I totally agree. Especially when making a Hall of Fame case, using the amount of All Star Game appearances is ridiculous. Just look at Joey Votto, he won the MVP this year and almost didn't make the all star team.
Re: Who was the greatest POST-WAR pitcher?
You could argue his team was great because he was on it. I think his peak years were as good as anyones. From 92-98 the guy was as good as anyone.
Re: Who was the greatest POST-WAR pitcher?
Sure I'm slightly biased but Maddux is 1st among post war pitchers in wins. And top 10 all time in strike outs.