2007 BC Trevor Cahill Orange Ref Auto - Hold longer or sell?

TonyB74 · Mar 5, 2009

I own this card. There is one listed right now but I haven't seen too many on ebay in the last several months. I've received an offer of $250 to sell the card offline and I'm torn whether to sell now or it has more potential to increase in value. I'm thinking that it has reached his peak and Cahill is an A's prospect so I can't see the card climbing that much higher especially because he isn't really a strikeout pitcher. Thoughts?

sheetskout · Mar 6, 2009

HOLD!

At the very least Cahill is sure to go to AAA to begin the season and is more than capable of being a repeat show on BA's hotlist to begin the season.

There's no reasonable way to think that Cahill has even hit a peak value yet. His stuff has been SOOOOOO undervalued thus far.

All The Hype · Mar 6, 2009

I think it could go higher.

I have a refractor auto of his that I'm sitting on. It's currently worth 30-40 but I think it will get up in the 50s this season. Obviously it's not as risky for me to sit on a 30 dollar card as it is for you to sit on a 250 dollar card, but I really think he's stuff will continue to climb a little bit further. Also, he was the #11 prospect on baseball america's top 100. Not that that means anything, but just a little FYI in case you didn't know.

Good luck either way man

brouthercard · Mar 6, 2009

I sold my orange a couple of months ago for $225. I think $250 is a good price.

darocker80 · Mar 6, 2009

hold unless you need money to buy some weiterse, heyward, bumgarner stuff

southeastjerome · Mar 6, 2009

I sold a raw gold for 300 dollars on a Best offer right at the end of august. I would hold

card-treasury · Mar 6, 2009

Cahill is a complete stud. As good as he has been in the minors, he is still undervalued. I own nothing. I completely missed the boat on Cahill, depressed after my snipe for the superfractor failed to launch.

southeastjerome · Mar 6, 2009

I Agree with you mike Cahill is a stud and still under priced.

Also i was after the Cahill Superfractor for a long time and when it finally showed up i offered the guy 650 dollars but he could not pull the trigger and would let it run. My bid was not even close and i was shocked it went for over a Grand. Does anyone know who won that card i have not seen it since and what do you guys think it is worth now 2800 ?

card-treasury · Mar 6, 2009

southeastjerome said:
I Agree with you mike Cahill is a stud and still under priced.

Also i was after the Cahill Superfractor for a long time and when it finally showed up i offered the guy 650 dollars but he could not pull the trigger and would let it run. My bid was not even close and i was shocked it went for over a Grand. Does anyone know who won that card i have not seen it since and what do you guys think it is worth now 2800 ?

I have no idea what it would fetch, but I believe it went for $1,200 give or take a couple.

southeastjerome · Mar 6, 2009

ya it did your right.

jlvjr16 · Mar 6, 2009

I actually sold my Cahills last year while hot and regret not buying more.

I made about $90 in profits. Sold 4 base chrome autos and two refractors autos.

MOFNY · Mar 6, 2009

I'll give you $200 paypal for it today...

muchuckwagon · Mar 6, 2009

MOFNY said:
I'll give you $200 paypal for it today...

The OP says he has current offer for $250....why would he take $200 from you?

thefasterblade · Mar 6, 2009

I have one of these too, I am and will hold it until I get my offer.

TonyB74 · Apr 19, 2009

I'm still debating whether to sell this now or hold longer now that Cahill has a couple of starts under his belt in the majors. I have an offline offer of $200 but I'm torn as to whether to accept it.

Ian Stewart · Apr 19, 2009

darocker80 said:
hold unless you need money to buy some weiterse, heyward, bumgarner stuff

Every single player you named is near their peak in value except maybe Heyward.

Nice.

miguelcabrera · Apr 19, 2009

Ian Stewart said:
darocker80 said:

hold unless you need money to buy some weiterse, heyward, bumgarner stuff

Click to expand...

Every single player you named is near their peak in value except maybe Heyward.

Nice.

did you sell all your miggys?

darocker80 · Apr 19, 2009

Ian Stewart said:
darocker80 said:

hold unless you need money to buy some weiterse, heyward, bumgarner stuff

Click to expand...

Every single player you named is near their peak in value except maybe Heyward.

Nice.

that was a while ago, i say sell on his first win.

darocker80 · Apr 19, 2009

darocker80 said:
Ian Stewart said:

darocker80 said:

hold unless you need money to buy some weiterse, heyward, bumgarner stuff

Click to expand...

Every single player you named is near their peak in value except maybe Heyward.

Nice.

Click to expand...

that was a while ago smart one, i say sell on his first win.

If he sold then he wouldn't be able to have a card at its peak right now..

aw00d05 · Apr 19, 2009

Hold, if he pitches on national TV or just has a great start that ESPN talks about just a little it'll definately go up, or if Gammons/Olney talk about how great he is too.

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

2007 BC Trevor Cahill Orange Ref Auto - Hold longer or sell?

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Similar threads

Log in