotcom · Feb 12, 2010

braves1047 said:
I had a redemption for a 2008 cosingers Garrett Olsen Brian Burres Autograph. Topps finally sent me a replacement. It is an uncirulated Adam Lind autograph. I have no idea what set it is out of. It just has a 2009 copyright date. I think Adam Lind is a good player but I liked the co-signers autographs just for the fact you get 2 autos on 1 card. Does this seem like a fair exchange or did they short me?
Here is an example of the card. I am not selling mine.

http://cgi.ebay.com/2009-Topps-Adam-Lin ... 1e5a72cc45

I think I'd at least ask for another dual autograph. While I do agree that Lind is a good player, he doesn't yet have the following that other superstars do. Maybe if you push you can get a dual with Adam Lind on it. However, I have found that Topps doesn't give a damn about what you want, only that you get something. Good luck!

Matt

Pine Tar · Feb 12, 2010

Here is mine I had a Allen & Ginter BB Alex Rios Framed Auto Redemption in for I think only Dec 2009
and I go this in the mail today they sent me this Clay Buchholz Auto

goldenegg1 · Feb 12, 2010

I got the same crap Lind card for the same dual auto. They say they are of comparable value, but there is no value on a card they produce for replacements. Topps cs is by far the worst out there!

Pinbreaker · Feb 12, 2010

I just got this in the mail yesterday from a redemption..

Exposfan · Feb 12, 2010

Pinbreaker- I redeemed 5 of that Triple Threads Ryan Braun, all five I received back were white "Patches". Congrats

pigskincardboard · Feb 12, 2010

If that said "Hebrew Hammer" it'd sell for crazy money.

colts1888 · Feb 12, 2010

i too got the lind for the burris dual personally im pretty happy considering what a crap dual the burris olsen is and the fact that the lind is an uncirculated auto i think would sell for more down the line

braves1047 · Feb 12, 2010

Thanks for every ones input. I know Topps cs is bad but i will call and see if I maybe able to get a duel with lind. I still think a duel auto should be replaced with a duel auto. Thats just my two cents. I am not hoping for much from Topps maybe I will get lucky

MacK · Feb 12, 2010

I'm not sure if a Burres/Olson would sell for .99.

The Lind surely would.

rymflaherty · Feb 12, 2010

Where are those uncirculated auto's even from?
Just curious cause I don;t remember any designs like that.

moxacaine · Feb 12, 2010

rymflaherty said:
Where are those uncirculated auto's even from?
Just curious cause I don;t remember any designs like that.

pretty sure they used surplus stickers and made cards to use specifically as replacements.

Kozma Collector · Feb 13, 2010

I received an encapsulated Robinson Cano Auto as a replacement for Brendan Ryan & Chris Duncan Dual Auto Today. Same type of card as the Lind.

MacK · Feb 13, 2010

Kozma Collector said:
I received an encapsulated Robinson Cano Auto as a replacement for Brendan Ryan & Chris Duncan Dual Auto Today. Same type of card as the Lind.

I had that card too.

I got a Markakis/Roberts Dual Autograph from 07 Co-Signers.

ajbraves25 · Feb 13, 2010

There are Lou Pineilla encased autos out there like the Lind. Like what was said before, Topps just made some cards to make up for not sending the cards out.

~AJ

cgilmo · Feb 13, 2010

Lind is worth both of those players combined

TomMurry · Feb 13, 2010

Pinbreaker said:
I just got this in the mail yesterday from a redemption..

sweet XM patch there

Rudzud · Feb 13, 2010

Pinbreaker said:
I just got this in the mail yesterday from a redemption..

Is that an XM radio patch?!?!

Pinbreaker · Feb 13, 2010

Rudzud said:
Pinbreaker said:

I just got this in the mail yesterday from a redemption..

Click to expand...

Is that an XM radio patch?!?!

Yes it is..

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Topps Redemption. Is this a fair trade?

New member

New member

Active member

New member

Well-known member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

Active member

New member

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

New member

New member

Well-known member

Similar threads

Log in