Trade Opinion - Let's Hear From the Peanut Gallery

mudflap02 · Jul 1, 2010

This is kind of a difficult trade since values on both sides can be all over the map. Would you call this an even trade, or no?

Side A -
2003 Bowman Heritage Signs of Greatness Robinson Cano RC auto
2005 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks Brett Gardner Blue Refractor /150

Side B -
2007 Topps '52 Rookies Combo Signatures Ryan Braun / Hunter Pence /25
2007 Bowman Sterling Red Refractors Jake Fox 1/1

Any input is greatly appreciated.

cjb9421 · Jul 1, 2010

mudflap02 said:
This is kind of a difficult trade since values on both sides can be all over the map. Would you call this an even trade, or no?

Side A -
2003 Bowman Heritage Signs of Greatness Robinson Cano RC auto
2005 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks Brett Gardner Blue Refractor /150

Side B -
2007 Topps '52 Rookies Combo Signatures Ryan Braun / Hunter Pence /25
2007 Bowman Sterling Red Refractors Jake Fox 1/1

Any input is greatly appreciated.

Would rather have a Cano RC auto...only RC AU too.

hoopster3977 · Jul 1, 2010

cjb9421 said:
mudflap02 said:

This is kind of a difficult trade since values on both sides can be all over the map. Would you call this an even trade, or no?

Side A -
2003 Bowman Heritage Signs of Greatness Robinson Cano RC auto
2005 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks Brett Gardner Blue Refractor /150

Side B -
2007 Topps '52 Rookies Combo Signatures Ryan Braun / Hunter Pence /25
2007 Bowman Sterling Red Refractors Jake Fox 1/1

Any input is greatly appreciated.

Click to expand...

Would rather have a Cano RC auto...only RC AU too.

Bingo!

I wish I hadn't sold my Cano a couple of years ago.

mudflap02 · Jul 1, 2010

Bump for more responses. Interesting to me that with 25 responses to the poll, only 3 people say this is an even trade.

ajbraves25 · Jul 1, 2010

I went with side A. With the Cano "RC" auto its not even close. I know there is a 1/1 and a dual auto #/25, but side A gets a true rookie blue refractor and the Cano Heritage auto.

~AJ

Phishmon23 · Jul 1, 2010

pretty even I think, but I'd rather have A

AmishDave · Jul 1, 2010

I like side B. Just because you don't see those duals up that often. Plus, it's two pretty solid players.

I'd do A if you're looking to flip now.

vetsgt02 · Jul 1, 2010

I liek side B I think do not think Cano holds any long term value and the 1/1 and double auto you have a better chance of making a profit later on.

cubfan131 · Jul 1, 2010

I'd much rather have side B. Cano's value has been all over the map and this is probably the high point and Gardner is overrated.

mudflap02 · Jul 1, 2010

Bump for a couple more responses. Still weird to me that only about 10% would call this even, with so many voting for one side or another.

Thanks again for all who have helped.

JoshHamilton · Jul 1, 2010

Jeff if I were you, side B in a landslide. Tough dual auto for a set you collect, plus an Oriole 1/1

mudflap02 · Jul 1, 2010

Yeah, it seems like a win/win/win. I collect the '52 auto set, he collects Cano and Yankees, but the values for both are tough to nail down.

JoshHamilton is the President of the Peanut Gallery from what I'm told.

bowmanchromeandorr · Jul 1, 2010

side eh

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Trade Opinion - Let's Hear From the Peanut Gallery

Which side is getting the better deal?

Side A

Side B

Even Steven

mudflap02

Active member

cjb9421

Active member

hoopster3977

New member

mudflap02

Active member

ajbraves25

Active member

Phishmon23

New member

AmishDave

Featured Contributor, Collector Showcase, Senior M

vetsgt02

New member

cubfan131

New member

mudflap02

Active member

JoshHamilton

Well-known member

mudflap02

Active member

bowmanchromeandorr

New member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts