Topps Replacement Mailday...Accept or Reject

[joker8334]

Gonna try posting on a new topic. I got these cards from Topps today as replacements for overdue redemptions. Wondering if people think I should accept or reject them?

(1) Card Owed: 2011 Topps Chrome Black Refractor Auto of Freddie Freeman /100
Card Substituted: 2010 Bowman Sterling Black Refractor Auto of Peter Tago 18/25
*Strange bc I previously redeemed and rec'd another Freeman Black Auto and I see others on eBay



(2) Card Owed: 2011 Topps Supreme Autographed Jumbo Patch Relic of Von Miller /10
Card Substituted: 2010 Bowman Sterling Gold Refractor Patch Auto of Eric Berry 20/25



My thought is to definitely send back the Eric Berry, but Im on the fence about Peter Tago. On a side note, I have only sent back a replacement once before and it was a HUGE headache but it ended up paying off really well. I was owed a 2011 Allen & Ginter 1/1 Book Card of Robinson Cano and Dan Uggla that was supposed to have a bat barrel and full team patch. (I was actually devastated that I never rec'd this one). Plus they sent me junk, so after going back and forth a dozen times and about 40 emails with various Topps executives I finally ended up with:

2011 Bowman Platinum Bryce Harper Blue Auto /99
2011 Bowman Chrome Bryce Harper Base Auto
2011 Topps Chrome Eric Hosmer Base Auto (SP)
2011 Marquee Manny Pacquiao Auto
2007 Topps Sterling Auto Triple Relic Albert Pujols 05/10
2007 Triple Threads White Whale Auto/Relic Dan Marino

 

[MojoDan]

I'd certainly be happy with the 6 card replacement package. Congrats!

 

[alexs64]

Yeah the 6 card payback was good, but the two singles up there...not so good IMO.

 

[mlbsalltimegreats]

Anytime you end up with Albert Pujols and Dan Marino autos as replacements for guys who havent really done squat in the Mlb i think is a no brainer and a huge win for you! Nice replacements.

 

[vwnut13]

Anytime you end up with Albert Pujols and Dan Marino autos as replacements for guys who havent really done squat in the Mlb i think is a no brainer and a huge win for you! Nice replacements.

sigh.

 

[chipperjfan10]

thats weird thats eric deckers auto not eric berrys

 

[alexs64]

Anytime you end up with Albert Pujols and Dan Marino autos as replacements for guys who havent really done squat in the Mlb i think is a no brainer and a huge win for you! Nice replacements.

The replacements list is from a different send back. Not the 2 card send back he is talking about, bud.

 

[joker8334]

thats weird thats eric deckers auto not eric berrys

Great spot! I didnt even notice that. They put eric decker sticker on eric berry card and send as replacement. Well done Topps. Thanks for pointing out!

 

[Mahoody]

That is definately Eric Decker's auto on that Eric Berry card - :lol: wonderful job Topps

I'd email topps and get different replacements for both cards.

 

[mlbsalltimegreats]

The replacements list is from a different send back. Not the 2 card send back he is talking about, bud.

Thanks for the clarification, now i need to buy the book for dummies on " how to read " :lol: with that said i have no idea what he should do. Good luck to the poster.

 

[alabamalongsnake]

tago for freddie freeman. what a joke. send them both back and ask for a XXXX ton more

 

[joker8334]

tago for freddie freeman. what a joke. send them both back and ask for a XXXX ton more

Done. Thanks for advice...I appreciate the input. Will let you know what happens.