Who would you rather have: Phil Hughes or Mike Pelfrey?

soccerman034 · Jun 13, 2010

Both are now 9-1 with sub 2.7 ERA's, both pitch in New York, and both are acclaimed pitching prospects from the past that have toiled in the majors for the past few years but both now seem to be turning into stars.

Codasco07 · Jun 13, 2010

Hughes and it's not particularly close.

Jays_Cards · Jun 13, 2010

Codasco07 said:
Hughes and it's not particularly close.

Agreed..Hughes has a ton more talent.

AmishDave · Jun 13, 2010

Jays_Cards said:
Codasco07 said:

Hughes and it's not particularly close.

Click to expand...

Agreed..Hughes has a ton more talent.

x3

Dice-K Collector · Jun 13, 2010

Hughes, he is doing it in the AL where the hitting is better. End of story.

matfanofold · Jun 13, 2010

Pelrfey. But I'm a bit biased.

daveyou · Jun 13, 2010

pelfrey by a landslide but im a met fan. heck, i'd take pelfrey over david price. ok, im lying. :lol:

dave

Zymco · Jun 13, 2010

I don't know how its close.. The better choice is Hughes, completely canceling out the fact that he is two years younger.

Jays_Cards · Jun 13, 2010

stevezimmer22 said:
I don't know how its close.. The better choice is Hughes, completely canceling out the fact that he is two years younger.

It's "close" because we have 7 biased Mets fans who have voted thus far. Such is the problem with polls..People cannot ignore bias, even when their choice makes no sense.

NECpilgrims8 · Jun 13, 2010

matfanofold said:
Pelrfey. But I'm a bit biased.

+1

:mrgreen:

thenumberonemetfan · Jun 13, 2010

Jays_Cards said:
stevezimmer22 said:

I don't know how its close.. The better choice is Hughes, completely canceling out the fact that he is two years younger.

Click to expand...

It's "close" because we have 7 biased Mets fans who have voted thus far. Such is the problem with polls..People cannot ignore bias, even when their choice makes no sense.

8 biased Met fans

ThoseBackPages · Jun 14, 2010

Cashburg

markakis8 · Jun 14, 2010

agreed, the only reason Pelfrey has 14 votes is b/c there are at least 12 Mets fan on this board.

Watch both of the pitchers throw for 10 straight games and it is very clear who has the better stuff - Phil Hughes.

and I HATE the Mets AND Yankees.

And I was rooting for the Mets in 2000, that's how much I hate the Yankees.

But the truth is truth.

Jays_Cards said:
stevezimmer22 said:

I don't know how its close.. The better choice is Hughes, completely canceling out the fact that he is two years younger.

Click to expand...

It's "close" because we have 7 biased Mets fans who have voted thus far. Such is the problem with polls..People cannot ignore bias, even when their choice makes no sense.

Jays_Cards · Jun 18, 2010

Mets fans are a joke...

http://www.nypost.com/p/sports/yankees/ ... dXX1pqBTbM

schmidtfan20 · Jun 18, 2010

Id take Moyer and 8 million.

Jays_Cards · Jun 18, 2010

schmidtfan20 said:
Id take Moyer and 8 million.

And once again, you would be an idiot. I guess that is to be expected, however.

Zymco · Jun 18, 2010

Its all good because they are facing off against each other on the 19th

daveyou · Jun 18, 2010

im going to the game tonight. i was so hoping this matchup was tonight but that stupid off day on monday.....now i get to see taka vs vaz. ::facepalm:: :lol: beer.....need beer...

dave

ThoseBackPages · Jun 18, 2010

Both!

Y4NK335 · Jun 18, 2010

Joel Sherman of the New York Post asked 12 baseball insiders whether they would prefer to have Phil Hughes or Mike Pelfrey for the next five years and was surprised to see all 12 select Hughes.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Who would you rather have: Phil Hughes or Mike Pelfrey?

Who would you rather have on your team right now: Mike Pelfrey or Phil Hughes?

Mike Pelfrey

Phil Hughes

New member

Active member

Active member

Featured Contributor, Collector Showcase, Senior M

New member

Active member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Similar threads

Log in