BA's 2009 Philadelphia Phillies Top 10 Prospects

Brett Keith · Jan 3, 2009

NL East issue arrived today. Nats coming in another thread.

1 - Dominic Brown
2 - Carlos Carrasco
3 - Lou Marson
4 - Jason Donald
5 - Kyle Drabek
6 - Michael Taylor
7 - Travis D'Arnaud
8 - Zach Collier
9 - J.A. Happ
10 - Jason Knapp

Best Tools

Best Hitter For AVG - Dominic Brown
Best Power Hitter - Michael Taylor
Best K-Zone Discipline - Lou Marson
Fastest Baserunner - Quinton Berry
Best Athlete - Anthony Hewitt
Best Fastball - Carlos Carrasco
Best Curve - Kyle Drabek
Best Slider - Mike Stutes
Best Change - Carlos Carrasco
Best Control - Mike Cisco
Best Defensive Catcher - Lou Marson
Best Defensive Infielder - Fraddy Galvis
Best Infield Arm - Fraddy Galvis
Best Defensive Outfielder - Anthony Gose
Best Outfield Arm - Dominic Brown

Projected 2012 Lineup

C - Lou Marson
1B - Ryan Howard
2B - Chase Utley
3B - Jason Donald
SS - Jimmy Rollins
LF - Michael Taylor
CF - Shane Victorino
RF - Dominic Brown
1 - Cole Hamels
2 - Carlos Carrasco
3 - Kyle Drabek
4 - Brett Myers
5 - Joe Blanton
Closer - Brad Lidge

studmack2004 · Jan 3, 2009

I was right for a change...I knew it would be Dominic Brown

bballcardkid · Jan 3, 2009

I was too. It wasn't Collier!!!

ryanhoward06 · Jan 3, 2009

That's a little ridiculous to have Brown at number 1.

Nick1190 · Jan 3, 2009

Nice.

jlvjr16 · Jan 3, 2009

Imma have to run down stairs from the 5th floor to open my mailbox to take the issue out. :shock:

ballerskrip · Jan 3, 2009

HILARIOUS that people thought it would be Collier. I swear, when a new player gets a chrome auto, "they must be the #1 prospect on the team"!!!

hahaha

ryanhoward06 · Jan 3, 2009

ballerskrip said:
HILARIOUS that people thought it would be Collier. I swear, when a new player gets a chrome auto, "they must be the #1 prospect on the team"!!!

hahaha

I was going to post on the other thread that I thought 8 would be about right.

Jaypers · Jan 3, 2009

Brett, could you give us the 2012 Lineup cards for both the Nats and Phils? Thanks.

Jaypers · Jan 3, 2009

ballerskrip said:
HILARIOUS that people thought it would be Collier. I swear, when a new player gets a chrome auto, "they must be the #1 prospect on the team"!!!

hahaha

Yes, why don't all of us have professional jobs in scouting departments like you do? Hahahahahahaha.

moxacaine · Jan 3, 2009

I would move it around slightly.

1 - Carlos Carrasco
2 - Lou Marson
3 - Michael Taylor
4 - Kyle Drabek
5 - Jason Donald
6 - Dominic Brown
7 - Travis D'Arnaud
8 - Zach Collier
9 - J.A. Happ
10 - Jason Knapp

ballerskrip · Jan 3, 2009

Jaypers said:
ballerskrip said:

HILARIOUS that people thought it would be Collier. I swear, when a new player gets a chrome auto, "they must be the #1 prospect on the team"!!!

hahaha

Click to expand...

Yes, why don't all of us have professional jobs in scouting departments like you do? Hahahahahahaha.

I think you have taken me the wrong way. I like collier. I was making more of a blanket statement, than just about Collier. It seems every year, there are a handful of players that are Over-rated by us prospectors based SOLELY on their inclusions in card sets.... Not sure what that has to do with my time with the Angels.

skrip

andyduke86 · Jan 3, 2009

ballerskrip said:
HILARIOUS that people thought it would be Collier. I swear, when a new player gets a chrome auto, "they must be the #1 prospect on the team"!!!

hahaha

The Michael Burgess Effect.

Jaypers · Jan 3, 2009

ballerskrip said:
Jaypers said:

ballerskrip said:

HILARIOUS that people thought it would be Collier. I swear, when a new player gets a chrome auto, "they must be the #1 prospect on the team"!!!

hahaha

Click to expand...

Yes, why don't all of us have professional jobs in scouting departments like you do? Hahahahahahaha.

Click to expand...

I think you have taken me the wrong way. I like collier. I was making more of a blanket statement, than just about Collier. It seems every year, there are a handful of players that are Over-rated by us prospectors based SOLELY on their inclusions in card sets.... Not sure what that has to do with my time with the Angels.

skrip

Your earlier statement came off to me as condescending, especially the laughter. It's one thing to be convinced a player will be #1 according to BA, and it's another to HOPE he will be.

kentuckyderby · Jan 3, 2009

Blanton still in the rotation in 2012 would solidify the Cardenas trade even more

Wonder if he will have any more playoff HRs

Brett Keith · Jan 3, 2009

Good thing I got $250 for this, otherwise I'd be upset.

ballerskrip · Jan 3, 2009

Jaypers said:
ballerskrip said:

Jaypers said:

ballerskrip said:

HILARIOUS that people thought it would be Collier. I swear, when a new player gets a chrome auto, "they must be the #1 prospect on the team"!!!

hahaha

Click to expand...

Yes, why don't all of us have professional jobs in scouting departments like you do? Hahahahahahaha.

Click to expand...

I think you have taken me the wrong way. I like collier. I was making more of a blanket statement, than just about Collier. It seems every year, there are a handful of players that are Over-rated by us prospectors based SOLELY on their inclusions in card sets.... Not sure what that has to do with my time with the Angels.

skrip

Click to expand...

Your earlier statement came off to me as condescending, especially the laughter. It's one thing to be convinced a player will be #1 according to BA, and it's another to HOPE he will be.

I wasn't trying to be condescending at all, sorry to all if it came off that way. I seem to put the "hahah" due to habit over anything else at this point. Again, I like Collier. I didn't think he had any chance of being #1 however. There are far too many proven guys on this list to put Collier in the top 3.

ballerskrip · Jan 3, 2009

I LOVE seeing the Drabek comeback also, I forgot to mention that!

There are some people that are getting excited about him, I have sold (3) of his cards out of my store in the last week, Gold and Blue 9.5's!

ryanhoward06 · Jan 3, 2009

ballerskrip said:
I LOVE seeing the Drabek comeback also, I forgot to mention that!

There are some people that are getting excited about him, I have sold (3) of his cards out of my store in the last week, Gold and Blue 9.5's!

On PhuturePhiies a lot of there poster seem to be getting excited about him. He got some good scouting reports when he pitched in Hawaii. He's supposed to be more mature now too.

- Ryan

tide12champrings · Jan 3, 2009

Brett Keith said:
Good thing I got $250 for this, otherwise I'd be upset.

I was about to ask if you still had that beauty.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

BA's 2009 Philadelphia Phillies Top 10 Prospects

Active member

New member

New member

New member

Banned

New member

New member

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

New member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Similar threads

Log in