Rolling the Dice (PSA/DNA Style)

[Mighty Bombjack]

For what it's worth, I agree that the HOF sigs on the back look legit. Very cool piece, clubhouse sigs on the front or not.

 

[cjedmonton]

Okay, case closed. PSA has confirmed that the entire front are clubhouse signatures. The good news is that the entire back is authentic (Cy Young, Bill Dinneen, Tom Connolly, Fred Clarke are the highlights). Should have no trouble breaking even.

Thanks for following along.

 

[200lbhockeyplayer]

Well, it did nothing more than confirm some suspicions about the front...the best part...the assumptions that the back was real. A great piece for sure. And it works out well that the back is all good, so it can be displayed as such. I think it's annoying when it's a mix of good and bad on the same side.

Okay, case closed. PSA has confirmed that the entire front are clubhouse signatures. The good news is that the entire back is authentic (Cy Young, Bill Dinneen, Tom Connolly, Fred Clarke are the highlights). Should have no trouble breaking even.

Thanks for following along.

 

[jbhofmann]

If you cut it up, send me a $ on the Young.

 

[cjedmonton]

I'm sorry, but that's not in the plans. This is still a fairly interesting/unique piece, so it's probably best to keep it intact.

I'm still debating on which venue is best, though (Ebay or consignment through an auction house).

 

[Sean_C]

Did you get the PSA/DNA letter with their notes about the authentic vs. clubhouse signatures? Also, dumb question but there aren't any signatures on the inside, correct? Personally, I'd list it on eBay rather than go through an auction house as long as you have the full PSA/DNA L of A. Otherwise, I'd suggest Clean Sweep, Hunt, or Huggins and Scott, as I know they will auction items that have a combination of clubhouse and authentic signatures (although I paid less than $400 for multi-signed ball featuring Connolly from CS).

 

[homerun28aa]

The front doesn't look great to me to be honest, but that Cy Young sig looks on point.

 

[Topnotchsy]

Okay, case closed. PSA has confirmed that the entire front are clubhouse signatures. The good news is that the entire back is authentic (Cy Young, Bill Dinneen, Tom Connolly, Fred Clarke are the highlights). Should have no trouble breaking even.

Thanks for following along.

Pity on the front but still some huge names there.

 

[Musial Collector]

Okay, case closed. PSA has confirmed that the entire front are clubhouse signatures. The good news is that the entire back is authentic (Cy Young, Bill Dinneen, Tom Connolly, Fred Clarke are the highlights). Should have no trouble breaking even.

Thanks for following along.

The front doesn't look great to me to be honest, but that Cy Young sig looks on point.

Wow who knew :lol:

 

[cjedmonton]

Did you get the PSA/DNA letter with their notes about the authentic vs. clubhouse signatures? Also, dumb question but there aren't any signatures on the inside, correct? Personally, I'd list it on eBay rather than go through an auction house as long as you have the full PSA/DNA L of A. Otherwise, I'd suggest Clean Sweep, Hunt, or Huggins and Scott, as I know they will auction items that have a combination of clubhouse and authentic signatures (although I paid less than $400 for multi-signed ball featuring Connolly from CS).

Yes, the full LOA is forthcoming, and will have full notes regarding the authentic vs. clubhouse sigs. It might even include their standard blurb regarding Charlie "The Brow" DiGiovanna and his prolific signing habits for Brooklyn back in the day.

The inside of the program is clean as a whistle. No markings of any kind.