"___ _______" just announced his retirement, HOFer, right?

reljac said:

Here's what the other HoF statistics on him, all of which point to no HoF and one says not even close

Player rank in (·)

Gray Ink Batting - 60 (416), Average HOFer ? 144
Hall of Fame Monitor Batting - 88 (189), Likely HOFer ? 100
Hall of Fame Standards Batting - 39 (165), Average HOFer ? 50



Blyleven who was credited with being helped by WAR, ranked as a HoFer in all three of the above.

Click to expand...

IndyMann said:

Might as well put Blyleven and Mazeroski in. Oh wait.

Click to expand...

morgoth said:

IndyMann said:

Might as well put Blyleven and Mazeroski in. Oh wait.

Click to expand...

Both of those guys aren't even in the top 10 of worst choices.

Click to expand...

ThoseBackPages said:

i think we have to have some kind of "correction" when it comes to getting into THE HALL OF FAME.
too many players are getting in. thats my belief, and im entitled to that.

Now that Pettitte and Edmonds have retired, people are ready to put them into THE HALL OF FAME.

give me a god damned break. Take the WAR and all that other stat nonsense and shove it.

LETS RAISE THE "HOF" BAR ALREADY

Click to expand...

ThoseBackPages said:

i think we have to have some kind of "correction" when it comes to getting into THE HALL OF FAME.
too many players are getting in. thats my belief, and im entitled to that.

Now that Pettitte and Edmonds have retired, people are ready to put them into THE HALL OF FAME.

give me a god damned break. Take the WAR and all that other stat nonsense and shove it.

LETS RAISE THE "HOF" BAR ALREADY

Click to expand...

bodiaz said:

ThoseBackPages said:

i think we have to have some kind of "correction" when it comes to getting into THE HALL OF FAME.
too many players are getting in. thats my belief, and im entitled to that.

Now that Pettitte and Edmonds have retired, people are ready to put them into THE HALL OF FAME.

give me a god damned break. Take the WAR and all that other stat nonsense and shove it.

LETS RAISE THE "HOF" BAR ALREADY

Click to expand...

I agree, but it's too late. They let to many good players in already. You should be great to get in, but Jim Rice, Tony Perez and others were put in, so it is not relevant anymore. I say at this point, who cares!

Click to expand...

Brewer Andy said:

Edmonds is first ballet in my own personal Hall of Fame and I doubt anyone would change my mind nor am I inviting anyone to try. Best CF in my life time not named Griffey. Just my opinion and I respect yours. These debates give me a headache. I therefore try not to lose any sleep over who you want to put in yours or who the Official Hall wants to keep out of theirs. Good discussion yes, worth raising my blood pressure over no

Click to expand...