I tend to agree with you on this being the same person, Brad. The wide chin is what i see linking them. Could be the angle of the photo but that man has huge hands.
I think it's ridiculous PSA won't reslab these for free. I've gotten them back from PSA already wrinkled. Just another way they screw you at PSA. Won't be long and they will be "updating" their slabs so you'll have to reslab again to keep your collection looking uniform. Just a joke.