Thoughts on this trade?

sportscardfreak31 · Jul 10, 2011

thoughts on this trade? Haven't accepted
I send him:
2009 Tribute David Wright Jsy/auto /75
2011 Tribute carlton fisk dual bat /99
red sox base
For
2009 Triple threads Jonathon papelbon triple All star patch /9
2009 triple threads Jose Reyes 6xrelic /27 or /36

LMK guys!!

EDIT:
Thanks guys! I managed to swing
His
Mike Stanton Topps Chrome BGS 9.5 AUTO (10 auto)
strasburg 10 PSA topps chrome rookie
Andrew McCutchen "CUTCH" Triple threads (patches) /18
for my
Dan williams 3clr patch auto /15 (dont collect football got it for free)
Andre Dawson Jsy auto /75
david wright jsy auto /75

blanning71 · Jul 10, 2011

I think its about even. You're trading an auto and a game used with some base for two relics. The papelbon is a nice card and the All Star patch cards from Triple Threads are sought after. He's lost some luster over the last couple of years but I think you'll do ok. The Reyes could bring in something nice now that trade talks are surfacing about him. Good luck whichever way you go.

sportscardfreak31 · Jul 10, 2011

blanning71 said:
I think its about even. You're trading an auto and a game used with some base for two relics. The papelbon is a nice card and the All Star patch cards from Triple Threads are sought after. He's lost some luster over the last couple of years but I think you'll do ok. The Reyes could bring in something nice now that trade talks are surfacing about him. Good luck whichever way you go.

Im still Newer to Serious card collecting (1 year) And i just really needed help. Reyes Is on fire, And that could be major trade bait.. i have 'till tonight to answer him.. if each comment is saying do it (atleast 80% ) i think i may do it.

sportscardfreak31 · Jul 10, 2011

guys NEED TO KNOW

blanning71 · Jul 10, 2011

I think you should go with your own gut and make the decision for yourself. Don't let us influence your trade. You do what YOU want to do and get what YOU think is fair in return. Afterall, you are the one that will end up with the cards in your hand. Not us.

sportscardfreak31 · Jul 10, 2011

blanning71 said:
I think you should go with your own gut and make the decision for yourself. Don't let us influence your trade. You do what YOU want to do and get what YOU think is fair in return. Afterall, you are the one that will end up with the cards in your hand. Not us.

my gut says I don't know ... I understand the cards come to me and you guys aren't giving anything nor recieving anything in this deal. I'm just trying to see what people with more hobby knowlege think of this deal..
Thanks!

Lancemountain · Jul 10, 2011

I would do it in a second. I think those triple threads all star cards are awesome and sell much better than tribute /99 any day

blanning71 · Jul 10, 2011

If you're going blind I might suggest you do some research. Look at completed sales on ebay of each players cards. Look at their current stock in MLB. What are you planning on doing with the stuff when you get it in? If you don't leap, you'll never fly. Take a chance. Thats how I started. I did my homework and became sharp in my skills. Gotta be handy with the steel if you know what I mean.....earn your keep.

schmidtfan20 · Jul 10, 2011

pretty even.

Kevin

alabamalongsnake · Jul 11, 2011

i probably wouldn't do it because i don't like giving up autos for just game used. plus carlton fisk is a hall of famer. you know his stuff isn't going down.

sportscardfreak31 · Jul 11, 2011

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Thoughts on this trade?

sportscardfreak31

New member

blanning71

Super Moderator

sportscardfreak31

New member

sportscardfreak31

New member

blanning71

Super Moderator

sportscardfreak31

New member

Lancemountain

Active member

blanning71

Super Moderator

schmidtfan20

Active member

alabamalongsnake

New member

sportscardfreak31

New member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts