- Thread starter
- #1
Ryo1549
New member
This was discussed on ESPN I believe. Does Michael Vick deserve it? To me Peyton Manning is the MVP imo. Who do you think?
Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
Nice choice, didn't think of him cause I'm a homer but a very good choice.Cadillac was ineffective the first two weeks and they relied on Freeman's arm.schmidtfan20 said:Josh Freeman
wheeler281 said:Vick has played 4 games. Just not fair based on such a small body of work to consider him. Just can't be a victim of the moment after last night.
I am all for Rivers who is playing with garbage while putting up awesome numbers and is on pace to crush Marino's record
bradical said:Matt Ryan
KandKCards said:I'll get killed for being a homer, but Brady. Just torched the league's #1 defense throwing to a rookie TE, essentially a rookie WR (Tate), after having lost his #1 target. The Pats have one of the youngest defenses in the league, putting even more pressure on him. Not to mention his team is 7-2, tied for the best record in the league.
After that, I have trouble choosing Vick, Rivers or Manning. Vick just hasn't played enough games yet. If he continues on his current pace, it's definitely him. Rivers has been amazing with practice squad WRs, but his team isn't winning and has only really played one tough team, which they lost. I put him on offensive POY category, not MVP. Manning...they have a lot of injuries, but they still have Reggie Wayne, who is light years better than anyone the Chargers/Patriots have (other than Gates who has been banged up, so I don't count him), and still has the same OL that has kept him perfectly upright the last few years. Also, they haven't played anyone. 1-1 against the Texans (they suck), struggled to a win against KC (who are proving to be the definition of mediocre), and he did nothing in a win vs. a bad Cincy team (they never would've won without the defense/Carson Palmer).