Quick player collector question

nyc3 · Oct 8, 2008

My pal collects basically one player, which do you think he would rather have a gold ref or that players first minor league ticket stub (but its a full ticket). They are about the same price so I am torn, now the gold ref is not a rc so its not like big time $$ I just need to add a bit more to his birthday gift. Thank you

ee10 · Oct 8, 2008

Is he primarily a card collector of said player? or does he collect anything?

For me, I think the ticket stub would be the way to go.

nyc3 · Oct 8, 2008

ee10 said:
Is he primarily a card collector of said player? or does he collect anything?

For me, I think the ticket stub would be the way to go.

Great question sadly I haven't got a clue :lol: It's been a while since I seen his collection but what I seen its mostly cards. I just figured it would be cool to get signed, but thats what I would want :lol:

ee10 · Oct 8, 2008

I'm the same way...a signed ticket stub is great for the collection. Although it's not signed yet, he always has the chance. Even if it doesn't get signed, it's a cool piece of memorabilia.

wolfmanalfredo · Oct 8, 2008

ee10 said:
Is he primarily a card collector of said player? or does he collect anything?

For me, I think the ticket stub would be the way to go.

I agree! As a fellow player collector, I would like that little piece of history.

onionring9 · Oct 8, 2008

Depends on what he collects. I'd personally prefer the gold ref if I didn't have it. But thats because I only collect cards!

gracecollector · Oct 8, 2008

Man, I really got excited last year when I finally found a ticket stub from Grace's first game. And it was a torn stub not in great condition. It was easily one of my favorite purchases of the year, and much more satisfying than a low-numbered card I would have a good chance of finding again in the future. I vote for the stub.

pujolsjunkie · Oct 8, 2008

Go with the ticket. The card will present itself more often.

nyc3 · Oct 8, 2008

Stub it is! thank you guys for helping.

onionring9 · Oct 8, 2008

pujolsjunkie said:
Go with the ticket. The card will present itself more often.

thats a really good point

Zambrano38 · Oct 8, 2008

Get the ticket for sure. i was so happy when I got 4 full tickets from Zambrano 1st game

I sure he will love the ticket!!

Welcome to our community

Be apart of something great, join today!

Quick player collector question

Which would you rather have

A non rc Gold Refractor

That players first game played ticket stub

nyc3

Active member

ee10

New member

nyc3

Active member

ee10

New member

wolfmanalfredo

Active member

onionring9

Active member

gracecollector

Well-known member

pujolsjunkie

New member

nyc3

Active member

onionring9

Active member

Zambrano38

New member

Similar threads

Members online

Latest posts