Would you rather have.......

Ryo1549 · Feb 8, 2009

I am going through some PC changes....

Just sold a card, probably shouldn't have but ohwell...soooo

Would you rather have

a Auto'd Jersey card #'d to the person's jersey # say 10/10

or

a BGS/PSA 9 Rookie card

Also this is a pre-1987 player who is a hall of famer.

Viking4Alpha · Feb 8, 2009

This is just me but I'd go with the auto/gu before I went with the RC...

KOBEARODLT · Feb 8, 2009

i would rather have the auto/game used but i know alot of people will say the rookie..

flightposite · Feb 8, 2009

Depends on the player, brand of card of the gu/auto, rarity of the amount of decent grade product from his rookie year.

Guest · Feb 8, 2009

I would say RC depending on the player (old School) I'm 46 years old
so old vintage RC for me.

But I would also want new blood Auto/GU of today's guys.

G $MONEY$ · Feb 8, 2009

Really depends on the player with me as well. If it was say, Joe Montana, i would take the RC, as that is in iconic card that is somewhat limited in great condition like that. If it was a player whose RC wasn't worth as much or as hard to find in a BGS/PSA 9, like say Jim Kelly's RC, id take the auto/patch for sure.

-Bilko

Brad · Feb 9, 2009

Tough call, I would probably want Montana RC over the auto. If it was Jerry Rice, perhaps a toss up. Steve Young, I would take the auto (and I am just throwing out 49ers in specualtion

) If it is an on card auto, that definitely helps.

sffanmike25 · Feb 9, 2009

Would take the graded RC.

madman1978 · Feb 9, 2009

A HOF Graded RC over a super patch card
Why?
the investment will never go down!

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Would you rather have.......

Ryo1549

New member

Viking4Alpha

New member

KOBEARODLT

New member

flightposite

Active member

Guest

Guest

G $MONEY$

New member

Brad

Active member

sffanmike25

New member

madman1978

Active member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts