- Thread starter
- #41
Welcome to our community
Be apart of something great, join today!
Keith Law's Top 100 Prospects of 2013
- Thread starter Jaypers
- Start date
Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
Nt saying he isn't much of anything. I'm saying I don't see the bat. Im saying i dont see how he is a top prospect. I pointed out a less heralded, though still MLB quality, player who at the same age and same level put up better numbers and did not improve on them much as he went up a level, as Lindor will as well.
I apologize for buttressing my arguments with available data. I'm well aware he was drafted high, and why. I'm suggesting that the pedigree (champion dogs have pedigrees, players have scouting reports, unles their father s an MLBer). You referred to might have been incorrect, or that the available data calls it in to question.
All The Hype
Active member
I asked about Lindor by basically posing the topic we're discussing here, but he didn't really answer the question with any substance other than simply saying he has more than just a glove so his response wasn't helpful.
Talking with the scout I associate with told me Lindor could hit 15-20 a year in his prime. Also said to me that Profar could be a Jeter with more range.
The guy I saw with Paulino is Robinson Cano. He can stick at 2nd IMO.
shayscards79
New member
Did you have the list posted?
- Thread starter
- #47
Use the link in the OP and scroll down - you should be able to see the list. Scouting reports require an Insider subscription.
EDIT - Evidently, things have changed since this morning, when it could be seen for free. Now it requires a subscription to be viewed. If you can't see it, shoot me a PM.
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- #49
He didn't.
shayscards79
New member
heh... wondering if he has word of something deeper and isnt telling us. mostly because of his favorable ranking of Sanchez, the guy toronto kept, and then synder, the guy they let go.
hive17
Active member
- Aug 7, 2008
- 21,426
- 24
What was it, if you don't mind.
MadHandle11
Member
Never had a high ceiling to begin with. Subpar stats. Lazy.
All The Hype
Active member
Yeah that pretty much summed up his explanation. Said he doesn't even have a case for the top 100 because he plays with no energy.
Which is funny because Law himself had Arenado ranked 26th overall last year.
ballerskrip
New member
Lindor is 19 /12, not 18. Just pointing that out. You can say baez has holes, that is possible. I personally don't see "a bunch of holes" in his swing. I can tell you that Giancarlo Stanton has holes in swing, and I don't see that being argued.
If you want to do an over/under of Lindor's career high in Homeruns, I would take UNDER 20, for say $500 and not blink twice. Watch this tiny little dude play, and show me way the power is coming from. Its not there, and is NOT going to be there.
If you want to do an over/under of Lindor's career high in Homeruns, I would take UNDER 20, for say $500 and not blink twice. Watch this tiny little dude play, and show me way the power is coming from. Its not there, and is NOT going to be there.
Last edited:
All The Hype
Active member
Can an Insider tell me how many Astros made the list?
I'm sure Correa, Singleton, and Springer did. Not sure about DeShields, Cosart, or Foltynewicz. Jaypers already said no McCullers.
The thing that's blowing my mind is Robbie Grossman at 105. He doesn't crack the BA Top 10 list (and Domingo Santana is probably #11 on that list) - so how does he crack the Top 110 in this list?
I'm sure Correa, Singleton, and Springer did. Not sure about DeShields, Cosart, or Foltynewicz. Jaypers already said no McCullers.
The thing that's blowing my mind is Robbie Grossman at 105. He doesn't crack the BA Top 10 list (and Domingo Santana is probably #11 on that list) - so how does he crack the Top 110 in this list?
yrocks2001
New member
- Jan 24, 2011
- 347
- 0
Thanks yrocks2001.
That makes Robbie Grossman the 6th best Astros prospect according to Keith Law. Ahead of Folty, Lance McCullers Jr, Rio Ruiz, and Domingo Santana. I'm pretty sure Keith Law is nuts here, but I'm happy that the Astros have so much depth to their system.
PadresFan86
New member
What proven major leauger does Rymer Liriano compare to if he were to reach his ceiling?
Sent from my HUAWEI-M920 using Freedom Card Board mobile app
Sent from my HUAWEI-M920 using Freedom Card Board mobile app
Similar threads
