Edit: Figured it out. The lineup and opponent match up perfectly to who they played in 2011 on this date. Have 2 different games of these and they both show 2010 but match up with 2011. Funny that they didn't realize.
It is hard to tell from the picture but is says "April 9, 2010." The correct date was April 9, 2011.
Sent from my iPhone using Freedom Card Board