Most collected Non-HOF Modern Player in your opinion ...

ThoseBackPages said:

Most collected Non-HOF Modern Player that is/was eligible, but isnt in. So that strikes these names off the list:

Rose
McGwire
Gonzalez
Griffey

I really think the answer is Don Mattingly, judging by his PSA 10 pricing he's doing quite well

Click to expand...

rookieaddict said:

ThoseBackPages said:

Most collected Non-HOF Modern Player that is/was eligible, but isnt in. So that strikes these names off the list:

Rose
McGwire
Gonzalez
Griffey

I really think the answer is Don Mattingly, judging by his PSA 10 pricing he's doing quite well

Click to expand...

Griffey isn't eligible yet

Click to expand...

rookieaddict said:

ThoseBackPages said:

Most collected Non-HOF Modern Player that is/was eligible, but isnt in. So that strikes these names off the list:

Rose
McGwire
Gonzalez
Griffey

I really think the answer is Don Mattingly, judging by his PSA 10 pricing he's doing quite well

Click to expand...

Griffey isn't eligible yet

Click to expand...

MOFNY said:

Jeter, Pujols

Click to expand...

Brewer Andy said:

The board's Will The Thrill thread might have something to say about Donnie Baseball. I would think that along with Clark, Bo Jackson is up there as well, maybe more on the football side? Just guessing

Click to expand...

gmarutiak said:

I don't understand why McGwire and Gonzalez are on the list of names that don't work. I'm not even drunk. Just slow, I guess.

Click to expand...

leatherman said:

Just throwing it out there, but what about Hideo Nomo?

Click to expand...

JoshHamilton said:

McGwire and Gonzalez are both eligible for the Hall Of Fame

Way to **** all over your own guidelines

Click to expand...

ThoseBackPages said:

Nomo and Murphy are good ones indeed.

ive never checked Nomo's PSA 10 status, but with the Japan angle, im sure they're up there

Click to expand...