The all-time best pull of your lifetime thread

smapdi · Feb 17, 2016

My main time for opening packs or boxes was in the early 90s when they were more economical and there really weren't any big hits to find. What was the big pull in 1993 Leaf or 1994 Upper Deck (edit: oh yeah, the Mantle/Griffey autos. Never got any of those)? Probably my best pull was either a 1993 BBM Hideo Nomo from 1998 Bowman (1:3250 packs or so), a 500 Goal Club stick card of Mike Gartner(?) (I can't even remember who, but I sold it for $100), or a President's Edition #/10 of Russell Branyan from 1998 SP Top Prospects. As boxes got more expensive, and the powerball cards more valuable, I had less and less luck. No mortgage-payment type cards, just cheap cards, according to the odds. Strangely, I would have decent luck buying a random pack here and there, pulling a $20 card from 1 or 2 $4 packs, but that's it. This continues with Magic, which is my foil-wrapped crack of choice for the past few years.

Oh, but how could I forget this extremely profitable trip to the card shop:

I really should have sold that laPorta.

klute14 · Feb 17, 2016

Pulled this from a $200 case of the product. It sold within minutes after listing for $600 to a buyer from Japan. It was his first Certified Auto.

Pulled this from a box. If I recall, it sold for a little more then $200.

Also pulled this from a box. I was offered $800 for it and foolishly turned it down, instead going the auction route. I ended up getting $600+. Not a bad haul but what could have been.....

All In Cards · Feb 17, 2016

here is a pic of the MJ

lonesomeagle1 · Feb 17, 2016

WCTYSON · Feb 17, 2016

jbhofmann · Feb 17, 2016

First GU card I ever pulled. 2001 my first year back into the game. 1 pack at the shop of my childhood.

The hook not only was set, but ripped my entire face off.

/100

Still a very very strong card. Last sold for $500 on eBay (none right now).

Dazed · Feb 17, 2016

Some of my favorites. Sorry for the different sizes. Apparently I don't know what I'm doing!

Dilferules · Feb 17, 2016

I don't open that much and have never hit a GIANT card, the most valuable was a 1999 Stadium Club Peyton Manning/Tim Couch (remember him?) Co-Signers that I sold for $200. I have pulled several $100-175 cards in the last 5 years but nothing to top that.

DeliciousBacon · Feb 17, 2016

I pulled a Byron Buxton auto /50 from a 2013 Bowman Chrome Blue Wave pack, and a Joey Gallo Purple Ref auto /10 from a 2012 Bowman Draft jumbo (bought two packs at the store that day). Sold both for $500. Next best was a Pujols auto /10 from some 2014 Topps subset (don't even remember what it was), that one went for over $400 on ebay. Scans are long gone, but their legacies live on in the great cards I was able to buy with the money.

death2redemptions · Feb 17, 2016

WCTYSON said:

Dayum, there was a time when that card was worth some serious coin. Still a good prospect with potential but I remember when his base autos were going for $50+.

olerudfan · Feb 17, 2016

Hockey: 2006 The Cup Alex Ovechkin RC Gold RPA /8
Basketball: 2012 Lebron Gold Prizm 6/10 (jsy#)
Golf: 2013 SPGU Edition Supreme Gear Tiger Woods Glove Patch Nike Swoosh (/3)
Football: 2012 RGIII Black Prizm RC 1/1
Baseball: Tie between 2002 SP Legendary Cuts Priority Signing Redemption of Mcgwire and 2008 Topps Triple Threads Legends Saphire Booklet 1/3 Ruth/Gehrig/Williams/Mantle/Cobb/Dimaggio

gogosox40 · Feb 17, 2016

I have a few big money pulls.

I just got back into collecting in 2007. I used to collect when I was a kind collecting in the late 80's early 90's and knew nothing about it.
Bought a few packs from the LCS of 2007 SP Authentic and pulled a redemption for the Derek Jeter Complete Name Set #/2
I redeemed the redemption and wound up getting #1 /2. I sold it at a local card show for $2,225. That money helped pay for my wedding.

Next Big Pull was a 2010 Bowman Chrome USA Manny Machado Superfractor. Pulled from the last 4 packs at a local LCS.
Sold it at auction for $1,225.00 to Wossa.

The last exciting Big Pull was a 2010 Bowman Sterling Jason Heyward Red Refractor Auto 1/1
Was at the local card show and opened one box of bowman sterling and pulled it.
Later sold it on ebay for around $1,100?? I dont remember.

WCTYSON · Feb 17, 2016

death2redemptions said:
Dayum, there was a time when that card was worth some serious coin. Still a good prospect with potential but I remember when his base autos were going for $50+.

I did not hold the card long.

Pinbreaker · Feb 17, 2016

I still have this one..

I sold this one for $1600

I sold this one for $800

jpcz · Feb 17, 2016

George_Calfas · Feb 17, 2016

Pinbreaker said:
I still have this one..

:thumbsup:

death2redemptions · Feb 17, 2016

WCTYSON said:
I did not hold the card long.

lol, good for you! I would have also but then again, I'm the guy who sold the Kershaw superfractor the moment I pulled it

WCTYSON · Feb 17, 2016

death2redemptions said:
lol, good for you! I would have also but then again, I'm the guy who sold the Kershaw superfractor the moment I pulled it

Right, I mean who knows how it will turn out but as of right now I feel good about moving it when I did and for how much.

16christensen16 · Feb 17, 2016

I was lucky enough to pull the prime cuts "Ruth" card. And it just happened to be the patch version

gvsu96 · Feb 17, 2016

Pulled this ripping a case of update. Best part was having a bunch of members here watching the U stream while I was breaking.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

The all-time best pull of your lifetime thread

Well-known member

Active member

Super Moderator

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

New member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

New member

Attachments

Active member

Similar threads

Log in