Tulowitzki is pretty healthy and looking at being back from the DL next week - if he has no other problems w/the rib he'll start the AS game.
Welcome to our community
Be apart of something great, join today!
Guess It's Up to Us to Vote in Puig
- Thread starter Jaypers
- Start date
Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
alwayson22
Member
Absolutely!
aarne13
Active member
Steve Delabar for me. 
I just don't think Puig has enough playing time. He will prob win the vote though.
I just don't think Puig has enough playing time. He will prob win the vote though.
HPC
New member
Why is it unfortunate?
This is the fans turn to pick the player they want in the game. If Puig gets in, then the majority of fans want him there.
I dont understand the attitude towards the All Star game. Until Selig added the home field stip, it was a completely meaningless game.
The game is a popularity contest and every year guys who deserve to be there over guys who are going get snubbed.
It's just like the Pro Bowl; guys dont put in 100% effort. No superstar wants to be known as the guy who tore his ucl pitching an inning in the All Star game.
No one has been hotter than Puig these past 30-odd games and he absolutely deserves to be there for the NL.
alwayson22
Member
Frankly, the whole notion of picking All-Stars based on half of one season is ridiculous.
chompsmcgee
New member
It's an All-Star exhibition, not the Hall of Fame. Who is more exciting for me to watch battle against the AL's elite - Puig, a couple meh 1Bs, the most awkward guy in baseball, or Ian Desmond? I voted manbearpuig.
hockeyfights
Active member
If Puig should get in based on 30 days, then Justin Upton should be on the team for his April and part of May and you could throw Gattis in there too.
- Thread starter
- #48
Keith Law said it best in his latest blog --
"As for the question of the week, I come down in favor of including Yasiel Puig in the All-Star Game, despite his scant time in the majors. The purpose of this event is to market the sport to a wider audience, and I've argued for a long time that doing so should mean including one or two young/rising stars in each league who may not qualify until we take their age or potential into consideration.
Even if you think Jose Fernandez is a bit of a reach this year, he's a strong choice because he's a rising star, just 20 years old and one of the top 15-20 starters in the league already. Puig won't hit .400 the rest of the year, of course, but he's showing a ton of ability, he's an exciting player, and he's already got all of baseball -- including the casual fans MLB is trying to hook further through this game -- talking about him.
Adding Puig to the NL roster to join Fernandez while putting a top rookie, such as Oswaldo Arcia (hitting .283/.347/.451 at age 22 this year for Minnesota), on the AL roster alongside emerging star Manny Machado would help broaden the game's interest while showcasing part of the next generation of MLB superstars. After all, it only counts if people watch."
"As for the question of the week, I come down in favor of including Yasiel Puig in the All-Star Game, despite his scant time in the majors. The purpose of this event is to market the sport to a wider audience, and I've argued for a long time that doing so should mean including one or two young/rising stars in each league who may not qualify until we take their age or potential into consideration.
Even if you think Jose Fernandez is a bit of a reach this year, he's a strong choice because he's a rising star, just 20 years old and one of the top 15-20 starters in the league already. Puig won't hit .400 the rest of the year, of course, but he's showing a ton of ability, he's an exciting player, and he's already got all of baseball -- including the casual fans MLB is trying to hook further through this game -- talking about him.
Adding Puig to the NL roster to join Fernandez while putting a top rookie, such as Oswaldo Arcia (hitting .283/.347/.451 at age 22 this year for Minnesota), on the AL roster alongside emerging star Manny Machado would help broaden the game's interest while showcasing part of the next generation of MLB superstars. After all, it only counts if people watch."
uniquebaseballcards
New member
- Nov 12, 2008
- 6,783
- 0
He's not necessarily stating the purpose of the AS game but rather his own purpose at ESPN - which is to market and sell stuff. The more others 'buy into' sports marketing the easier his own job becomes. He may not even care about Puig or the future.
Its difficult to think that those whose responsibility to sell stuff always have the public's best interests at heart, wouldn't you agree... ?
This whole thing will be a lot more interesting to look at and dissect... in several months.
hockeyfights
Active member
It was a great thing to hear on the Braves TV broadcast just now. Joe Simpson just ripped ESPN for pimping Puig on their website.
arhodge13
New member
I've thoroughly enjoyed reading through this thread. Lots of strong opinions regarding whether or not Puig should be including in the All-Star game, so I might as well weigh in. I've voted for Puig and will continue to do so.
I won't sit here and argue that he deserves to play based on tenure or merit. He clearly doesn't. However, he's a rising star who's exciting to watch. If the fans want to see him go to the All-Star game, why not? It's not like he's up for a trip to Cooperstown. I won't try to convince anyone to change their mind (since Freeman et al each deserve the final roster spot), but I'll continue to support including a guy who will perhaps make a few more casual fans tune in to watch.
I won't sit here and argue that he deserves to play based on tenure or merit. He clearly doesn't. However, he's a rising star who's exciting to watch. If the fans want to see him go to the All-Star game, why not? It's not like he's up for a trip to Cooperstown. I won't try to convince anyone to change their mind (since Freeman et al each deserve the final roster spot), but I'll continue to support including a guy who will perhaps make a few more casual fans tune in to watch.
markakis8
Active member
- Oct 31, 2008
- 12,081
- 2
e_t_f84
New member
- Jan 13, 2013
- 30
- 0
What's the cutoff for games played? I wasn't able to find that in the ASG rules so curious to know what is considered enough to make someone eligible.
uniquebaseballcards
New member
- Nov 12, 2008
- 6,783
- 0
? Not sure why your statement applies here given apples are being compared to apples, but we know Markakis is 100% right.
It's a simple question. What is the cutoff for enough games to qualify for the game?
BluesBroSJ
New member
Considering it determines home field advantage for the world series, it is not considered an exhibition. Give me Freeman. Through his first 23 games you know who Puig is not as good as? Jeff Francoeur.
ronniedp23
New member
Am I alone in thinking giving home field advantage this way is beyond idiotic? Personally I think HFA should be determined by the team with the better record, or the higher seeded team, but that's just me.
Sent from my DROID RAZR using Freedom Card Board mobile app
RiceLynnEvans75
Active member
Going to vote in someone else. I don't believe he belongs.
Similar threads
