I, personally, don't touch ACE... but it could be fine on a case-by-case basis.
That said. It SEEMS okay, but I'd be a little put off by the fact that it was cut out of the full check, since there's likely other things on the full check that could help authenticate it.
I will be blunt:
Charles Radbourn is one of the toughest autographs out there, and ACE is one of the worst authenticators. They are rightfully banned from eBay, and I have seen countless fakes authenticated by them. Unfortunately, I think this is one of them.
If you believe it's real and want to sell it, you would really need to get either JSA or PSA/DNA to authenticate it, which (without looking) I'm going to guess would cost you $200+. And I think you'll kiss that goodbye because I think they'll say it's no good. I've been wrong before and could be wrong here, but I collect HOF autographs and am not interested in that Radbourne because of the ACE cert that is with it.
HOF auto collector - I'm up to 258 different in my collection (used to have a photobucket link here, but photobucket sucks)
If you haven't already ask on Net54 which has many more people focused on this kind of thing.
Personally I'd leave out of the info if the COA so as not to bias the perspectives, though for your own knowledge remember that this is not a company with a great reputation, and the value of a rare autograph like that is much much higher with authentication for a reliable source (which should make you skeptical).
Sent from my iPhone using Freedom Card Board
JSA is around every month and sometimes multiple times per. If I see the rep I will at least show him and get some sort of opinion on it for you.
Sent from my SM-G920V using Freedom Card Board mobile app
ALWAYS LOOKING FOR ODDBALL, REGIONAL, TEAM ISSUED, VARIATIONS, AND TOUGH CARDS OF WILL CLARK AND MIKE BROWN
When asking real or fake on this I would definitely not say it has ace certification.
TopNotch is right.
Thanks everyone for their input. I guess I screwed up by saying it came with the ACE cert, because I was looking to see if I should get an opinion from PSA on this. I submitted this with JSA at a show a while back. They actually told me they wanted more time to review the piece as some of their people believed it could be authentic. However, it ultimately failed. I guess it will go back into my collection and I'll just keep thinking that there is a chance it's real.
Was this you who asked about the same cut autograph in 2015, or the previous owner?
Set builder, autograph hunter and fan of the Texas Rangers & '50s-'60s Yankees
Edgar Gonzalez Collection: - the 1/1's: 108/111 (97.3%) Have 12 1/1s out of 29
Jorge Cantu Collection: 487 / 688 (70.78%), 58 1/1s (14 non plates)
- the 1/1's: 429/443 (96.84%)
Total Mexican Collection: 4,326
Mexican autographs: 129/130 and on baseballs 118/130
This was me. I didn't get any help on that site.
The "MIGHTY " has spoken . trust his wisdom on this field
I'd love for it to be real but I think there are less than 20 known Old Hoss Radbourne signatures in the world. I wouldn't touch one without full letters from PSA, JSA, and Ron Keurajian. Even then there's a good chance it was stolen from a public institution.
His autographs are so rare they make Christy Mathewson auto's look as common as Bob Feller.
Mariano Rivera Super Collector. Always buying rare Mo's - PSA's, Auto's, Patches, Printing Plates, or any other rare Mo's. I PAY MORE THAN ANYONE FOR MARIANO'S I NEED.