The odds of pulling any one specific 2014 Topps Platinum 1/1 are 1:8,415,000. That's a 330 card set at 1:25500; pulling any one specific card, be it Puig or Coco Crisp, the odds are 1 in over 8 million.
Ignoring the fact that more than one of those A-Rods exist, the odds seem so high because it is basically a one card set (they only did the Super for the 1994 reprint). Say Topps did a 1/1 Super for each of the four reprint years; your odds of pulling a Super auto go from 1:614088 to 1:153522 or so. Pulling the exact 1994 would still be 1:614088, which is still not as high as pulling that one exact Platinum.