- Thread starter
- #1
Topnotchsy
Featured Contributor, The best players in history?
- Aug 7, 2008
- 9,448
- 176
I recently bought a 2010 Chris Sale BC Gold Ref BGS 9.5. It cost $1000+ so definitely not a cheap piece. When I got the card in the mail I was really surprised to see the BGS case completely beaten up as the pictures below show.
I went back to the listing and these were the pictures in the listing. Based on the way the bottom half of the back is cut off etc. it seems like he was intentionally trying to hide the damage.
I reached out to the seller whos response was “replacing the case is $5 and I’d be happy to take the item as a return and sell it for more.
Both the seller and I know that the card has gone up in the week or so since I won it. To me though that doesn’t provide any defense for using images that hide damage that impacts what the sale price would have been.
I’ve been trying to decide what to leave him regarding feedback, both in rating and the comment and would appreciate perspectives.
Sent from my iPhone using Freedom Card Board
I went back to the listing and these were the pictures in the listing. Based on the way the bottom half of the back is cut off etc. it seems like he was intentionally trying to hide the damage.
I reached out to the seller whos response was “replacing the case is $5 and I’d be happy to take the item as a return and sell it for more.
Both the seller and I know that the card has gone up in the week or so since I won it. To me though that doesn’t provide any defense for using images that hide damage that impacts what the sale price would have been.
I’ve been trying to decide what to leave him regarding feedback, both in rating and the comment and would appreciate perspectives.
Sent from my iPhone using Freedom Card Board
