- Thread starter
- #1
JoshHamilton
Well-known member
- Aug 7, 2008
- 12,205
- 320
I've started slowly collecting the rookies from this set and I'm getting confused. Every list - PSA, Cardboard Connection, SGC, Beckett, etc - has a slightly different list, but around 60 names are consistent. Ruling out everyone who had Topps rookies before Star came around is a given, but after that it gets a bit murky. Take Mark Aguirre and Jay Vincent, for example. Both drafted in '81, both have previous Star cards, and neither have anything else pre-Fleer. Aguirre is universally regarded as a RC, while Vincent is not. Same with '82 draftees Terry Teagle and Dominique Wilkins. No one lists Teagle as a RC, yet 'Nique is.
What's the deal?
What's the deal?