Mark McGwire Collector's Thread

Big Mac McGwire · Oct 6, 2010

17ROCKIES12 said:
I'm sure most of you have seen this, but here is an IP auto I got this year

I should be able to make it to 9 Cardinals games next year, so I'm hoping to get at least one more.
Things I want signed
1) 1991 Topps (for my set)
2) Something from the 1998 All Star Game in Colorado
3) Ticket from when I saw him play in '98

awsome!

jam92102 · Oct 7, 2010

jam92102 said:
Anybody interested? $70 shipped or best offer

Too much???

Big Mac McGwire · Oct 12, 2010

Any one get a sport for the McGwire signing coming up?

i got my order in early for 5 cards, 1 GU bat and 16x20

The signing was for 300 items and sold out in 5 days.

tonsofcommons · Oct 12, 2010

Any of you Big Mac studs have a 2000 Pacific Invincible Wild Vinyl serial number /10?

onionring9 · Oct 12, 2010

tonsofcommons said:
Any of you Big Mac studs have a 2000 Pacific Invincible Wild Vinyl serial number /10?

I think Jay got that one in one of the collection breakups. Still looking for one myself!

Mark McGwire Museum · Oct 12, 2010

tonsofcommons said:
Any of you Big Mac studs have a 2000 Pacific Invincible Wild Vinyl serial number /10?

I think I have that card. I know I have a 2000 Pacific /10 that has tie dye effect printed on what I assume is vinyl. Let me look around for it and I'll post a picture.

Krom · Oct 12, 2010

Had this posted in a Pujols thread but figured it might fit here.

Mark McGwire Museum · Oct 12, 2010

Krom said:
Had this posted in a Pujols thread but figured it might fit here.

I can't speak for the other autographs, but the McGwire is fake. Sorry

Krom · Oct 12, 2010

I have alot of Mac autos and this looks like every one i have seen, except obvious fakes. Show me an authentic Mac auto in thick paint pen that different.
Edit, i am more sure of the Pujols and Edmonds being real than anything and the Kyle is similar to others i have seen. It was only $100 so its worth sending it off to psa just to be sure, and for that $ if the Mac was fake and the Pujols alone was real its still worth more than cost.

Mark McGwire Museum · Oct 12, 2010

Krom said:
I have alot of Mac autos and this looks like every one i have seen, except obvious fakes. Show me an authentic Mac auto in thick paint pen that different.

I can and I will, I just have to search through my pictures.
I also know it won't matter; it's amazing what people can't see when they don't want to. I'm not trying to rain on your parade, but that's not even really a good forgery at that. Some HUGE red flags, no matter how many McGwire auto's you have or what medium they are signed on, doesn't pertain to this particular signed piece.

Big Mac McGwire · Oct 12, 2010

Like Museum said, your Mac is fake.

Here is a REAL McGwire in Paint Pen done at a private signing in July.

Big Mac McGwire · Oct 12, 2010

Big Mac McGwire said:
Like Museum said, your Mac is fake.

Here is a REAL McGwire in Paint Pen done at a private signing in July.

Here are 2 other mcgwire signed helmets. Both Mini helmets.

Mark McGwire Museum · Oct 12, 2010

Krom · Oct 12, 2010

Mark McGwire Museum said:
Krom said:

I have alot of Mac autos and this looks like every one i have seen, except obvious fakes. Show me an authentic Mac auto in thick paint pen that different.

Click to expand...

I can and I will, I just have to search through my pictures.
I also know it won't matter; it's amazing what people can't see when they don't want to. I'm not trying to rain on your parade, but that's not even really a good forgery at that. Some HUGE red flags, no matter how many McGwire auto's you have or what medium they are signed on, doesn't pertain to this particular signed piece.

I am not saying your wrong. But i have seen authentic autos of players that rushed and signed on the feild compared to any other time. You can see the Edmonds on the side and if you have ever seen his sig enough you can tell thats real, so like i said i dont mind having it looked over by psa.

Big Mac McGwire · Oct 12, 2010

Were not trying to bust your balls dude, but trust us, All we collect is MCGWIRE. I have close to 300 McGwire autographs. I have been collecting him for 20 years. That autograph is a fake.

Steiner sports signed helmet. In Silver Paint.

The M in McGwire is bad as well as that "E" at the end which he NEVER puts out.

Big Mac McGwire · Oct 12, 2010

Yea alot of players Rush, Here are some signatures of "Rushed" McGwire Autographs. And i know they were rushed because i got them in hords of people at the ballpark.

Mark McGwire Museum · Oct 12, 2010

Krom said:
I am not saying your wrong. But i have seen authentic autos of players that rushed and signed on the feild compared to any other time. You can see the Edmonds on the side and if you have ever seen his sig enough you can tell thats real, so like i said i dont mind having it looked over by psa.

That's cool about the other sig's, and I hope for your sake they are real, and somebody just tried to add a Mac to it.

On the other hand, show me ANY authentic McGwire signature, rushed or not, that has the whole 2nd M in the k loop. Also show me any (doesn't even have to be the same one, because it doesn't exist) that has a cursive E at the end. I'm tired of doing the work. Your turn, just show me those two things above. Never mind the handful of other things wrong wrong wrong with that signature.

When McGwire "rushes" you get a ballpark sig. He doesn't take every instinctual and subconscious writing habit he has and throw it out the window. Nobody does.

Krom · Oct 12, 2010

I got ya. Still hopeing tha Pujols is real, have had a few rc Pujols autos and it looks good to me, but hey some fakes are better tahn others, even 100% fake at $100 is a cheap gamble. When i first started buying autos on the bay i paid 100 each for a cobb cut (way fake now that i know better) an Ott thats fake too, but a Paul Waner hitting booklet that i sold for about 300, and a Tris cut that i thought was altered but found out it was just a water stain and affected the ink and sold that for about 300 also. The Lajoie in my sig also was 100 and have looked at every one authenticated on the bay for years and would bet thats good. Just wanted to say i am never upset to find an auto fake, i am in the + too far to worry. Also bought an unauthenticated 1918 tigers ball a while back with 12 or so sigs w/ Cobb and Jennings for 2000. Later sold to one of the bigger auction houses (Heritage or something like that) for 3500 cash. Really regret the sale but that was a good profit. Thanks for the heads up.

tonsofcommons · Oct 12, 2010

I would LOVE to see a scan of the Wild Vinyl. And that is exactly what you have.

Thank you in advance!!!

Mark McGwire Museum · Oct 12, 2010

When you see something signed in paint pen, you need to be extra careful and scrutinize it even closer. A lot of forgers like using them because they can sign 75% slower without it being evident, which makes it easier for them to get a close copy of what they are forging. The paint pens also hide the overlapping pen strokes, which hides even more clues to the authenticity.

Also, another collector-to-collector warning. Pujols' signature is amazingly easy to forge, especially the older style as most guys write with a right slant naturally. There's a lot of money to be made practicing Pujols signature a couple hours a day, and some of these scumbags do. Provenance is king.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Mark McGwire Collector's Thread

New member

New member

New member

Active member

Active member

Member

New member

Member

New member

Member

New member

New member

Member

New member

New member

New member

Member

New member

Active member

Member

Similar threads

Log in